Five before Midnight

This site is dedicated to the continuous oversight of the Riverside(CA)Police Department, which was formerly overseen by the state attorney general. This blog will hopefully play that role being free of City Hall's micromanagement.
"The horror of that moment," the King went on, "I shall never, never forget." "You will though," the Queen said, "if you don't make a memorandum of it." --Lewis Carroll

Contact: fivebeforemidnight@yahoo.com

My Photo
Name:
Location: RiverCity, Inland Empire

Thursday, November 19, 2009

The Robert Forman Trial: He said; She said and Joking about Women's Lingerie




Testimony continued in the ongoing trial of former Riverside Police Department officer Robert Forman who has been charged with three felonies of sexual misconduct under the color of authority. Riverside County Superior Court presiding judge, John Molloy apparently recovered from his illness convened court for the first time in a week. The court days are already cut shorter than usual because the trial is taking place inside the old civil courthouse and it's judges who are assigned to civil cases who are presiding over the trials. Which means that they hear a civil calendar until mid-morning and then switch over to conducting a criminal trial. Not exactly how they conduct business in most counties but then this is Riverside.

And sure enough on the tables, there aren't placards that read prosecution and defense but plaintiff and defendant. The jury seats are slightly more comfortable and the design of the courtroom is much different with fewer seats for the audience and no adjacent holding facilities for incustody inmates like in the newer building.

Not that this trial has exactly been packing the seats but a few people have dropped by to observe the proceedings of the latest trial involving a former law enforcement officer who is being prosecuted for alleged onduty crimes that took place between February and April 2008.


Sitting in the back of the room were Internal Affairs Division sergeants, Pat McCarthy and John Capen dressed in business suits along with Investigations Lt. Mike Perea who sat in for a while, as witnesses testified for the prosecution in this case. The presence of the Internal Affairs sergeants was duly noted by some of the parties in the case although the two sergeants remained silent during the proceedings even as people talked about them and pointed them out to the jury. Given how backlogged Internal Affairs is with its investigations, it's significant that the division is having two of its five sergeants spend the entire day sitting in a courtroom to testimony by several of the department's officers although it's probably a given that they're going to hang out at any venue where a police officer is providing a statement or being interviewed about an incident even if it's at the witness stand at a criminal trial. They weren't sure whether or not they'll be back on Monday.

And so with all that, another day of testimony began in the case of the People of the City of Riverside vs Officer Robert Forman.



The Ex-Trainee

Former officer, Megan (Edwards) Meyers took the stand and continued her testimony, much more composed than she had been a week earlier when she broke down on the witness stand and cried after three hours of testimony between lawyers from both sides who switched back and forth through out the afternoon as her account of the incident unfolded. Though it seemed that an admonition by Molloy about her testifying style set her off, she had been getting increasingly agitated and impatient as the day went on.

Meyers testified that she spoke with the reporting party and discovered that this individual had erroneously or falsely (and she was asked both during her testimony as if they were interchangeable) reported the call as a home invasion robbery. Meyers said she didn’t consider the victim in this case, a victim of a criminal action or involved in criminal behavior herself but somewhere in the middle. As such, she also testified that she didn’t hear anyone else threaten to arrest the victim at any point nor did she do it herself. Among the officers in that reference were Officer William Zackowski and Sgt. Paul De Jong.

At some point, some officers were standing near a dartboard in the living room posted by the kitchen door about eight feet away from Meyers and the victim. And so her testimony began about what's becoming the infamous lingerie incident. Not in itself a crime but something that took place only several hours before a crime was alleged to have taken place. An example of sexist behavior by officers on the scene of a crime just hours before an alleged act of sexual assault under the color of authority and thus testified about during the trial. At times, the testimony particularly by the current and former police officers seems to resemble an administrative proceeding of the lingerie incident as much as it does a criminal trial about an alleged sexual assault by a police officer.

As it turned out, it didn't appear that Meyers approved of this behavior by some of the male officers on the scene judging from comments that she made during her testimony even as she had some recollection issues.


“I saw lingerie on the dartboard,” Meyers recalled, “But I didn’t see who placed it.”


She said that she overheard an officer ask out loud if the lingerie belonged to the victim. Saying something like “Oh are these hers” in a joking fashion.


“I remember hearing them joking but I don’t remember who said it,” Meyers told the jury.



She said she remembered thinking that these guys are being “immature”. Fortunately, she apparently wasn't the only officer in the room who felt that this behavior was problematic as it turned out.

She was asked if Zackowski put the lingerie on the dartboard and she said she didn’t know who did it nor did she remember if he spoke with the victim. Under redirect by the prosecutor, Elan Zekster, she was asked about the relationship between Forman and Zackowski and she said she thought they were “pals” and that “they talked a lot”. Something Zackowski would later modify in his own testimony by saying that the belief existed that the two men were closer friends than they actually were.

Zekster asked her about when she, Forman and Zackowski had left the scene. One of them had gone back to the victim’s apartment to retrieve something and she said she wasn’t sure which officer. She just remembered walking with only one officer and then the second one coming back. Zekster made a reference to an interview she had given to police detectives where she had said her memory was fuzzy but when she thought about it later, she had believed it was Forman who had gone back to the apartment. Testimony which as it turned out would be contradicted by one of the other officers who had left the apartment with her.

Meyers was questioned a lot about why the victim, who was on felony probation for drug possession hadn’t been arrested for violation of probation when the drug paraphernalia was found in her closet. She said that she had approached Forman about whether or not the victim would be arrested.



“He told me we wouldn’t be arresting her,” she said, though he didn’t explain why, “I didn’t pressure him no.”




The police did seize a computer tower for investigation on suspicion that a check fraud or counterfeiting operation was being done inside the victim’s apartment. But they didn’t arrest her on the drug charges because they had asked the victim if the hypodermic syringes they had found in her closet were hers and she said no.


“End of story,” Zekster said.

“Yes,” said Meyers.




Meyers was asked if she would lie for Forman and she said no.


“I would never lie for anybody,” she said.


That's what every officer or former officer who testified said in one form or another even as they contradicted each other in several key areas of the testimony including whether or not anyone or who returned to the apartment to retrieve a forgotten item as the officers left the scene and what happened involving the aforementioned lingerie incident. There's the spirit of the words and the letter of them because the combined testimonies don't come together well to create a single portrait of the events which took place in the early morning hours of April 18, 2008 but a variety of different ones. So which one is the truth, or is it a combination of different accounts that is indeed what happened? And what is or is not attributed to memories fading and recollections becoming weaker during an 18 month period or was it the Thin Blue Line at work?


The Senior Officer


Next up on the witness stand was Zackowski who said that he had been a police officer for 15 years and with the police department for 11 of those years. During his tenure with the department, he had taken drug recognition classes, arrested over 500 people for methamphetamine offenses and also was very familiar with search terms for parolees and probationers including through his involvement with the department’s Parole and Corrections Team (PACT). He had known Forman for his entire tenure at the department and had ridden with him 2-3 times. In April 2008, they had both been assigned in separate vehicles covering the University Avenue corridor area during the graveyard shift.

On April 18, 2008, Zackowski said he was responding to a home invasion call of an uncertain location so he went to the general area and saw a parked car with people inside parked on the street in the general area near where the report originated. He shone his spotlight on the car and about 3-7 officers including Sgt. Ruddy, Sgt. Dan Russell, De Jong, Anthony Watkins, Forman, Vivian Tate and Forman’s trainee (Edwards) responded to the scene. Zackowski testified that a woman, the victim, came out and said she owned the residence. The police ran a search on her at some point and discovered she was on felony probation.

Because of the nature of the call, several police did a protective sweep of the house to uncover any potential threats and secure the residence. Once they accomplished this, they began a secondary search. What they uncovered is that the victim had said some individuals had come to her house to use their computer and overstayed their visit. Based on the probationary status of the victim, the police decided to search the house.

Forman who had responded to the call because he had a trainee took over the scene once he had arrived with Edwards assigned the task of writing the primary police report. Zackowski who brought a wealth of experience with probationary searches due to his PACT history searched the bedroom and during the search found several syringes in a dresser drawer. Knowing that they posed a hazard to himself and other officers, he confronted the victim as he should have to ensure the safety of the officers in the apartment including himself.

He talked to the victim in the bathroom, with her sitting on the toilet and him standing by the sink in a stern manner asking her if there were other syringes that might create a safety issue for him and other officers while searching. He told her that he didn’t want to be stuck with needles because several of the syringes had blood on them.

He told her if she didn’t cooperate with him, he would violate her probation, arrest and send her to jail if they found any more needles which they did in a bag inside her closet which contained between 20-30 of them as well as a used syringe sitting outside the bag on a shelf in the closet. Zackowski said he also found a spoon which had methamphetamine residue on it. He called over Meyers and explained to her what he had found, what the spoon was used for, that it contained drug residue and what it meant so it would help her recognize similar things in the future as she gained experience in her career as a police officer in the department.

Zackowski testified that he did tell Forman about the syringes at some point but wasn’t sure whether he did it separately or whether he showed him all the syringes together. He said that he believed that eventually the evidence including the syringes would be collected and processed in an evidential fashion. When asked if there was enough evidence for him to have arrested the victim, Zackowski said yes and when asked what that evidence was, Zackowski said it was the syringes.

Then Zackowski was asked about the lingerie incident.

Zackowski testified about seeing lingerie around the bedroom and that at some point he had picked up a pair of underwear and placed it on the gun belt of Officer Anthony Watkins. It appears that the intention behind the action was that the officer wearing it wouldn't be aware of it at first and then the others watching would laugh at him as a joke. Only the joke isn't on the officer, it's on the woman whose lingerie is being used in this manner by professional police officers assigned to the Riverside Police Department while no less than three field sergeants were somewhere onscene during the incident involving what was originally a home invasion call. It's also a joke on the officers in the police department who do not act in such a matter when responding to calls for service or interacting with the public, while wearing their badges and uniforms telling everyone where they work and what they represent.

