Five before Midnight

This site is dedicated to the continuous oversight of the Riverside(CA)Police Department, which was formerly overseen by the state attorney general. This blog will hopefully play that role being free of City Hall's micromanagement.
"The horror of that moment," the King went on, "I shall never, never forget." "You will though," the Queen said, "if you don't make a memorandum of it." --Lewis Carroll

Contact: fivebeforemidnight@yahoo.com

My Photo
Name:
Location: RiverCity, Inland Empire

Friday, March 18, 2011

Election 2011: The Gates Have Opened and They're Off!

UPDATE: Riverside Police Department hosts department/media relations meeting involving different media outlets. Chief Sergio Diaz says that transparency among all his employees is important even as troubling developments have surfaced at the top allegedly stemming back to a response to a March 18 incident outside the city.

What went overlooked were some critical programs in the city's roster of Community Services and the work that those employees can do as the media relations aspect of the program dominated. But it was a very enlightning interesting couple of hours of questions and answers.

More to come.






[Members of the Riverside Police Department listening to comments made during Chief Sergio Diaz' meeting on police department/media relations]








[Concerned residents fill Riverside's City Council chambers on a meeting on Sendai's relief effort]



Ted Honcharik 25 miles away from Sendai purchasing and distributing heating oil to keep residents warm in their homes and shelters in sub freezing temperatures.



UPDATE: Special Governmental Affairs Committee meeting scheduled to address appointments to Charter Review Committee


A Crisis at the RPD? What went on at the top over the weekend? Why did it happen ?And how much have we really learned since 2010?







[Crews from Victoria Country Club shore up the river that floods Sedgwick with rocks, the only work that's been done on this commonly flooding area of the city so far]




"When good people in any country cease their vigilance and struggle, then evil men prevail."

---Pearl S. Buck







Riverside's Response to Sendai




The city set up a Sendai Relief Fund to help raise at least $250,000 to send to the city of Sendai in the wake of a meeting held at City Hall on March 14. The Fuel Relief Fund also raised funding and is in Japan trying to purchase fuel for transport and distribution along with generators up in the northern part of Japan including Sendai. Riverside City Council will review a resolution to send a $100,000 to Sendai Relief.

The City Hall in Sendai is up and running and very busy doing many things including as a shelter for homeless people. The university was badly damaged and there was discussion about what to do with the students. In Christchurch, New Zealand, the University of Canterbury was also badly damaged by soil liquification and quite a few students were sent to Australia to continue their studies. Food, water and gas continue to be in very short supply and there's not many areas with electricity. Long lines for blocks for food and for gasoline.

The weather in Sendai in March is very cold, often below freezing at night and there's snow or sleet, all of which the area saw this week.

About 20,000 or more individuals are believed dead or missing in the Myagi Prefecture which includes Sendai. The delta region near the coast was hit by the tsunami in between 15-25 minutes after the quake, leaving very little time for evacuation. Many people that the Sendai Committee was trying to contact have been accounted for except some of those in the coastal areas. Ted Honcharik flew to Toyko for the Fuel Relief Fund and is trying to buy fuel to take to Sendai.

Complicating rescue and relief efforts is the ongoing situation with the Fukushima Daini plant which although it generates electricity had its own supply cut off. Workers have been working around the clock to deal with six reactors in various stages of overheating and meltdown.

Radiation reached California on Friday morning but it's in teeny tiny amounts as radioactive iodide doesn't last long before degradation or conversion into a more benign form that dissolves in ocean water. According to some diplomat, radioactive Xenon was detected in equipment in Sacramento as there's a storm hitting Central California (and tornado warnings in San Mateo County)and so far none detectable in Southern California including Los Angeles.

Real Time Radiation Model is based on projects and weather shifts can change the pathway and the area where the troubled plant is will be facing a major rain storm on Sunday which could cause wind shift. Different cities in Southern California have radiation detectors including Riverside. Ironically, there's the usual particulate smog in the Riverside/San Bernardino area that's probably more dangerous.


Salt hoarding is taking place in some countries. But iodized salt doesn't ward off radiation caused by radioactive iodine 131. And Potassium Iodide can cause serious health side affects particularly in those over 40 which it doesn't help much anyway unless they receive major exposure. A lot of people have shell fish allergies (as it's the most common allergy in adults) including those not aware of it as well who could experience serious side effects.

One of the major cautions given out for people who are close to where there is release of radioactive iodine 131 is not to drink the milk until it's safe (and the iodide has degraded) as most of the thyroid cancers caused particularly in children after Chernobyl were from drinking cow's milk in contaminated areas. Cows eat the grass where the iodide settles before it can degrade naturally and then through bio magnification, they absorb concentrations and can pass it through their milk for a period of time. Leafy plants that are eaten might harbor some risk as well.

There's a lot of debate and discussion on nuclear power plants including in the United States. Want to know how closely you live or work to one? This site will give you a rough estimate of your proximity to different power plants.