When Zackowski was asked about it, he admitted what he did and when asked if he had regrets, responded that yes he did. Maybe on his part it was an impulsive act without clear thought until after. But this wasn't one of the police department's highest points in its history and it's only come to light because of a criminal case that's held in a public forum known as a courtroom.

Watkins then walked out of the bedroom with the lingerie on his gun belt into the living room and that it somehow wound up on Officer Lonnie Battest’s gun belt. Battest then took the underwear off his gun belt and put it on the dart board, according to Zackowski who said that Battest hadn't seemed happy with what the officers had done.



“He wasn’t entertained by it,” Zackowski said.



He said he couldn’t recall if the victim had been in the area where this was taking place but that she had been sitting in a chair near the front door and he wasn’t sure she could see what was on the dart board. But Edwards had already testified that she had been seated at the chair by the table near the dartboard for reasons of officer safety while the officers were inside her apartment including when they were conducting the search. Still, Zackowski said he wasn't sure of where she was at the time of the lingerie incident.



“I didn’t look at her,” Zackowski said, “At that point, I wasn’t happy myself.”



If that's the case, then at least Zackowski admitted it. There's actions and then there's reactions to actions, even if it takes time for them to catch up with what's been done. And the fact is that playing and joking around with a woman's lingerie in her own home under the color of authority sends the message that the police department views women not as victims, perpetrators or even that "in the middle" that Meyers testified to, but as objects to be used for entertainment or to alleviate the boredom that might arise from spending hours in the earliest hours of morning when most of the world's asleep, dealing with a crime scene.

After he left with Forman and Edwards, Zackowski said he didn’t remember anyone going back upstairs to the apartment while they were leaving. He said he drove back to the Orange Station but didn’t recall going to the jail nearby although he was told that he was taped by a surveillance camera while he was there. He did recall being with Forman in front of the station and must have had a conversation with him but that he didn’t recall Forman saying anything about going back to the victim’s residence. He remembered what he had talked about with Forman but not what Forman had said to him. A lot of his recollection appeared to come from reviewing interviews.


Johnson cross-examined Zackowski and asked him why the two Internal Affairs Division sergeants were sitting in the back of the courtroom or whether he was ever notified that they would be present during his testimony. He responded no, to being notified that they would be showing up at the courtroom. Johnson asked Zackowski if he been put on notice about the department not believing that he didn't remember or did remember things that happened.

And that 20 minutes of missing time has been called into question by the department's investigators because he couldn’t recall where he was during that time in interviews with them. He was told that he had come back to the Orange Station about 45 minutes before Forman had and Zackowski said he had a vague recollection of a conversation with Forman about his personal life.

He had been interviewed twice by investigators about the incident in the summer of 2008 and after the first interview was told by a sergeant that “they don’t think you’re funny and you need to go back after lunch”. The concern by investigators had been over why he remembered specific details about the home invasion robbery call but not after that incident.

Zackowski told the jury he would never cover for another officer. He also related an incident that happened when he was out at the movie theater and received a phone call from Forman’s investigator when he hadn’t given the number out and he had asked the investigator how he had gotten his number. He had told the investigator he had not planned to cooperate with him and said that the investigator told him that he might have to work with him in the future. Zackowski took that as a threat he said, because the man worked for the law firm that represents the Riverside Police Officers’ Association and thus him as an officer. An allegation was made through questioning during his testimony that he had said that most attorneys who were ex-police officers were fired from their jobs.

He was excused subject to recall. He seemed to be relieved to be off the stand.



The Camera Man


Lonnie Battest testified next and said he had responded to the home invasion robbery call to take photographs of areas and items that other officers told him to document, usually arriving after searches had already been conducted. He saw the victim in passing and to him she didn’t seem very upset. He said that during the 30-45 minutes he had been at the scene, the atmosphere was normal and relaxed.

At one point, he looked down and saw a pair of pink underwear on his gunbelt. He didn’t think it was funny and knocked it off of his belt. To his best recollection, he said, he didn’t put it on the dart board. He didn’t see putting it on his belt or the dart board as appropriate conduct and said he conducted himself in a professional manner at the scene.


“From what I remember, I knocked them off my belt and continued walking,” Battest said.


When he left, he saw that several officers remained including Forman and Edwards at the time he had left after knocking the underwear off. What was interesting about his testimony was that he had been adamant in his testimony that the underwear on his gun belt had been pink while the victim had mentioned that it had been black. Was Battest confused about the color? He seemed absolutely set in saying that it was pink. Or was there more than one pair of underwear involved here? The questions continue as the testimony does.

It's interesting watching the legal strategies unfold by both the prosecutor and the defense attorney but curiously enough, the defense counsel seems to be assisting the prosecution more with its case than with its own. It's not clear if Forman is planning to testify in his defense but in most of these cases, police officers don't take the stand. They usually hope that their attorneys will try most of their own case through cross-examination of prosecution witnesses. In many cases involving police officers this has been enough, given that juries are reluctant to convict police officers for on and off-duty crimes and the alleged victims in these cases often have criminal records which are used to impeach them.

But the defense attorney is making it seem like Forman wasn't in the apartment at all by side-stepping his client's actions or inquiries about what he was doing while focusing on those of the other officers, which will leave the jury with the tendency of wondering why this is so and asking themselves why there's so little mention of the leading character in this ongoing story that is unfolding in front of them. What exactly was Forman doing in the apartment while the police officers were there investigating the home invasion call? It's much more clear at this point in the trial where every other officer at the scene was positioned, when and what they were doing at the victim's apartment than is the case with Forman whose actions actually matter most. The jury's biggest questions running through their heads at this point in the trial surely must be where was Robert Forman when all this was going on and what exactly was he doing inside the victim's apartment? And most importantly, did he return later?




The Detective


Linda Byerly has been a detective in the Riverside Police Department for seven years and employed as an officer for about 20 years. Currently, she's assigned in the Sexual Assault and Child Abuse Unit and has been assigned to this case. She spends the days at the trial sitting in the role of assigned investigator at the prosecutor's table. She testified after Battest had been excused (and he actually was, not just subjected to recall like everyone else) and her testimony seemed to set some foundation on evidential issues involving the use of the police department's Honeywell security cards.

She testified that security cards were required to obtain entrance at both the Orange Street Station and the Lincoln Field Operations Station and that the department kept records on each officer's use of the cards at the different facilities.

She testified and reports of card activity were produced that showed that the actions of both Forman and Zackowski were highlighted, showing that Zackowski returned to the Orange Street Station at about 7:18 a.m. and Forman a bit later, at 8:10.40. am. The issue of the time cards was raised in earlier testimony including the fact that Forman and Zackowski went to the jail to book a woman from the residence into jail for a felony violation but Zackowski returned to Orange Station about 52 minutes before Forman did. Unless Forman testifies, his lawyer has a couple of choices which is to discredit an electronic security system or to have other witnesses besides Forman account for the time he spent missing from Orange Street Station.

One of the biggest issues at the trial has been where was Forman during this time period and how much did he say or not say to Zackowski about where he was going and what he was doing at the point where they parted ways. And whether or not this officer is aware that his former colleague seems intent on selling him out down the river which is odd behavior from an innocent man. Of all the witnesses so far, Zackowski seems to be the most caught between a rock and a hard place, stuck answering difficult questions 18 months after the alleged criminal incident in front of Internal Affairs sergeants. Is he testifying honestly and are his gaps after the home invasion robbery car genuine or is he covering up for another officer and if so why?

And what is he thinking in that Forman's lawyer is trying to make it seem like he's the one who acted suspiciously that day? Whether it's making innuendos that he was the officer who returned to the victim's apartment and had more contact with the victim than Forman did or even trying to make it appear as Zackowski was involved in misconduct, it seems clear that for whatever reason the defense strategy is to place Zackowski in a particular role, probably not one that fits him. If Forman was indeed his friend, there's a saying about that. But Forman's in the fight of his life and his freedom playing a role inside a venue that he never expected to be. Everyone else is supporting characters.

Perhaps Zackowski's refusal to help the defense team or be interviewed by them is a reflection of his realization that something's not quite right. Because after all, there's something stronger than the Blue Code and that's self-preservation. But Zackowski's been the hardest testimony to watch because he's an officer who put in 11 years in the department and probably accomplished a lot during his tenure and made a difference in the city who sat on the witness stand looking like he's watching his career is slipping away.

Testimony is set to resume on Monday morning.



Does blogging about the Forman case make a person popular? Not exactly and apparently it hasn't in some circles on this case either. When I first wrote about Forman's arraignment last year, I received the following comment on Inland Empire's Craigslist.




So now Shelton follows one of RPDs officers through the courthouse? Sits close and eavesdrops on a handshake between a prosecutor and the officer?

Sick.

Her true intentions ring out again. She is infatuated with the thought of an officer being charged with sex crimes. "This cop abused his authority," she screams. Just like he (that authority figure from her past) did to me!" Oops.

You might ask why. We have a hunch. Maybe she's reliving her Army days? Yeah we know all about that. Don't act surprised.

Sick, Shelton. You really ought to get some help with your spirits of the past. oh and get some clean clothes and get yourself clean. Your disgusting.




Eh whatever. And you of course, are cute and sexy even if you can't spell. You might want to shave once in a while though.






How the political ambitions of one key player in the San Jacinto scandal led to his downfall as the tendrils of the latest political scandal to hit the Inland Empire expands ever so outward from its epicenter.




What's going on with those red light cameras in Riverside?





Local Political Buzz



Yes, the Riverside Ward Six election is nearly four years away but there's already buzz that one candidate, Frank Corral is running for office in that ward when that seat is up in 2013. Never too late to plan ahead.