For example:


Zip Code: 92501 (downtown Riverside)



Closest Plants and Their Distance

* San Onofre 2, 3: 44 mi (can be unsafe in major catastrophes for food/water)
* Diablo Canyon 1, 2: 215 mi
* Palo Verde 1, 2, 3: 262 mi
* Columbia Generating Station: 868 mi
* Comanche Peak 1, 2: 1137 mi



* Interesting detail about San Onofre, Riverside's Public Utility gets about 1.8% of the electricity generated there.




Election 2011: Let the Games Begin



Elections can be very dull or very exciting and after going through an HOA board election that had to be sent to a lawyer for a decision, it's interesting to read about the situation playing out in the Riverside election. All but the fifth ward have candidates who are set to challenge the incumbents.

I don't endorse candidates because for one thing I don't live in any of these wards. What I do endorse is that the city residents register to vote if they're eligible to do so and that they vote whether it's by mail-in, absentee or at the polls. That's the most important power that people have in our city and our country is to vote. Many of the wards have had low voter turnouts and there needs to be greater engagement and participation in the process. People and organizations have engaged in voter registration drives, carpools to the polls particularly for the elderly and/or disabled. Elections are actually a lot more fun when you're on the sidelines and don't endorse.

But also because voters in their wards need to make their own decisions on who to vote for, and do the homework on candidates including their incumbents. If there's candidates forums in your ward, or neighborhood, attend them or maybe get together and hold your own. The League of Women Voters usually hold forums in different wards on different local candidates and issues. So do other organizations so if you can attend them, you should check them out.

The city's labor unions will be going through their endorsement process. Riverside Police Officers' Association President Cliff Mason is apparently the new PAC chair for that union. But Mason has more time now having severely injured his knee during a training for a position on the department's Metro/SWAT team. I was a bit surprised to hear that he had put in for the special assignment because he's a probational sergeant (and probational status does have its restrictions in certain areas for most people) but hopefully he's recovering. Some city unions like the Riverside Firefighters' Association usually endorse incumbents while others make it more interesting with some other choices. But you can't really blame the RFA for sticking to incumbents, it's often (but not always) safer and after witnessing how certain incumbent candidates have treated those who didn't endorse them in some past several election cycles.

Any questions on voting or on the election, or call 826-5557 and ask for City Clerk Colleen Nicol.


Ward 1:

Dom Betro

Michael Gardner

Dvonne Pitruzzello

Marisa Valdez Yeager


Betro's decision to file papers had allegedly resulted after Betro had made phone calls including those working in the Yeager campaign to support him running for election and some splintering followed. Because if you remember, some of the same people spearheading Yeager's campaign worked heavily on Betro's 2003 and 2007 campaigns.

He had been relatively quiet after losing his 2007 election by six votes, after issues such as Eminent Domain and the handling of two ward parks, Fairmount and Tesquesquite came under fire. But apparently Betro didn't make it through his first candidacy forum without complaining that the DGR allowed Save-Riverside's Kevin Dawson to ask the question about the July 2005 vote by the city council to restrict members of the public from pulling consent calendar items for separate discussion and vote. Betro denied at the forum that he had supported that but minute records drawn from the city's city council meeting archive as posted on this site clearly show that a motion which included that language regarding the consent calendar had been presented by Betro and seconded by Steve Adams and had passed 6-1 with Councilman Art Gage dissenting.

Memory loss or a false denial? It does make you wonder because that false or misstated claim by Betro was relatively easy to receive factual clarification on for anyone who goes on the city's Web site. Because if Betro had truly opposed the restrictions on the consent calendar that were eventually passed by the majority of the city council, why did he propose a motion to do just that and really, how stupid does he think people including those in Ward One are anyway?

This link shows the minute record if you scroll to 91-17 on the motion sponsored by Betro, which incidentally he also voted on its passage. So that gave him two opportunities to "push" for the restrictions on the consent calendar through proposing the motion and then voting on it.

The Democrats of Greater Riverside had a candidate forum for the two Democrats, Yeager and Betro and some contention was sown there by Betro who said he wasn't seeking its endorsement but that the members should "police" their membership. That caused quite a few members to be upset. There were also rumors for a while that some behind the scenes action would be taking place to decide which candidate would run, Betro or Yeager but if that's indeed the case, it hasn't appeared to work so far.

Will Ward One be as contentious in an election this time around as it was last time? That remains to be seen because there's not been much discussion or debates on the issues that each candidate brings into the race. Most of the focus so far appears to be on fund raising and garnering support even if it means poaching onto another candidate's army roster.




Ward Three:

Rusty Bailey

James Harold Davis


This election was fairly quiet. A few murmurs of possible candidates but only one other filed papers.

Davis has a blog called Rivercity Voices where he wrote this campaign letter addressing redevelopment agencies and the ban of mobile "hot food" vendors passed by the city council. Bailey still has to make amends with many of those who stumped for him in the first election because even those who specifically went out and recruited him as a third ward candidate against incumbent Art Gage are dumbfounded and somewhat dismayed at his shifting of position on several issues. So what will be interesting to watch with Bailey is whether these folks have parted ways with him or will return to his camp. Will Bailey be extending the olive leaf branch instead? Not unless he needs to and it's not likely this time around. That would be more likely if he does as rumored and puts his hat in the mayoral election (along with half the political set it seems) next year.




Ward Five:

Chris MacArthur


Although there were some murmurs of candidates thinking about running in the fifth ward including Keith Michael White (who took out papers), none of them filed papers and so MacArthur is running uncontested. Contrast with 2007 when a flock of candidates lined up in the ward to contest for a seat vacated by an incumbent rather than a candidate who wants to stay in his seat.

The city council will discuss this issue on whether or not to hold the election in his ward anyway which would allow for write-in candidates hopefully before they or most of them blanket endorse him in his election or appointment. Because yes, if the election is called off, MacArthur would be a city council appointed representative for Ward Five, not an elected candidate from that ward. That's something for MacArthur and the city council and mayor to keep in mind when they discuss this issue on March 22. Do they want to elect MacArthur to represent Ward Five or allow the ward's voters to do so themselves?

The city including the voters in Ward Five will find out this Tuesday.





Ward Seven:

Steve Adams

John Brandriff

Terry Frizzel


This race started out looking like it was going to be between incumbent, Steve Adams and challenger John Brandriff until Terry Frizzel who just missed winning the election by about a dozen votes last time entered into the race, potentially increasing the odds for a runoff election (and thus a longer campaign season) quite a bit. Races with three candidates don't always result in runoffs but many times they do. How will the balance of the election in this ward shift with Frizzel in the race, or will it? It's going to mean burning more shoe leather for the candidates in the La Sierra area but they're some good pairs on sale at various venues.

Campaigning for all three candidates will be crucial as the race will likely be over for at least one of the candidates in the June mail-in election. So no one can afford to be relaxed in their political campaigns up to when those ballots start get mailed in by voters from that ward.




Drop the Take Home Cars Already




The Press Enterprise Editorial Board has this issue by the teeth involving the ongoing issue of take home cars. And it has once again stated that the city has to address this issue and provide more than fuzzy math to explain the costs to the tax payers. They should just scrap the whole cars to council cars period and go back to a car allowance that's accountable and transparent to the city's residents. And they should also lose all those post it notes which makes you wonder how many expenditures of the residents' tax money are recorded using similarly dubious methods.

And did any of the independent audits including the ones done by Mayer Hoffman McCann catch or make notice or warn the city about using the post-it method for recording financial expenditures? Apparently not, or those warnings were ignored because former Asst. City Manager Tom DeSantis was still trying to pass off post its as good accounting and recording practices. Speaking of DeSantis, Hudson has allegedly been doing a soft shoe shuffle to distance himself from his former sidekick by telling newer people working for the city that DeSantis had "bad" relationships with certain entities.

Hudson had in DeSantis' final weeks tossed under a bus or two but DeSantis' departure was not due to this but his own behavior. During his tenure, DeSantis had micromanaged the police department almost down to the penny but he had competition for engaging in micromanagement mania with City Attorney Gregory Priamos who had matched him action for action. So far, Chief Sergio Diaz has apparently kept Priamos at a distance and a bit out of the loops, which Priamos (who allegedly has a "shrine" to law enforcement in his office) won't like that one bit. But that action done by Diaz would have been long overdo, because when it's getting to the point where Priamos wanted police equipment including lights on his city-issued car, that's just way too far.

But Diaz doesn't work for Priamos, he works for Hudson and it remains to be seen what will ultimately happen in that relationship.

Nothing good has come out of it from the cold plate scandals to mysterious incidents involving damage to cars (and yes, a fence post through the undercarriage of a vehicle would qualify) to city residents subsidizing the costs of council members to use vehicles for personal business and vacations. Many people can't afford to keep their own cars or fuel them up or fix them (especially after they hit hundreds of new potholes) so how can the city residents be expected to foot these costs for elected officials?

But the PE does a good job at explaining how ridiculous it gets. The faces from some elected officials on the dais are classic when city residents ask for little things like accountability and transparency when spending money, in the face of all the problems and scandals that have been uncovered or are waiting to be.


(excerpt)




The latest revelations from City Hall exhibit yet more confusion about this perk. Council members can drive the city cars on personal trips, as long as they report that largesse as income to the Internal Revenue Service. But city officials give differing accounts of how that approach works in practice.

In 2009, four of the five council members then driving city cars claimed on their taxes that half the mileage was for public business and half was for personal trips. One councilman claimed no personal mileage that year. Councilman Steve Adams said last week that the city uses the 50/50 split on mileage to ensure council members don't underpay taxes, though Council Andy Melendrez thought the division would be 60/40. City Finance Director Brett Mason said the city has no formula, and that council members are responsible for reporting their personal mileage totals for tax purposes.