And the usual rumors about everyone and his mother planning to run in the mayoral election in 2012, the first without incumbent Ron Loveridge in the running. At least eight names have been tossed about in speculation.

Rumors are too that Ward Seven incumbent, Councilman Steve Adams might try his hand at running for the state assembly seat again which he attempted to do but failed to make it out of the Republican Primary. Perhaps he believes the second time is the charm. Probably not. It's like moving up from little league to the pros.



The Orange County Sheriff's race which takes place next year is heating up. Like both Riverside and San Bernardino Counties, Orange County has an appointed sheriff rather than an elected one. All three counties are set to hold elections next year.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Balancing the Latest Budget Cuts on the Back of the RPD

After the mayoral election resulted in long-time incumbent Ron Loveridge winning another term, the news came out from the city not long after that it was another $4 million in the hole in terms of shortfall in its anticipated budget revenue. In reality, that budget shortfall has been there a while but you know it's not really nice to talk about negative and unpleasant details like a budget crisis during an election cycle so there was somewhat of a collective silence on this until the election was over. Why, is two fold, being that budget cuts are nasty issues for voters especially when it's a public safety department that's been placed on the chopping block. In this case, the Riverside Police Department which will face about 60% of the cuts, allegedly at the request of Loveridge to the city manager's office. Ironic, given that the Riverside Police Officers' Association's PAC endorsed him in the latest election. Not that the mayor should do what any of his endorsers tell him but PACs usually endorse people after evaluating whether their views on issues fall into line with their own as much as possible. Then again, that has to be balanced against the liklihood of winning and whether an incumbent may retaliate against a union for not endorsing them. Sounds silly? That's one of the thrusts of a recent lawsuit filed by two former leaders of the Riverside Police Administrators' Association so maybe it's not so silly in this city.

At the time, there was no announcements of where the latest round of budget cuts would take place but as it turned out, the police department will be bearing over half of them, to the tune of over $2 million. That's put a lot of things on hold including the unplanned thawing of up to two lieutenant and four sergeant positions which have been in deep freeze for well over a year, even as the vacancy rates of supervisory positions increase and will increase again next year. Not to mention the creation of more officer positions including the 10 that Councilman Paul Davis regularly asks for. Employee freezes especially those in promotional positions tend to feed retirements and resignations as employees see the incentives for remaining in their positions fade away. What's preventing the supervisory levels from approaching a more critical level is the high vacancy rates in the sworn officer positions which number about 30, plus or minus the six entry level positions that were recently unfrozen by the city council.

A department representative said that some of the cuts had already been taken care of by the department's vacancy rate and that's somewhat reassuring to hear. But the news came as the department was trying to figure out how to reconfigure its Special Operations Division which will see two out of three of its lieutenants retire later this month. The traffic division lieutenant which has been vacated by retirement for the second time in 18 months will be filled by a lieutenant assigned to another division, rather than through the promotional process as originally hoped. In fact as stated, the planned promotions have been scrapped until further notice.

Chief Russ Leach appeared at a recent Latino Network meeting on Nov. 4 and said that the department's vacancy rate was currently 25 positions (although a Human Resources report put the vacancy rate of the department at around 10% which is 65 positions) and that the department would start planning its Strategic Plan, part deux. The plan was to originally have been completed by the time the current one mandated under the stipulated judgment with the state expires in December. But of course, the best laid plans often go astray and so was the case here when elements of City Hall allegedly blocked the development of this latest Strategic Plan until just before the date of that Latino Network. Currently, the department hopes to have its Strategic Plan completed and ready to go to the city council in some form in March. Both Leach and his boss, City Manager Brad Hudson have given different comments in terms of how the public will be able to provide input. Neither is optimal to reach all areas of the 300,000 people in this city whose tax dollars go to pay the general fund which pays for the police department's budget.

Both chiefs need to go back to the drawing board on that issue.


Community Police Review Commission Meets






[CPRC commissioners John Brandiff and Ken Rotker react in different ways to the ongoing discussion on whether or not minority opinions will either be allowed as minority reports or pretty much allowed period. ]



The Community Police Review Commission met last night alas without nerf sticks to do battle again over the idea of publishing or including minority reports within their majority reports. Unfortunately I was unable to stay for the entire meeting but I will update on this ongoing situation in a future posting.

The most ridiculous conversation took place when a member of the public asked the commission when it was planning to hold vice-chair elections, given that the previous vice-chair, Peter Hubbard had vacated that position to become chair after the last chair, Sheri Corral resigned last month. The commission currently has no vice-chair. When Hubbard as chair of the commission was addressed with this question, he had very little to say about it. In fact, he did what Corral often did and that was to defer the response to CPRC Manager and de facto Chair Kevin Rogan. Rogan said he had consulted Priamos on this issue and that the election had been postponed because the commission would be appointing in a new member and that person would be unfamiliar with the candidates and thus unable to make an informed vote.

Commissioner Chani Beeman shot a quick hole in that response by saying that the charter and commission's own written procedures requires elections to take place every March, a time when new commissioners are sworn in so that the election is mandated to take place (and Priamos has said made this clear during several past meetings) on the same day one or more new commissioners might be attending their first meetings. She said that Commissioner Rogalio Morales had attended several meetings before he took his position so he had a chance to be familiar with the sitting commissioners. Rogan responded by splitting hairs on whether it's any different between mandated elections and "discretionary" ones which opened the door on who's serving the commission and making those "discretionary" decisions. It's probably not Hubbard who introduced items and interjected his opinions but otherwise is no more an active chair than Corral was during her term.

Interestingly enough, Morales was a no show at this meeting, which would have been his second appearance on the commission.

In other news, it appears that commissioner Art Santore was called into the office of either Rogan or perhaps even the city manager's office (whether Brad's or his adjutant) to be chastised for appearing at the Nazi rally and counter rally in Casa Blanca earlier this month. Apparently someone complained that he was asking people if they wanted to file complaints with the police department. Shocking indeed, not so much that he was chastised because most people know that the commissioners are under quite a few people's thumbs at City Hall these days but that he was actually asking people about complaints. What's fascinating about that episode would have been to see how some elements at City Hall react to the news of such activities by a commissioner it believed was firmly in its camp. But then again, a micromanaged civic body can often have its more unpredictable moments.

By the way, the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee was to hear an ethics complaint against Hubbard for conflict of interest on Monday, Nov. 23 at 1 p.m. For whatever reason, the agenda hasn't even been posted online yet on this item and probably won't be until the requisite 72 hours before. But the latest news is that the entire city council has been told to appear at this meeting because a second complaint has been filed against the entire committee for conflict of interest because all of them receive sizable campaign contributions from the national parent company of American Medical Response (which employs Hubbard in some capacity) during their election campaigns, according to their campaign disclosure statements.

It will be interesting to see what plans the city council has to address this latest ethics complaint. A good guess is that it will probably be another group spanking by the city council which is exactly what the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee did during the only hearing it ever held involving an ethics complaint (against a former city councilman). That memorable meeting provided a useful exercise in not telling people why it's pointless to have elected officials hear and decide complaints amongst themselves but more importantly, showing why.

Jennifer Vaughn-Blakely, the tireless chair of the Group and its members as well as those in Save-Riverside and other organizations should be lauded for pushing for the complaint process to go to an independent panel for discussion and resolution, including possibly a panel of retired judges. So far, the city council has pretty much given that no brainer suggestion a cold shoulder although the only elected official who wigged out about it publicly was actually Councilman Rusty Bailey.





City Council's Decision Not to Take Public Comment Before Commissioner Vote



Speaking of the CPRC, I received some comments and emails in the past day on the decision of the Riverside City Council to vote on the appointment of its newest commissioner before taking public comment. Doing so was proposed by Mayor Ron Loveridge who chaired the meeting and it was supported tacitly by the city council who after all, lets him lead the meetings the way he feels and when asked about them taking a vote on an agenda item without public comment, Councilwoman Nancy Hart, who's also probably done running for political office answered, "yes we are". She was heard telling someone that she appeared to be concerned that someone who spoke before the vote would be trying to influence her to change her vote.

Loveridge is now for the first time a lame duck mayor and perhaps a lame duck politician so he can pretty much do what he wants to do including how he leads a meeting or pushing for an over $2 million cut in the police department's budget as he allegedly did. The city council pretty much goes along with it either because its members don't value public input or they are fearful that their pet projects will not be voted upon favorably by the other city councils. This was especially common when recently ousted alpha male Councilman Frank Schiavone pretty much ruled the city council, but clearly remains in effect now. Maybe they're worried the mayor will spank them. But this dynamic otherwise called "Groupthink" has been the law for Riverside City Councils for the past decade.

City Attorney Gregory Priamos was absent but if he had been there, he would have backed the city council's decision as he's the only attorney I'm aware of who actually uses the state's sunshine law, the Brown Act to restrict public input and he does it quite well. But you have to be realistic as an appropriate nickname for Priamos is "Four Votes", meaning the four votes from the city council he needs to keep his job when he undergoes his periodic job evaluations in closed session.

But GroupThink is a well known phenomenon in social psychology and unfortunately is not an uncommon problem in legislative governmental bodies. The city of San Jacinto probably had this dynamic exercised within its circle to some degree as well as other clearly dysfunctional behavioral patterns.




Definition of GroupThink:


(excerpt, wikipedia)




Groupthink is a type of thought exhibited by group members who try to minimize conflict and reach consensus without critically testing, analyzing, and evaluating ideas. Individual creativity, uniqueness, and independent thinking are lost in the pursuit of group cohesiveness, as are the advantages of reasonable balance in choice and thought that might normally be obtained by making decisions as a group.[1] During groupthink, members of the group avoid promoting viewpoints outside the comfort zone of consensus thinking. A variety of motives for this may exist such as a desire to avoid being seen as foolish, or a desire to avoid embarrassing or angering other members of the group. Groupthink may cause groups to make hasty, irrational decisions, where individual doubts are set aside, for fear of upsetting the group’s balance. The term is frequently used pejoratively, with hindsight.