Well, that certainly clears matters up. City records might throw light on how often council members drive the public cars on private trips -- except that the city does not track the vehicles' use. So taxpayers have no way of knowing how much of the 19,494 miles Adams listed for 2009 were on public business, or why he drove his city car 10,000-plus miles more than Councilman William "Rusty" Bailey did that year.

The city should be embarrassed by an official privilege no one can interpret coherently. And the fact that the city hands people free cars and gas with no questions asked should make taxpayers uncomfortable. Slapdash oversight of public assets is unacceptable practice.

Riverside residents understand that doing the public's business does entail expenses. But city policies should ensure that those costs are verified and justifiable, and not just wild guesses billed to taxpayers.



Councilman Paul Davis is surrendering his city-owned vehicle.

Adams has also apparently surrendered his car in the light of these unresolved issues popping up especially during an election year. Because if city officials are using their city cars for personal use, it's pretty much a given that the voters will make their feelings on that well known during an election year.


Police Department to Sponsor Open House





[Chief Sergio Diaz, Deputy Chief Jeffrey Greer and Asst. Chief Chris Vicino in quieter times but is something brewing behind the scenes?]



Chief Sergio Diaz and his cabinet will take a break from welcoming the department's newest hires to hold an open house at the Magnolia Policing Center for the newly revamped Community Services Division housed at Orange Street Station.

Some say it's critical for Diaz in particular as a chief, because being the chief's not an easy job, but by Thursday, everyone should be in good spirits to welcome community members to the station to educate them on a division that was disbanded several years ago under the former chief. Crime-Free Multi-Housing, Youth Court and other services are umbrellaed under this new division. Acceptance letters are already going out for the newly reopened Citizen Academy. But the job as a chief is to keep your management team close and never take your eyes off of them because you might not know what they've been up to when you're not looking because the last permanent chief didn't look. And when someone's been a busy bee, that's his responsibility to address just as much as if it's in a negative way as in a positive.

Thursday, March 24 at 10 am. at Magnolia Police Station on Magnolia near La Sierra in that little mall. It will be hosted by the management team as well as Lt. Guy Touissant and Sgt. Dan Warren who lead that division.




Local Organization Cites Lack of Diversity on Charter Review Committee



Jennifer Vaughn-Blakely wrote this letter in response to the selection of nine White city residents to the Charter Review Committee despite the fact that members of that racial group comprise about 39% of the city's current population. This blog had already cited that in a previous posting on the selection process for the Charter Review Committee by the city council and mayor. Applicants of different races applied for the committee but of those forwarded to the city council for interview by the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee, all of them were White. One Latina was submitted as a member of Councilwoman Nancy Hart's ward and was chosen as second alternate.

But the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee's screening process has always been problematic, not as much from a racial or gender perspective as the fact that this Committee tends to forward mainly names that its members are familiar with. The mantra that is commonly used on that Committee has often been cited here and that's the following:


Member #1 (holding application): Do you know this person?

Member #2: No, I have no idea who they are, do you?

Member #3 (shakes head) ----

It usually goes into the reject pile UNLESS....


Member #4: Wait a minute there, I saw this person at [this meeting or this social event] and such and such and such...



The application gets snatched from the rejected pile and put in the interview pile. So too often it comes down to whether or not the member of this committee knows a particular person and if someone applies who they don't know, they often act as if it's that person's fault for not being "involved" in the *right* places or things even if they're active in their communities. But when you come and think about it, part of the job of an elected official is getting out into their wards, all its communities and neighborhoods to get out and know the people they represent. So if they don't "know" a particular person, then in a sense he or she has failed as well. Some people who have good applications including long-time involvement in various areas of civic and community life just aren't on the "right" places (or have no prior board or commission experience) and get overlooked.

As for the lack of diversity, it just seems that for most of the members of that screening committee not to mention the city council seem to be much more familiar with the applicants who are White than those of other racial backgrounds. There's some exceptions but that's been mostly the rule in some years of witnessing how the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee works as well as city council and mayoral interviews of candidates. In many ways, it still appears to be pretty much an insiders club.

UPDATE: Special Governmental Affairs Committee meeting to be held Tuesday, March 22 at 1 pm in the Mayor's Ceremonial room to address appointing additional people to the Charter Review Committee




Melendrez Faces Heat; Quiet Zones Added to Eastside




[Councilman (and 2012 mayoral candidate) Andrew Melendrez faced intense complaints from ward residents about the lack of quiet zones in the Eastside]




Riverside's Eastside will be getting two quiet zones after criticism arose involving actions taken by Riverside's City Council. This happened when the city council voted on a motion involving the Perris Valley Metrolink project which included in fine print that the city would be placing the fourth ranked Third Street grade separation on the indefinite back burner and then be funneling some of that money to quiet zones outside of that area. But criticism arose including by community leaders so the addition of these "quiet zones" was added onto a "revised" city council agenda for March 15's meeting.