Causes of Groupthink:



  • Structural faults in the organization: insulation of the group, lack of tradition of impartial leadership, lack of norms requiring methodological procedures, homogeneity of members' social background and ideology.
  • Provocative situational context: high stress from external threats, recent failures, excessive difficulties on the decision-making task, moral dilemmas.

Social psychologist Clark McCauley's three conditions under which groupthink occurs:

  • Directive leadership.
  • Homogeneity of members' social background and ideology.
  • Isolation of the group from outside sources of information and analysis.


As you can see, this is a formidable obstacle in the path of accountable government.

It's heartening to read the responses to this unfortunate development at that city council meeting because yes, it was not the democratic or ethical way to conduct business at a public meeting. That's why it's very important to remember incidents like this particularly if they become a pattern and practice at election time which rolls around on some level every two years for city council and four years for the mayoral election. What this elected body needs are leaders who will step forward and step up to speak to committee or city council chairs when they try to limit public comment rather than go along with it and then justify it by saying they're afraid that the public will try to influence a vote.

Strangely enough, even members of Riverside's City Council don't seem to be that concerned when developers try to do so, as they get the floor for longer period of time at public meetings and probably meetings behind closed doors as well. And that's what they really should be concerned about a lot more than their own constituents as hard lessons like those provided courtesy of cities like San Jacinto and the majority of San Bernardino County have shown.




San Jacinto Continues its Ethical Plunge


Councilman Jim Ayres from scandal ridden San Jacinto has to surrender a key position he had held in the Riverside County Economic Development Agency.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



The county placed Ayres on paid administrative leave pending the outcome of an internal human resources investigation and a criminal case against him, county spokesman Ray Smith said. Ayres was notified by mail, Smith said.

"He will remain on administrative leave until this whole issue is resolved," Smith said.

A grand jury last week indicted Ayres on 51 felonies and 97 misdemeanors amid allegations that he and eight others conspired to launder hundreds of thousands of dollars, conceal campaign contributions and offer bribes as part of a scheme to advance their political agendas.







One neighborhood in San Jacinto has attracted scrutiny and investigators in the corruption case had to abide by the old adage, follow the money.


The Press Enterprise Editorial Board stated that the indicted city council members should just resign already.




And does newest Riverside County Supervisor John Benoit have a connection to San Jacinto?



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



State campaign-finance records show that the donation was one of three to Benoit -- all given on the same day and all for the then-election maximum of $3,600 -- from donors that authorities identify in last week's indictment as funneling contributions from developer Stephen Holgate to San Jacinto Councilman Jim Ayres and other politicians.

Benoit said Wednesday that he had no reason to suspect that any of the donors to his Senate campaign might have been illegally reimbursed by Holgate, a political supporter, or others. He said he will review his campaign account.

"I certainly never questioned them until now. It certainly merits a good look," said Benoit, R-Bermuda Dunes. If any of the money is tainted, Benoit said, he will donate it to charity or deal with it some other way.

Benoit has not been accused of any wrongdoing.

He has close ties to Holgate, who has a home in San Jacinto.

Holgate and his wife have been among Benoit's top individual donors to his legislative campaigns, giving at least $27,000 since 2005, according to state records.







Inside Riverside which has been blogging on Benoit's appointment picked up the thread on this one quickly.

Labels: , ,

Monday, November 16, 2009

Update: Trial of Former RPD Officer Robert Forman Sidelined by Flu

"Yes we are."



---Riverside Councilwoman Nancy Hart when asked if the city council was going to vote on the appointment for the Community Police Review Commission before taking public comment. Not one elected official countered Mayor Ron Loveridge's directive to do this, which provides proof positive that the word "community" in the CPRC is truly extraneous after all. Now imagine if the mayor and city council followed this procedure on items on the discussion calendar.






The trial for former Riverside Police Department officer Robert Forman was set to resume on Monday at 1:30 p.m. but the presiding judge, John Molloy and a juror became ill and it was rescheduled for Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 10 a.m.

But alas, the next morning rolled around and Molloy was still stricken ill having to hand off his civil calendar to Department 2 and the Forman trial has been delayed until Wednesday, according to the Riverside County Sheriff's Department deputy assigned to that department. However, tomorrow is the monthly furlough day for the downtown courthouses though a judge can waive that furlough if necessary. It remains to be seen when this trial will be back on course especially if this contagion (most likely influenza) sweeps through the rest of the jury like wildfire. The ill parties are doing the right thing by isolating themselves from the rest of the population but one wonders what the impact will be on the Forman trial given that next week is Thanksgiving week, with the courthouses being closed on Thursday and possibly Friday as well.

Former Riverside Police Department officer Megan Edwards Meyers is set to resume her testimony on the next court date followed by Officer William Zackowski and possibly others. Current testimony surrounds an incident that allegedly took place involving one of the women and Forman at her apartment after a home invasion was reported and police responded around April 18, 2008 at 3 a.m. Meyers had testified that she had been partnered with field training officer, Forman and they had responded to the call in downtown Riverside along with other units. The alleged victim in this case had asked if she was going to jail and Meyers had testified last week that she wasn't, but then had said in a police interview that she hadn't talked about it with her. Meyers like most of the witnesses in this case had been on the stand for a long time and as time went on, she became more irritated as she may have been a hostile witness for the prosecution. Finally at 4:15 p.m. when she had been on the witness stand for nearly three hours, she broke down in tears, turned away from the court and said she couldn't remember everything that happened 18 months ago.

The prosecution seemed to key in on two key moments in the time line involving the home invasion call for assistance and that was the time period when she, Forman and Zackowski had been walking back to their cars and Forman went back to the apartment to retrieve an item he had forgotten. Meyers had testified that she had been gone for less than a minute but she didn't see him carrying anything when he returned.

The other focal point had been when Meyers testified about writing the report which she did as junior officer on the scene and she said that Forman had been with her, sitting next to her but at one point had gone to transport one apartment resident for booking at the Robert Presley Detention Center next door.

This case has been ongoing for over a year. Forman was arrested on Oct. 14, 2008 and charged with three felony counts of oral copulation under the color of authority and sexual battery after investigations were conducted by the Riverside Police Department's Sexual Assault and Child Abuse unit over the previous six months. A Riverside County Superior Court judge determined during the preliminary hearing that there was enough evidence for the case to go to trial which is where it's at right now.





CPRC Commissioner Interviews


On Tuesday, Nov. 17, the city council will be interviewing and selecting the newest commissioner for the Community Police Review Commission, in this case one to represent the third ward. As you can recall, former commissioner and chair, Sheri Corral resigned due to change of residency and the process to replace her proceeded more quickly than that to replace former Commission Jim Ward who resigned last March and whose replacement wasn't installed until October. More information on the candidates is included in this report. The candidates are Dale Roberts (no not that one), George Perez and Janice Bielman.



Dale Roberts was on deck first, the financial analyst from JPL who was the first interviewed. She told the city council and mayor she believed she would bring a "fresh perspective" to the panel and that she was used to dealing with disparate opinions in her work meetings. Although she's a third year law student and works for a company in Pasadena, she said she would have enough time to serve.

She believed the commission serves as a "sounding board of community to air their issues".

What was interesting is that the city council and mayor were impressed with her interview, and then immediately began asking each other who she was or whether any of them knew who she was, which mirrors the closed country club system often put on display during the applicant selection process which takes place at the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee. She mentioned minority reports in general but wasn't asked about her opinion of them and believed in independent investigations but didn't commit to them being done before or after the police department had completed its own investigations but noted the CPRC had several outstanding investigations.

Janice Bielman, the nomination of Councilman Rusty Bailey, was interviewed next. She said she had worked close with the police department in the Neighborhood Watch out of Beatty Street as well as spent time involved with the Magnolia Area Neighborhood Association. She had been studying the CPRC for several years and was fascinated by the machinist operations.

She told them she had signed up a long time ago and thought she would never get the chance to appear for an interview. She said that there was a lot going on with the police department, a lot of investigations and she wanted to be part of that. The department gets a lot of heat, she said and the law fascinated her. The interesting thing is that she said a lot in her interview but didn't really answer many of the questions posed by elected officials but her responses seemed to satisfy most of them anyway.

But she did support the commission's ability to do an independent, parallel investigations of the officer-involved deaths and her reason why was interesting. However, her answer to this question pretty much knocked her candidacy out of the water.


"When I do commit to something, I commit 100%," Bielman said.



George Perez was the final candidate and he didn't believe in parallel investigations but wavered on minority reports at first saying he didn't support them, then he did but when pressed on it in an impromptu line of questioning by Councilwoman Nancy Hart said he was fine with minority reports not being published. He didn't really answer the questions either but it was an interesting interview.

The mayor skipped over public comment and when asked about it, Hart backed him up. They then voted 7-1 to appoint Roberts. The mayor dissented, casting his vote for Bielman citing her history of public outreach.

Then the mayor asked for public comment but it's pointless to provide it on an issue once it's been voted on. Hart was heard complaining after that people who want to speak before they vote on an island are trying to influence their opinion. As if that were a bad thing and it's truly shameful if she believes that's the case and it was probably the two elected officials with political science training and civics training who should have explained to her that taking public comment from constituents before an item is voted on is part of the democratic process that one would hope to see in a city like Riverside. But guess what, one of them gave that directive while chairing the meeting. And what's clear about the mayor and the city council is that he gives the directives and they fall in line like a line of ducks.

But it was a bit disturbing to see the mayor defer on public comment until after the vote, especially after he ran on open government as part of his reelection bid. Open to whom? His campaign supporters, perhaps?

Because if the public's opinions aren't heard because it's not seen as being valuable or even seen as bad, then what opinions are "good"? It sends a disturbing message when the public tries to use its three minutes to weigh in on an issue or even to influence an elected body's vote or individual elected official's vote and that's seen as bad or not allowed (which was essentially what happened at the city council meeting) while developers and other people with thick wallets can donate hundreds or thousands into political candidates' campaigns and that is seen as welcoming. Then we see the council members turn around after getting donations from two developers in the downtown area and Doug Jacobs and try to as a body seize properties under threat of eminent domain including homes and try to hand them off to these private developers.

Is that kind of "influence" seen as good, while public comment by city residents before a vote is taken is seen as bad?

Is it influence through the more financial channels like political campaign contributions? Is the "good" kind of influence that which motivated the four elected officials indicted for corruption in San Jacinto? It would be interesting to do a study to see how this majority body of individuals governing San Jacinto conducted themselves in public meetings. Whether or not they fully allowed public comment before votes were taken on items that impact this city. Whether any of them spoke out rudely from the dais with their colleagues not challenging them on their conduct. Whether the city council of San Jacinto minus one saw public participation and comment as an albatross around their neck rather than as a privilege and a responsibility under a democratic system.

To find out the truth about that would be interesting indeed.





Is the CPRC the Laughing Stock of NACOLE?



The NACOLE organization which consists of civilian oversight and police review mechanisms had its recent annual conference in Austin, Texas. None of the CPRC members attended due to bans on out of state traveling in the city due to budget cuts. However, it was well attended overall and the news coming out of it is that especially among the well-represented California contingent, the foibles of the CPRC in Riverside are among the worst kept secrets. Many people apparently knew about the terrible problems with the CPRC in Riverside and asked what would be done about them. So among other things, Riverside's being known as the city that's destroying its own form of civilian oversight. Perhaps when it comes to adopting yet another slogan or catchy title, the mayor and city council should keep this in mind as a source of creative inspiration.



Mixed Sentiment about the Downtown Library Plans


The Library Board of Trustees public hearing on the design of the downtown library elicited a mixed response.



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)




Some residents said they were pleased to see the project going forward, but others worried that the new building would take up much of the existing front lawn.

Barbara Purvis said she was disappointed that plans don't include underground parking, because the current lot is usually full.

"True, (underground parking) can be expensive, but you don't have the money for the library, let alone for the parking," she said.

About 92 parking spaces are in the present plan, a slight increase over what is now available.

Doug Shackelton, a former city planner, suggested a basement to keep the building from overpowering the site. The new design pushes out nearly to the street, which Shackelton said would interfere with views of its historic neighbor.

"Our most important architectural building in this community is the Mission Inn," Shackelton said. "It's a very sensitive façade and this doesn't respect it."






The RPD's Strategic Plan Update



As you might know, the Riverside Police Department is working on its next Strategic Plan which will be implemented after the current one (which was mandated under the consent decree with the state) expires in December. It was originally supposed to pick up where the other one left off when it left off but as too often is the case, there was some static by a faction at City Hall which blocked its creation until just recently which means that now it won't come back to the city council for a unveiling and a vote until March 2010 at the earliest. There still seems to be somewhat different interpretations of "public input" between Chief Russ Leach and City Manager Brad Hudson (who spoke on it recently at a city council meeting).

That being the case and due to the somewhat less than stellar prior history of the original Strategic Plan's implementation post-consent decree, regular progress reports will be solicited on the progression and status on this vital blueprint and the process getting it into place. It would be nice to leave it up to the professionals but that mistake has already been made and learned from so this is the procedure that's to be followed to ensure that it continues without any more drama or interruptions.

It's also important that the components of the stipulated judgment that are still in effect are included as integral to the plan as well as related issues pertaining to the staffing levels of both the civilian and sworn divisions of the department which are somewhat sorely lacking right now, not to mention that it be made crystal clear who actually is encharged with running the police department. The "too many chiefs in the kitchen" is absolutely unacceptable and as research has shown, it is not common practice among law enforcement agencies in this country to have city managers and city attorneys or even elected officials running them.



Fallout in San Jacinto



It turns out that people in San Jacinto aren't too surprised with the huge scandal breaking there involving the majority of their city government. Seriously, sometimes the people living in these scandal ridden burgs can see that something like this is coming down the bend.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



Jessica Francia, 41, owns the Donut Pantry Café on Pico Avenue. She said customers talked about the charges as they ordered their coffee.

She heard "comments like, 'It's about time,' and 'I'm not surprised,' " she said.

Many knew that some city officials were under investigation, but they are unhappy about the black eye they believe the case is giving their city.

"It makes the community look bad," said Roy Neugent, 83, who lives in Hemet but likes to come to San Jacinto to do his grocery shopping. "It hurts everybody."

Betty Jo Dunham, 79, has lived in San Jacinto all her life and works at the San Jacinto Museum. Her family came here by train in 1888, the year the railroad reached the area and the city was incorporated. She's taking a wait-and-see attitude on how the new charges will affect the city she loves and knows so well.

Now with a population of 39,000, for most of its history San Jacinto was a small farming community. Dairy was the main industry, Dunham said.






A tip to an investigator got the ball rolling on disclosure of the San Jacinto scandal as the one elected official who hasn't been indicted seeks advice from the Riverside County Board of Supervisors.





Developers will see their fees getting cut in many different venues.
Tis the Season to be Jolly.

But at a time when the relationships between developers and their elected officials will be scrutinized more closely throughout the Inland Empire including Riverside to ensure that this latest bonfire is truly an isolated event.






Press Enterprise
columnist Dan Bernstein conduct an experiment with Riverside's AT&T wireless service.






If you happen to be going downtown, stop by the Back to the Grind Coffee place for some java, food and to check out the first posted ad for this Web site that is on display there on the counter. The ad was designed and produced by the excellent professionals at PIP Printing located on Market Street just a block or two away from City Hall. Remember, to shop Riverside including when you're running for office and need to buy campaign materials.











Two more earthquakes hit the desert. Never a bad time to check your stash of emergency supplies.

Labels: , ,

Friday, November 13, 2009

Anatomy of a Scandal and Other Trials

The Fruit is Rotten but is the Barrel?





Anatomy of a Corruption Scandal as the corruption that has infested the city of San Jacinto gets split wide open like a rotten fruit. This incident came up in discussion with an elected official in Riverside and the conversation touched on the critical vote taken by this city's city council a while back where the majority of the city council voted to uphold the inclusion of language in the code of ethics and complaint process which was inserted under very questionable circumstances and addressed the issue of whether city council members were really ever on or off duty.

That question split the Riverside City Council in half with three elected officials, Mike Gardner, Andrew Melendrez and Paul Davis believing that they were never really off-duty because the reality is that they get approached even in their lives off the dais by people who see them as being onduty as their representatives. Gardner and Davis especially came off of upset wins in wards where the incumbent had alienated many of the voters with his behavior or actions, including on the dais. Voters apparently saw them as the alternative to what these two incumbents had to offer their constituents.

The majority of city council members, which were Steve Adams, Chris MacArthur, Rusty Bailey and Nancy Hart either believed that you could neatly delineate between being on or off duty or they just didn't want people looking into their "off-duty" behavior too closely. If the rumor mill is correct, at least one member of this voting bloc might have reason to worry.

Adams seemed to have done everything short of wearing a neon sign to express his concern that he get complaints filed against him (by a process that's fairly toothless, which makes this concern kind of funny) for "off-duty" conduct whereas MacArthur and Bailey seemed to be more concerned with having complaints filed against them (again by the same toothless process) for behavior as incumbents running for reelection in two years over their campaign tactics. Not surprising, given that most of the mud slinging that happened in their last election cycles involved the races over their ward seats. MacArthur in particular rubbed some people the wrong way for how he painted his rivals Donna Doty-Michalka (including her marriage to her late ex-husband) and Harry Kurani, who was slammed by one of MacArthur's campaigners over his Middle-Eastern ethic heritage. So it's not surprising that those two council members voted against striking the suspect language in the code on those grounds.

And why again is this language suspect? Because of an unfortunate chronology of events that took place in 2007 after a member of Save-Riverside, Kevin Dawson filed a complaint against them councilman, Dom Betro. As you know the complaint was supposed to go to the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee for a hearing date but as you may know, that didn't happen and proper procedures weren't followed because City Attorney Gregory Priamos who was only supposed (pursuant to the resolution and municipal code language) was supposed to serve in an "advisory" capacity, not as arbiter. Yet he on at least two occasions mailed out letters to people filing ethics complaints that their complaints had essentially been denied. But even as Dawson's complaint was getting quashed, at least the members of the Governmental Affairs Committee which included Betro met in the middle of summer, 2007 to add the now controversial language that said that elected officials had to be acting under that capacity to be subject to complaints.

Not surprisingly, both Betro and Schiavone attended that meeting and pushed this language. Now you know that Schiavone as committee chair couldn't propose the motion himself so naturally Betro who of course had no personal or professional stake in this at all, went ahead and did it, according to this minute order of the July 23, 2007 Governmental Affairs Committee meeting.

It's not difficult for most people with a little common sense to figure out that 1) this was completely a self-serving action by both committee members who are now ex-council members and that 2)this is exactly why it's critical to have an ethics code and complaint process in the first place because of the behavior exhibited by these two former councilmen.

One question for the city council members who either by personal motivation or through fear voted to include this language, is whether or not you would view the city officials in San Jacinto who had to show up in Riverside County Superior Court for their arraignments after the scandal finally broke as being on or off duty. But these are just rhetorical questions as part of an exercise because the truth boils down to this, it doesn't matter what the elected officials answer. It matters that when scandals like this break, it's nine elected officials who were entrusted by the city's voters to be ethical leaders and representatives and their business and political bed mates who were indicted, not nine ordinary city residents or businessmen. Because the truth is, elected officials are never offduty. That will be amply shown by how the public views these now criminal defendants as either elected officials or private citizens, which do you think it will be?