The excuses for the lack of ability to fund raise still don't wash at all especially since the fifth ranked Iowa grade separation has its requisite funding along with those three grade separations which preceded the Third Street project. Not to mention they were originally planning as early as 2007 to actually funnel the funding for the Third Street separation to a belatedly added one in Madison Street in Casa Blanca mainly as a means to reinvigorate the plans to "finish" Overlook Parkway, essentially working towards completing the expressway, more commonly referred to as locals as the "Highway to Hell". Without this grade separation prioritized for funding, the "Highway" can't be completed. So there's some speculation that might ultimately be behind the Eastside losing the construction of the grade separation which would have prevented trains from two companies from blocking a main thoroughfare into several neighborhoods. If emergency vehicles suddenly can't get through Third or Seventh (or Spruce) depending on how far the train's gone before it stops, it's supposed they can always go around and hopefully no one will die in the meantime.

Stop the Highway to Hell is a site with more information including a FAQ section on that whole situation.




A former councilman in Corona has plead guilty to making false statements.






Public Meetings



Monday, March 21 at 3 pm inside City Hall, the second community meeting on the response by Riverside to its Sister City Sendai which has been hit hard by a 9.0 earthquake and tsunami.



Tuesday, March 22 at 3 pm and 6:30 pm, City Council chambers, the city council and hopefully the mayor will be meeting to discuss this agenda. Among the items discussed in closed session is the workman's compensation claim filed by former (and now retired) Riverside Police Department K9 officer, Allen Jaekel.

Not to mention this item on whether to hold an election in June involving Councilman Chris MacArthur, the only candidate filing for the fifth ward seat. The city stated it would save about $55,000 not to hold the election but if they decided not to, it would prohibit write in candidates and most recent, the precedent has been to hold the election anyway.

Wednesday, March 23, at 4 pm and 5:30 pm, at City Hall is the Community Police Review Commission's meeting to discuss this agenda. Items including discussing the annual report and whether or not the police department should change its personnel complaint form.






[CPRC while it was trying to conduct its wild election earlier this month]

Thursday, March 24 at 10 am, at the Magnolia Policing Center near Tyler Mall is the open house for the newly revamped Community Services Division.



Event



40th Anniversary Memorial Service for Leonard A. Christiansen and Paul C. Teel

April 2, at 10 am at the Mission Inn in Downtown Riverside

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, March 08, 2011

Never a Dull Moment in River City

"We're Not Running Away"

---Michiko Otsuki



(excerpt)

'As a worker at Tepco and a member of the Fukushima No. 2 reactor team, I was dealing with the crisis at the scene until yesterday (Monday).'

'In the midst of the tsunami alarm (last Friday), at 3am in the night when we couldn't even see where we going, we carried on working to restore the reactors from where we were, right by the sea, with the realisation that this could be certain death,' she said.

'The machine that cools the reactor is just by the ocean, and it was wrecked by the tsunami. Everyone worked desperately to try and restore it. Fighting fatigue and empty stomachs, we dragged ourselves back to work.

'There are many who haven't gotten in touch with their family members, but are facing the present situation and working hard.'

Battling On

'Please remember that. I want this message to reach even just one more person. Everyone at the power plant is battling on, without running away.

'To all the residents (around the plant) who have been alarmed and worried, I am truly, deeply sorry.

'I am writing my name down, knowing I will be abused and hurt because of this. There are people working to protect all of you, even in exchange for their own lives.

'Watching my co-workers putting their lives on the line without a second thought in this situation, I'm proud to be a member of Tepco, and a member of the team behind Fukushima No. 2 reactor.

'I hope to return to the plant and work on the restoration of the reactor.'




Sendai Relief fund: $42,447.37


Rescue Relief Rebuild



The Sendai Committee met yesterday to discuss steps to take in responding to the emergency situation in Sendai. Ted Honcharik of Fuel Relief Fund has left for Sendai to transport generators and fuel that will be purchased before as was done in Haiti after the earthquake there.

A skeleton crew of workers are fighting to prevent a total meltdown at various reactors at Fukushima and are getting police to fire a water cannon at one of the pools that stores spent rods (which is probably the most problematic situation besides that at Reactor 2). The U.S. has sent nuclear energy experts to Japan and monitors to Hawaii and the California coastline.

The risk to the western U.S. is viewed as minimal at this point.

For more information from the State Department of Health: (916) 341-3947

The committee says that some people more close to the center of Sendai (i.e. downtown and City Hall) have responded to check in that they're doing okay. Areas outlying near the coast still are not responding. The entire delta region by the coast was hit by the tsunami with miles/kilometers reach inland different depending on the location in proximity to the epicenter of the now 9.0 quake. The local university was heavily damaged by the quake and is inaccessible. At least one museum survived in pretty good shape and individuals at the Metropolitan Museum downtown (which is undergoing seismic retrofitting) might consider sending a delegation to help with any needed work on the museums in Sendai later on.

Electricity, water and other infrastructure issues are still serious problems in the area as is phones. Still many sizable aftershocks. The real time maps show the aftershock activity is moving south through the Pacific Ocean off the coast of Japan.



[City residents and community leaders pack the Mayor's Ceremonial room during a meeting on responding to the earthquake and tsunami in Sendai]



****Sendai's Mayor Katsuhiko Umehara and his staff and the member of Sendai's IRC are all accounted for but not sure about members of the Orange Club. A lot of uncertainty about whether people are deceased, or missing due to evacuations or lack of ability to communicate as mobile phones and internet were down. Sendai City Hall did email Riverside about what was happening there.

***Riverside's Urban Search and Rescue Team is currently fifth on the list for deployment but maybe be prioritized higher. Designated primary responders from Los Angeles deployed from March Air Reserve Base on Saturday with supplies and have reached a town up in Northern Japan impacted by earthquake and tsunami damage. USAR Teams from Mexico (and Acapulco is also Sendai's Sister City) and Christchurch, New Zealand have reached Sendai. Ironically the USAR team based on Japan had been deployed to Christchurch to help them with their Feb. 22 6.3 earthquake when the 8.9 quake happened off the shore of Sendai.


*****Ted Honcharik ifrom Fuel Relief Fund is leaving for Japan in several days hopefully with $50,000 to purchase fuel over there to distribute for free up around Sendai. As you know, Sendai is currently out of food, potable water in many places and nearly out of fuel.

His contact information is:

phone: 951-233-0283

Fax: 951-680-1993

email: troncharik@fuelrelieffund.org


****Riverside and Riverside's International Relations Committee is setting up an electronic donation fund for checks and hopefully pay pal in the upcoming days at City Hall 3900 Main St. or call Mayor Ron Loveridge's office at 951-826-5551

***Several fund raising events are also planned including a possible MLK Jr. band concert at the Fox Theater in Riverside around March 31.







Sendai monument near Riverside City Hall





[The 1998 Sister City teams for the Sendai Half Marathon before the race including Riverside's delegation]



UPDATE: 8.8 quake strikes North-Eastern Japan off coast trigger tsunamis. The quake hit about 60 miles east of Riverside's Sister City Sendai which faced major tsunami damage.

Sendai hit by 10 foot wave. Damage "devastating, at least 300 dead"

Two Riverside city officials said that they will ask city to respond. Mayor Ron Loveridge's office says city is "working" on coordinating its response to the disaster. Riverside to send urban rescue team to Sendai.

Riverside officials said they are discussing how best to aid Sendai and may help create a local donation fund. For now they are directing residents to the American Red Cross, which is taking donations online at riversidecounty.redcross.org or by calling 888-831-8031.


I had the fortunate experience of traveling to Sendai, Japan in 1998 with other runners, coaches and trainers on the Riverside delegation entered in the Sendai Half Marathon. Other sister cities came from France, Mexico, China, Belarus and Dallas Texas also participated. From the moment we landed at Sendai International Airport (the only delegation to fly directly to the city), to the moment we departed, the people of Sendai were the most gracious hosts and very friendly and they hold Riverside in very high esteem. Riverside and its people do not have a bigger fan club in this entire planet than in Sendai. In front of City Hall, there's the Raincross symbol and there is a very descriptive diorama of Riverside's downtown in one of the museums.

Sendai was devastated by the 8.8 earthquake and tsunami with at least 300 dead so far and many more missing. Many of the images of the tsunami going through the coastal area shown on TV are of Sendai including its fishing community as one of the area's main industries is fishing.

Riverside Councilmen Mike Gardner, Rusty Bailey and Chris MacArthur have so far responded to emails requesting that Riverside respond to this crisis impacting its Sister City. Since 1957, the two cities have been in this relationship, the longest still active such relationship in the world. Riverside needs to be a "sister" and engage in sending assistance and aid to Sendai and hopefully will along with the International Council of Riverside send its support.


An interesting article on the Feb. 22 Christchurch, New Zealand which discusses the ground acceleration forces that made it nearly impossible for most buildings even those built to higher earthquake standards to survive intact.




Riverside fifth on national list for failed job recovery which kind of shows that even with redevelopment agencies, they couldn't spark new jobs.





[Former Councilman and current mayoral candidate Ed Adkison represents his company at the Finance Committee meeting on business tax enforcement]




Retire RPD Detective Takes Legal Action



Former Riverside Police Department Det. Chris Lanzillo who left the department last year allegedly took legal action against Police Chief Sergio Diaz and City Manager Brad Hudson in the wake of comments that Diaz made to the Press Enterprise about Lanzillo’s termination and resultant lawsuit that he filed against the city, department and employees including former Acting Chief John DeLaRosa and current Deputy Chief Mike Blakely.