Who's going down for a fall here, four ordinary citizens or four elected officials? And how long did it take you to answer that question?

But seriously, there is one elected official on the dais of San Jacinto's elected government that hasn't been indicted at least not yet. If you were to ask that government of one the same questions about elected officials being on or off duty, might this person provide a slightly different answer?

You're elected and you don't like these rules? Well, the exit door is that way and don't let it hit you on the way out. And thank you for leaving because the public really has made it clear that it wants ethical and professional elected officials to represent it. Including the Riverside voting electorate as was evidenced in the past two legislative elections.

But here are several questions anyway because it's going to be an interesting journey to how far this ethics breakdown has reached in the halls of power in San Jacinto.


(excerpts, Press Enterprise)



City Councilman Jim Ayres and his wife, Nancy, a school district trustee, sold their home for $89,950 more than its appraised value to Scott Shaull, of Roseville, who used money provided by developer Stephen Holgate to pay for the house.



On or off duty?




City Councilman Jim Ayres and his wife, Nancy, a school district trustee, sold their home for $89,950 more than its appraised value to Scott Shaull, of Roseville, who used money provided by developer Stephen Holgate to pay for the house.

The Ayreses then bought a $550,000 home from one of Holgate's companies on a gated cul-de-sac where eventually four of the nine indicted people lived.

Jim Ayres voted as a councilman in favor of a development deal that helped Holgate prepare his property for the planned Mid-County Parkway and for commercial development after the road is built.


On or off duty?




In the affidavit, Robinson outlined how Ayres sold Shaull a home for an above-market price, resulting in an almost $90,000 "gift" to Ayres. She detailed the money path by which she said Holgate secretly bankrolled the home purchase by Shaull.

"All parties I consulted with advised me that it was a 'big red flag,' " Robinson wrote.

Holgate withdrew at least $78,000 from various bank accounts between April and June 2006, the same time period in which Ayres deposited $82,000 into the account for his state Assembly campaign, Robinson wrote.

Jim and Nancy Ayres received tens of thousands of dollars for their state Assembly and school board campaigns, respectively, from Holgate, Shaull and Ellison, and from others whom Holgate reimbursed for their contributions, Robinson said.



On or off duty?



The Riverside City Council and Mayor Ron Loveridge should really have a reality check about whether or not they are ever really "off-duty" once they take the oath and are sworn into elected office. Particularly those who seemed the most concerned about their conduct at baseball games being linked to their council jobs like Steve Adams and those who were worried that their conduct during elections might be problematic for them as elected officials like Chris MacArthur. The remainder who just appeared to latch on to the lemming mentality should reexamine whether they should leave it up to other elected officials to tell them or scare them with scenarios to vote a particular way.

The fact is, that anyone who behaves ethically and professionally when not in council uniform will not be concerned about whether or not an ethics complaint will be filed against them. The fact is, that an incumbent elected official running a clean, ethical and principled campaign will not be concerned about an ethics complaint being filed against them.



The San Jacinto Corruption Scandal roster of players. And who was "played"? Why, the city's residents of course! And once again, we're all reminded of the unholy political (and economic) alliances that often exist between elected officials and their pet charity, developers.

Does this happen in Riverside? To the extent that brought the house of cards called San Jacinto's government toppling down, we should all hope not. But the Inland Empire Weekly wrote about financial contributions being made to a former councilman's campaign by developers who were generously endowed through the Redevelopment Agency with key properties in this councilman's district.


(excerpt)



Such was the case with the city’s acquisition of businesses on the downtown block bordered by Market and Mission and 1st and 3rd streets. In lawsuit after lawsuit filed November 2, the city moved to condemn a dozen parcels of land to make room for Raincross Promenade, a tony housing project by LA developer Mark Rubin. This action, one of the largest and, at an estimated $5.4 million, one of the most expensive condemnation efforts in the city’s history, resulted in dozens of merchants and their employees being forced to find work elsewhere.

Rubin, incidentally, is listed by Betro as a key endorser of his council re-election bid.


Across the street, business owners—scared out of their wits by what any fool could clearly see coming—quickly sold out to Beverly Hills developer Alan Mruvka, who wants to build 125 residential and live/work units between 1st and 3rd streets along Market.

“We didn’t really have a choice, did we?” says Lee LeMunyan, the co-owner of Bader Motors, who sold his property to Mruvka and shut down the business in May. “The city doesn’t want older businesses here. They want new businesses for a new tax base—then they’ll be happy. Wherever we go after this, I can promise you it won’t be Riverside.”

Mruvka, incidentally, donated $500 to Betro’s re-election bid. A company called CityWorks, LLC—listed as the developer of Maric College in Riverside and holding the same post office box address as Mruvka—contributed $1,500 to the Betro campaign. Mruvka and CityWorks also donated a total of $1,000 to Riverside Councilman Steve Adam’s re-election effort.




The Press Enterprise wrote this article about the use of eminent domain including in downtown Riverside several years back but doesn't mention anything about campaign contributions in its article. But then it's been said that the building which currently houses the newspaper itself was constructed through the use of threatened eminent domain. That building might be looking for a buyer right now and has already leased office space to outside businesses.

After all, its staff is getting tiny now what with all the layoffs of valued employees that it doesn't really need all that space anyway.


Then there was the embarrassing situation involving how the city council voted to pay settlements for several lawsuits including the legal fees for one against former City Councilman Frank Schiavone. called the Bradley Estates Scandal first reported here by Save-Riverside and later by the Press Enterprise in this article and that one.

What was a tad bit disturbing about the whole Bradley Estates mess is how nonchalant the city council was about what had just taken place. Imagine setting a precedent for paying the legal fees of a developer by having that fortunate person just happen to be an elected official. City Attorney Gregory Priamos tried to explain away the embarrassing episode in that fashion but how many people were actually convinced?



Anyway, Press Enterprise Columnist Dan Bernstein comments on the scandal involving Riverside County here and analyzes how this county stacks up to that other one in the Inland Empire.


Inside Riverside is blogging about the indictments and scandal here.




Depositions Begin in the Bacon/Hurt Lawsuits


One other lawsuit that this blog has been following is that filed by Riverside Police Department lieutenants, Tim Bacon and Darryl Hurt which make allegations of questionable practices by the city manager's office employees, Brad Hudson and Tom DeSantis as well as Schiavone and current councilman, Steve Adams. This lawsuit which came up for discussion and/or update at a closed session by the city council not too long ago will enter into the critical phase known as deposition gathering which is where prospective witnesses are interviewed by either side of the case. It's not known who will be giving depositions on the plaintiffs' side but it should be very interesting as finally a lawsuit focuses on what's actually one of the city's worst kept secrets. And whether or not any individuals will try to resist giving depositions will also be another potential issue. After all, in past lawsuits, some employees have tried to use up all their sick days just to avoid appearing for a deposition in a lawsuit filed against them or their agency.

One of the major issues raised through this litigation was whether elements of City Hall including Hudson and DeSantis were overinvolved in the day to day operations of the police department and if so, to what degree. The case is set to go to trial though given that the federal courts in Riverside are fairly congested (and one judge, Stephen Larson is set to retire if he hasn't already)it could be a while. It's difficult to believe that the city will go to jury trial in a public forum involving the police department considering the financial beating it took during the last round in the autumn of 2005. But then the buzz is that if the city's still carrying an insurance carrier, that this carrier wants the city to stop settling so many cases and start taking them to trial.

Still, it's not likely the city government wants any information to come to light in terms of how deeply one or more of its direct employees or even past or current elected officials are influencing the operations of the Riverside Police Department as has been deeply rumored for the past several years at least back to the time the department was released from its stipulated judgment with the state attorney general's office. Actions which are rumored to be attracting more than a little outside attention.

The fact is this, the police department is supposed to be run by who else, the police chief. It's the police chief who is by the way getting paid a pretty generous six figure salary that allegedly was increased under the new five-year contract signed last December, that needs to be in charge of his department. The police chief needs to do the hiring (which in one case last year caused some concern), the disciplining and the promotions. Which three of these powers does the chief have?

I'm betting none. Because if one of those three powers, in this case potentially promotions is impacted, then so will go the other two, if not today then eventually.

Allegedly, the police chief was out of the state and had no idea what was going on when two key management personnel (who weren't the subjects of concern, just the process of promotion) were promoted in 2007 at first, only if they agreed to be "at will" employees but when that was scraped as being not just inadvisable but not allowed, concerns were raised about the promotions of upper management including captains. The perception being that if you didn't want to play ball not with the police chief but his bosses, you couldn't get promoted. That's part of what the Bacon/Hurt lawsuit is about but the perception seems to have permeated even at the lower levels of supervisory positions as well and that's disturbing.

And why is it when two Latinos are getting promoted to join a third one in upper management, that suddenly their positions are going to be "at will" and at the will of who? It can't be the police chief because it's getting more and more clear that he's not in control of his own department so it's most likely his own employers.

But the confrontation that was allegedly to have taken place over some key promotions between the chief and his bosses at the city council meeting turned rally in March 2007 didn't take place. The resolve to take the department back that many thought would take place during an expanded command staff meeting in July after the chief returned from a medical leave didn't materialize. And even the chief's own advisory board met for the first time last month after six months on hiatus.