That lawsuit settled last year overturned Lanzillo’s termination and he was medically retired and received a financial settlement and back pay minus a week’s suspension. It had alleged that former Riverside Police Officers’ Association President Chris Lanzillo was the subject of an investigation in connection with a training session and terminated after he had verbally confronted DeLaRosa during one of the management team’s roll call bull sessions after the Feb. 8, 2010 DUI incident involving the former police chief. DeLaRosa had shown up at roll call sessions often with the entire management team in tow to rally the officers to stick together as “one big family” and not to talk to the bloggers or the press.

Lanzillo allegedly then had said that the handling of the DUI incident should have been done differently and asked DeLaRosa why he had waited over 30 hours to hand the investigation to the California Highway Patrol. Not long after that, a supervisor who had not attended the training and witnessed the incident filed a complaint and the incident was investigated involving insensitive comments in a diversity training class. Lanzillo had allegedly said he made similar comments in the past and the department investigated several years back and no one recalled it so he was allegedly given a notice of intent of termination for lying. If that’s truly the case of how the events unfolded, then that’s got to be one of the most bizarre terminations ever…at least in recent history. For admitting that you made a racial comment several years earlier…and because no one can remember it, recollect it or perhaps don’t want to be asked by investigators why if they heard it they never reported it and then being investigated for that, firing an employee. It's bizarre in the face of other employees who were caught making racial comments and were given other jobs inside the city's employment after leaving the police department.

And leaving the final decision to another employee who allegedly also received a notice of intent to terminate around the same time or even the same day as Lanzillo and how was a subject officer in the most publicized internal investigation of the year…who incidentally had been publicly challenged by Lanzillo who asked the same questions that City Hall and investigators should have been asking DeLaRosa.

Almost as bizarre as having a subject officer on the year’s most publicized internal investigation present or involved in the interrogation of a “witness” officer in that same case simply because he was acting chief at the time. If it had been a criminal investigation would you have the suspect of the crime be present during the interview of a witness? Of course not. No, this might not have been as serious as a criminal investigation but the two share some similar reasons as why it might not be prudent to have the subject person in the same vicinity as a witness during an interrogation to gain information for an investigation.

Just another reason on a stack of them not to have all that much faith in Hudson’s “independent” and “sweeping” (the surface) investigation. Just another reason on a stack of them not to have all that much faith in Hudson’s “independent” and “sweeping” (the surface) investigation.

When discussing Lanzillo, Diaz had said that he had “done very bad things” without specifying what they were to the press and Lanzillo had been concerned about that because any prospective employer or other person could do a search on the internet and see the comments by a police chief and think he had done something like child molestation or a serious crime.

This incident allegedly had taken place after Diaz and Lanzillo had an emotionally charged verbal altercation outside one of the police facilities over the lawsuit. After the comments were made, one of the leaders of the RPOA contacted Diaz and asked what was up with that and Diaz allegedly told him he got emotional and it was a mistake.

The city has the option of deciding how to handle it and whether or not to litigate it to trial. Diaz had raised an important point in the Press Enterprise about how too many lawsuits have been settled by the city (which is now self-insured after having had a carrier at one time) rather than taken to trial. I agree with his point although my reasoning might be somewhat different. The city settles for two reasons, to preserve its civil liability or to minimize the risks and to prevent publicity of the surrounding issues in lawsuits. It’s hard to buy the city’s argument that it settles to save litigation costs after seeing how aggressively it’s litigated and fought several labor lawsuits include those filed by a group of Black city employees in 1997 and Officer Roger Sutton’s filed in 2000 and tried by a civil jury in 2005. But then Diaz also allegedly has been working to minimize City Attorney Gregory Priamos' historic micromanagement of the police department which if so is a hopeful and long overdue development in that troublesome area.

There's this pattern of events that was relayed in an earlier Press Enterprise article.

Those officers only file lawsuits or claims when they get in trouble. That’s an interesting point but what would make an interesting study in contrasts is how those numbers that align with his contention stack up against officers who file complaints that are handled inhouse (and not known publicly), then get into “trouble” and then file more public claims and lawsuits alleging mistreatment or misconduct including retaliation. Add in officers who have very little prior contact with complaints or internal investigations initiated against them who suddenly have multiple complaints open or investigations open against them after complaints of mistreatment or misconduct or those who after they file complaints may know or not know that meetings have been called between individuals at Orange Street administrative offices and the department’s Internal Affairs Divisions on discussing those officers soon after they file grievances, claims or lawsuits.

Then provide stats on how many cases are settled, how many go to trial and what the end results are in both cases including average payouts per settlement and/or trial verdicts. All of this together would make for a very interesting sociological study or research paper, maybe a thesis for a doctorate as to what the outcomes would be and any conclusions which could be reached.