Leach is probably smarter than his bosses and he's certainly more politically astute (though it's not clear whether he stuck to his pledge of not being "politically involved") and he has a wealth of experience from different agencies including a stint as chief of El Paso's Police Department to draw upon. He's done some great things as police chief and he's made some very difficult decisions that probably upset the community some times and his own department at others but that's what police chiefs do. They're not there to please people all of the time, they are there to run a department that interfaces heavily with the communities it protects and serves. He wasn't here when the problems which plagued the department ultimately forced it into a mandate of reform issued by the state but he understands better than his bosses what got it there and more importantly, what can get it in that state again. And he proved to be most effective when bolstered by the five-year stipulated judgment, but as soon as that document was dissolved, he began to lose control of his own department.

It took two months for it to begin. It took two more to see how off track the department was going because it didn't have the leadership it needed and it's own management was not moving forward together but were in congruent and uneven in their progression (a trait unfortunately shared by the Los Angeles Police Department's own management during its reform process). During the summer of 2006, the city manager's office was doing its best to circumvent a directive issued by city council vote in late March 2006 on an action plan to keep the department moving in the direction that it needed to including in its implementation of the Strategic Plan.

But the police chief needs to step up to the plate and assert for greater control of his agency and follow through with it. There are just less than 400 sworn employees and about 650 total employees who need a chief who is consistent in his leadership particularly during these difficult teams. They and the communities of Riverside deserve no less. There needs to be the police chief who is the department head rather than these shadowy city employees from the sidelines pulling strings to be accountable for what's good and bad, the successes and the failures. And unfortunately, it's pretty clear that's not what is in place now. And lawsuits like those filed by Bacon and Hurt and also the most recent filed by the Riverside Police Officers' Association make that even more clear. When the tax payers are paying off settlements or verdicts on these cases (and it will be one way or the other) then perhaps those who vote can make it even more abundantly clear when it's time to go to the polls, beginning in 2011.

Of course, once the S.S. Hudson gets set on a course including off-course, the only thing that can set it straight again is his captains, the city council and that's where the other problems exist. Unfortunately, a majority currently exists which is more than happy enough to hand off its responsibilities to the city manager's office (and to a lessor extent, the city attorney) so it's pretty easy to just let that office micromanage some city departments as well. The majority or a very vocal minority (and that works sometimes pretty well on rerouting a ship) is what is needed to either set this ship straight again as it should be or explain to the public why this can't be done.






The Tangled Web: The RPD and U.S. Border Patrol



What: Two RPD vehicles, one U.S. Border Patrol van, two police officers, two federal agents and 6-8 Guatemalans

Where: Brockton, south of Central/Magnolia interchange.

When: Between 2-3 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 13



Between 2-3 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 13, two police cars were parked with lights on behind a white pickup truck and in front of a white van with a police lights bar on top of it but no markings. Two male agents dressed in green were talking with two police officers, one male and one female. One police officer led a male Guatemalan dressed in jeans towards where five others were sitting on a curb directly behind the white van. They were loaded in the white van and driven off while the police officers remained behind to process the truck. It was interesting to witness because of all the controversy and confusion and mixed messages (and complete lack of clarity) that has been issued by the police department's management and City Hall on apparent changes that were made in police practices involving undocumented immigrants since the police department had its representatives meet with Border Patrol agents last November.

Most likely, the Guatemalans were flown back home to their country of origin. Having gone to school with Guatemalans including young girls who showed me their scars that they received while being tortured by the regime that the United States financially and militarily backed in the 1980s, it's difficult for me to view them as simply seeking economic opportunities when any time the country tried to exercise economic autonomy over its own resources, the United States funneled money in there to back a military dictator who would then turn around and kill, torture, rape and "disappear" over 100,000 of the Guatemalan people. Not that the counter revolutionaries were angels either but they didn't have a state backed military.

The focus here is not so much on whether this is right or wrong (and the officers behaved professionally from what was seen), or the pluses and minuses of an understaffed police force policing federal laws but the complete lack of clarity and some have said honesty regarding the department's stand on this issue. You ask different people you get different answers and that should not be happening.





[If you click on this photo, the white van in the distance is the U.S. Border Patrol which was parked behind two Riverside Police Department officers.]



[Just after the U.S. Border Patrol van has left with about 5-6 male Guatemalans. The two police officers process the white truck in front of the squad cars. Click photo for larger size.]




Yes We Do...No We Don't



This issue has created a great deal of confusion among city residents as different people give different accounts in different venues about the relationship between the police department and Border Patrol. Yes they work together. No they don't work together. Yes, Border Patrol just provides bilingual translation. No, they provide means for identification. Yes they met with the RPD last autumn. No they haven't met with the RPD. Yes there is a specific policy. No, there's a policy simply because there isn't a specific policy. No, no, there's a practice but may or may not be a policy. Yes, we want the Guatemalans to feel safe to come report crimes to the department. No, we're there to enforce federal law.

And so it goes. So many words to say so little. But pictures say the loudest if the fewest words and yes, the two agencies are working together.

At any rate, the Seventh Floor through its conduit Kevin Rogan has finally allowed the Community Police Review Commission to put this item on its agenda for discussion from a policy and practice perspective. The Human Relations Commission has also been addressing the issue from a policy perspective and has met with the police chief and written letters to the city council for seeking clarification on both federal and local law enforcement policies and practices on professional contacts for the purpose of establishing residency status.





Officer for a day is about an eight year old kid who received this wish from the Riverside Police Department through the Make a Wish foundation.

The unfortunate thing is that for all the talk about "crack babies" in the 1980s, the one drug that's been proven to have the most detrimental effect on developing fetuses both through studies and real life examples is the legalized drug, alcohol. Drinking alcohol and pregnancy don't mix.

The most lethal drug of course is nicotine. Not so much the drug itself, but the "package" that carries it and kills over 365,000 people a year, most of them through gradual suffocation from a terminal lung illness. That's a city larger than Riverside.




Reimaging the Downtown Library




The Library Board of Trustees is taking public input on the preliminary design of the downtown public library which will either be rebuilt or renovated in the next decade. It will be held Monday, Nov. 16 at 5 p.m. at the Arlington Library on 9556 Magnolia.



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)




The library's board of trustees met in October to look at how a new library could be laid out on the current site at the corner of Mission Inn Avenue and Orange Street. The plan people liked most included about 100,000 square feet with two-story and three-story sections, board President Nancy Melendez said.

"It's not the same big box that it is now," she said.

The new building also could have many more windows and an atrium to let in the natural light absent in the existing library. Hassett said she is pleased that the early design would allow for expansion, and that it won't clash with the varied architectural styles that surround it.

"It's 360-degree architecture, which means there's no side of the building that is industrial, that isn't fully articulated," she said.

At Monday's meeting, the board and the public will see and discuss what could go inside the library.

Judith Auth, another Renew the Library member and a former Riverside library director, said some key elements will be a community meeting room that can be used after library hours, a larger children's area, and space to arrange the library's book collections in a more user-friendly way.




But it could be worse too. Colton for example said bye bye to its libraries for now.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



Shock and disappointment were rampant in Colton after the city abruptly shut down its two libraries and a learning center, and laid off about five dozen employees in a cost-cutting move to stave off a $5 million budget deficit.

Interim City Manager Bob Miller said by phone that 34 full-time employees have been laid off so far, but more layoffs could still come as the city works through contractual issues with some employees. Close to 30 part-time workers have also lost their jobs.

Colton's assistant city manager, Mark Nuaimi, said he laid himself off.

"I put together the layoff plan," he said by phone. "For the past 4½ weeks I've been looking at the revenue shortfall and looking to see how we could bridge that gap."

He said he and "a couple of other directors" were charged with recommending a reduction plan.





Other Meetings



Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 3 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. Riverside City Council meets again to discuss this agenda.


Wednesday, Nov. 18 at 5:30 p.m.
The Community Police Review Commission provides another case lesson how micromanagement works at City Hall on the fifth floor conference room. Hopefully after three or four hours, they will have discussed this agenda.




CPRC Interviews


The city council will be meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 2 p.m. to interview three candidates for the Ward Three position on the CPRC. This report provides some more information.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Trial began for former RPD officer accused of sexual assault under the color of authority

The People of the State of California
vs
Officer Robert Forman Trial:

Day Four




The trial of ex-Riverside Police Department officer, Robert Forman began in downtown Riverside Tuesday on three felony counts of both oral copulation under the color of authority and sexual battery stemming from allegations raised by three women between February and April 2008. The alleged incidents took place in February and April 2008 and were investigated beginning in May 2008 by the Sexual Assault and Child Abuse Division. Forman was arrested on the felony counts on Oct. 14, 2008 and fired by Chief Russ Leach approximately one month later.

His case went to its preliminary hearing in Corona within several months of charges being filed, moved there at the last minute and the presiding judge after hearing testimony mandated that the case progress to trial which started earlier this week in downtown Riverside. Testimony started Oct. 10 and the courthouse was closed for business on Veterans Day.

Riverside County Superior Court Presiding Judge John Molloy was assigned to hear the case after one of the parties papered Judge J. Thompson Hanks (who though retired is like other retired judges hearing cases to relieve the backlog) which has been going on several days now after selecting 12 jurors and two alternates. The trial is following a crunch schedule given that it's taking place in the civil courthouse and that calendar has to be completed by 10:00am before the trial can begin its daily proceedings.

The prosecutor is a young guy named Elan Zekster, with Mark Johnson representing Forman. Each side has their own investigator sitting at the table. And Forman of course sits with the defense.



The Concerned Friend?

Maribel Manzo testified on Thursday morning about dropping in on her friend who was one of Forman's alleged victims. Manzo who was convicted in 2008 of possession of a controlled substance with intent to sell knew this woman and said that she went to her apartment in the downtown area because she was concerned that she hadn't returned her phone calls. Manzo said she knocked on the door and no one answered although she could hear someone moving around inside the apartment. When she knocked again, the door opened this time and her friend came out and hugged her immediately. Manzo said she was shaking and crying, and appeared frightened.


"She was literally shaking," Manzo recalled.


Manzo said she asked if she were okay and the woman immediately started crying for several minutes. Manzo asked why she was crying and sat her friend down on the couch. The woman said that the police came to her apartment and her boyfriend was taken to jail after several syringes were found. One male officer had told her that she would go down for all of that because it was her apartment but then he told her, there was a way out. Manzo said the woman started crying again when she said that the officer had said he would come back later.


"She said he made me suck his dick," Manzo said.


Her friend then grabbed her hand and took her to her bedroom before she pointed at the bed and said he was there.


"She told me she felt very dirty," Manzo said.



Johnson cross-examined Manzo and said that be believed that the two women weren't friends but that Manzo had gone over to the woman's house to sell her drugs, knowing that she used drugs and said they had gotten high together. Manzo responded to his questioning by saying that she didn't sell the woman drugs. They kept in touch by talking on the phone 2-3 times weekly and that she had been worried about her not returning calls because that was something she often did about people she knew.


The Reporting Police Officer


Police officer, Justin Mann testified on the witness stand next and testified that the woman had told him that "something serious had happened". She eventually told Mann that she was scared of Forman.

Mann had been responding to a PC 242 battery case and that it was a mutual argument with no clarification regarding an aggressor. When Mann came to her door, she was too scared to open it, she told him because she was scared of the RPD. She told him why and seemed at a loss at what to do next.

"She told me she did not know what to do," Mann said.


Mann had testified the previous day but was subject to recall. On Thursday, he was on and off the stand in about 20 minutes but could be called back to testify again.



The Drug Counselor

Steven Wells who owns a substance abuse clinic and works as a counselor said that the woman had been one of his clients. He said she had told him about a "non consensual contact" and he seemed to believe it was psychological, rather than physical. He said that he had been interviewed when he reported it to the police department by Det. Rick Wheeler. He also testified that the woman had been hesitant to report it to police because she didn't think they would believe her because of her history.


The Trainee


Next up, was former Riverside Police Department Officer Megan Meyers who went under the surname of Edwards while working with the department. She started patrol in early 2008 but was separated from the department on Aug. 20, 2008 before the end of her probation and at the time or after her seventh phase of training. The judge and attorneys fretted over confidentiality issues pertaining to police officers when it came to exactly why Meyers left the RPD with Johnson whipping out the need for a Pitchess Motion but Molloy rebuked back saying that Pitchess and the confidentiality laws in the evidence and penal codes referred only to officers' records not the officers themselves in terms to what they could testify about their own employment. With that settled, the trial moved onward and Meyers testified as a former trainee of Forman's during the time period when his conduct had been called into question and ultimately investigated by the department. She started out fairly calm, got more irritated as the trial went on and near the end of the session, broke down on the stand.

During her tenure with the police department, Meyers had worked with different field training officers including Forman during April and May of 2008. Before she trained with him, she knew of him. Of their relationship as FTO and trainee, she said they got along very well while they were stationed out of Lincoln Field Operations near Adams and Lincoln. Zekster asked her if she became so jovial with Forman that she forgot he was her training officer. She looked taken aback at the question and answered, no. But they were companionable and they often joked around and she had talked to him every once in a while including after she had been subpoenaed. And as it turned out, she had received subpoenas from both the prosecution and the defense.

They were working together the early morning hours of April 18, 2008 when at 3 a.m. they received a priority call of a home invasion robbery downtown. They and numerous other police officers responded.


"Pretty much everyone in that area went," Meyers recalled.



Officers that showed up at the scene included William Zackowski, Vivian Tate, Mike Dillion, Lonnie Battest and Sgt. Paul De Jong. Meyers said she was told to wait at the bottom of the stairs while other officers cleared the apartment upstairs. She waited with two women who lived in the apartment and then went upstairs. One of the women gave her permission to go in the apartment and gave officers permission to search it which they did. Meyers said that several officers showed her items they discovered in their searches including empty baggies used for holding drugs and a bag of 20-25 syringes. Some officers searched the place, Battest took photos but Meyers said she didn't remember what Forman was doing. She did see Forman talking with the woman, possibly more than once. When Zekster pressed her on Forman's activities, Meyers got a bit testy and said she wasn't there to babysit the other officers or watch what they were doing.


Tate and another female officer left the scene leaving Meyers and male police officers. They saw the underwear near the dartboard in the living room. Meyers recalled one of the officers asking the woman if the underwear were hers but Meyers didn't say who. Meyers said the woman who had two felony warrants asked her if she was going to be arrested and she told her no. Meyers said she was encharged with writing the police report and that it went to Forman before the sergeant.

Meyers wavered when asked whether the focus of the police action was on drugs or check fraud. The syringes weren't taken in for evidence, she said, but the computer equipment was by officers and was included on the property report. After about two hours, she, Forman and Zackowski were the last to leave. Forman said he forgot something and was going back to the apartment. Meyers told the jury he was gone for less than a minute and she didn't see him carrying anything visible.

Under cross-examination, Johnson asked Meyers if she was in charge of the scene and she said no, she was a trainee and that one woman had been arrested because the drug paraphernalia had been in her purse whereas they couldn't arrest the woman because it was in her bedroom closet and she shared the apartment with other people.

After that, Molloy admonished Meyers for saying that whatever was in the detective's report of her interview was what she had said, due to her inability after 18 months to recall every detail. The judge said she could look at the report and either it refreshed her memory or it didn't and then to say either way under questioning by the attorneys. About a couple of a minutes later, she burst into tears on the stand, turned to face the judge and said she couldn't remember "every fucking thing" after 18 months. At that, the judge adjourned the trial for the day and the week while someone helped Meyers from the witness box. She left before being instructed that she had to return the next court day so the prosecutor had to go find her to have her come back for the judge's instructions.

Molloy instructed each witness on how to testify and admonished the lawyers several times, seeming to be in control of his courtroom. He did at one point nearly resume the trial after a sidebar while juror #2 was in the bathroom. But the deputy remembered that he had authorized the juror to go to the bathroom and informed Molloy.

Testimony will resume on Monday, Nov. 16 with Meyers set to return to the stand to finish her testimony including cross-examination.








Elections Continued


Speaking of Riverside Police Department officers, a correction is in order in the previous blog posting on the Riverside Police Officers' Association election regarding the candidates. Sgt. Cliff Mason who is running for the top spot is now apparently Det. Cliff Mason and has been since earlier this year.



DHL Revisited?


Are the latest plans surrounding March Air Reserve Base offering up a bad case of deja vu?



One Response to the Neo Nazis in Riverside


This essay was written by three local religious leaders in response to the Neo Nazi rallies which have taken place in Riverside as of late, even as Riverside's political leaders discuss behind closed doors what to do with the latest Nazi threat.



Union Pacific Train at Standstill




The city of Riverside spent years being plagued by trains mostly belonging to Union Pacific Railways blocking intersections for up to six hours a day, largely due to train congestion coming as goods and other products were shipped from the ports in Southern California to the rest of the United States. This train was moving through Riverside's Magnolia and Brockton intersections at about 12:45 p.m. at normal speed until it slowed down to a crawl. About three minutes into its crossing, it stopped completely for roughly five minutes before finally making the creaking and grinding sounds which means that it's starting up again to continue moving through the intersection which it did for roughly two minutes. Traffic was backed up to Jurupa on the north side but no emergency vehicles were affected.

I called 311 to report it but it was on holiday so first it said to leave a message and then it directed me to a live person who took the report but told me to report it as a traffic emergency to police. But the Riverside Police Department has very little authority or jurisdiction over Union Pacific which is under federal guidelines as a mechanism of interstate commerce movement and has its own police department. This practice of parking trains by Union Pacific is very unsafe since it can hinder the movement of emergency vehicles in the city.

Councilman Mike Gardner responded to an email quickly and as there are cameras on the crossings, the video will be pulled on this incident to send to Union Pacific.






Union Pacific entered into an agreement with the city to curtail or greatly reduce its blockages of the city's main thoroughfares which has decreased the time spent blocking city streets quite a bit. It was a bit surprising to see this stoppage because they haven't been as frequently noted. It might be an appropriate stop but all stopped trains should be reported to the city and the city should call up Union Pacific Dispatch office and ask why that particular train stopped because it's a serious situation in some situations. Not to mention that the intersections of major thoroughfares are not parking lots.

Several weeks earlier, crossing guards were going up and down over a 15 minute period under apparently their own volition as there were no trains and no signs of any maintenance or other work being done by Union Pacific.







[Union Pacific train stopped on Veterans Day in front of the Magnolia intersection where the grade separation is set to be built.]




[Pedestrians wait as the Union Pacific train slows before it stops in intersection. These two gentlemen would walk to the other side of the street as they waited for it to start moving again. In the past individuals had climbed in between train cars to get to the other side which is very dangerous not to mention it can delay the train from moving again until it's been completely inspected.]




Riverside County's furlough program for employees falls short on saving money.




Den of Corruption?



In San Jacinto, nine people including the mayor and city council members have been indicted on corruption charges.



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)

The nine defendants appeared for arraignment today in Riverside County criminal court. They either pleaded not guilty or deferred entering a plea. They will make another court appearance in early December.

Riverside County District Attorney Rod Pacheco will offer more details on the sweeping corruption probe at a 4 p.m. news conference.

Few details were available during the crowded arraignment appearance before Riverside County Superior Court Judge Michael B. Donner.

But the indictment is 68 pages long. According to a copy viewed by a reporter, the 155 counts allege felony and misdemeanor violations.

The defendants are accused of hiding campaign contributions. In one count, two defendants -- Jim Ayres and Holgate -- are accused of offering a bribe.





Not surprisingly, this disgraced City Hall is suffering from a few credibility issues just about now.







Veterans Day Monument

(located on Central Avenue near Olivewood Cemetery)

Labels: , , ,

Newer›  ‹Older