The Charter Review Committee Gets Ready To Meet


The Charter Committee is set to already start meeting and all the various agendas that are contingent on charter changes will start popping up for “discussion” at these meetings. One of those will no doubt be the future of the city’s only business, Riverside Public Utilities as there’s serious discussions taking place in different venues about trying to push for an initiative which will increase the percentage of funding which can be taken from RPU to pay for the city’s bills. The problem is that RPU has its own expenses like any company would to pay out of its monies made and one of the debates out there hands down is how much money that RPU has that’s really being spent by the city for outside expenditures.

If you’ve ever wondered how Riverside Renaissance is going to be funded, this can be a critical development to follow. Because people act as if the Renaissance has been paid for and news flash, a lot of it is deferred payment not actual payment and since Riverside’s not making enough money on sales tax and property taxes which are recession-sensitive, how else will these bonds or other forms of deferred payment be done? And will the RPU be liable to shifting a larger percentage of its earned money to do this and pay for other outside expenses? If it passes the muster of the city’s voters, how will this impact them? The answer to that is easy, higher rates for water and electricity (which after the “freeze”, you might have to buckle your seat belts at some of the rate hikes that have been proposed) because how else will RPU make the money to offset a higher payout to the city to spend? Money comes from some resource and the bulk of the Renaissance will likely wind up on the backs of the residents in ways not exacted yet.

But remember when the city council passed and then revoked (because they were election-sensitive) that mult-tier hike that counted amps instead of actual kilowatts used? And the uproar that followed which pressured some council members who were facing elections to back peddle?

What adds a lot of intrigue to this discussion will be the fact that the city council and mayor quickly appointed Tom Evans to the chair position of the Charter Review Committee. Evans is currently an elected official serving on the local water board, was interim city manager before Hudson’s arrival and his expertise was of course, RPU which he oversaw for four years before his appointment in the interim management position. If eking out a larger piece of RPU earnings comes to the committee, how will Evans react?

Stay tuned to see this situation as it pans out, whether it does now or not with RPU, City Hall and the city residents. Because what is ultimately decided could really impact and hit home that the costs of the $2 billion plus Renaissance haven’t even begun to come out of your pockets. Yes, there are definite advantages to having a municipal public utilities entity but it takes responsibility on the parts of the stake holders including city residents to keep an eye on what’s happening and to voice concerns about it too including the charter review process in connection with a valued resource.






CPRC Hold Another Wacky Election

Elects Chair, Vice-Chair



[The CPRC members minus one in Missouri conducted their annual elections]






The Community Police Review Commission engaged in its annual exercise of holding its election for chair and vice-chair. All of the members showed up including the three new members, to conduct the special meeting and to elect their new officers, except for Robert Slawsby who appeared via conference call in Missouri. Rogalio Morales was absent for a short period and missed the first round of elections for both chair and vice-chair.

For chair, Commissioner Ken Rotker nominated outgoing vice-chair Art Santore for chair and Commissioner John Brandriff nominated Dale Roberts. The voting broke down with Santore, Slawsby, Rotker, Ralph Johnson and Robin Jackson voting for Santore who had the five votes necessary to win. Roberts received votes from Brandriff, herself and Jane Adams.

For vice-chair, Rotker nominated Slawsby and Brandriff nominated Roberts. For that the voting became more complicated, because it resulted in a 4-4 tie. Voting for Slawsby were himself, Rotker, Santore and Johnson while Roberts received votes from herself, Brandriff, Jackson and Adams. There was some legal consultation; most of it outside the ability of the public and several commissioners to even hear let alone to follow what took place. At the end, they decided to table the vote for vice-chair to the next meeting when Morales could attend since the CPRC was not required to appoint a vice-chair at the first meeting in March only a chair.

But then Morales appeared and then there was a debate on whether to table the election or revote for vice chair in hopes of having him serve as the tie breaker. It became clear when Morales was polled for his vote that the election would go to Roberts as everyone voted the same as they had in the prior round and he gave his vote to Roberts.

Never a dull moment with a CPRC election as the whole issue of allowing certain individuals teleconferencing votes in the past and not others not to mention the behind the scenes election several years that took place before March of that year have made it clear that there’s been issues with it electing its officers. But in this particular election year, the most pivotal and important position may actually be that of the vice-chair for reasons that could further to light moving through the calendar year when the makeup of the commission might change on several fronts.




Former Councilman Dom Betro Mixes Up the Facts



During a recent debate by the Greater Democrats of Riverside, two candidates for ward one showed up because only the registered Democrats in that race were allowed to participate. These were former Councilman Dom Betro who lost a squeaker of an election in 2007 and also Marisa Valdez-Yeager who is opposing him and two other candidates. Betro provided some colorful participation by engaging in some commentary. One of his claims was that as a councilman, he didn't push the action to ban city residents from pulling items off the consent calendar which the city council did during a meeting in 2005.

Baloney as one person put it upon hearing his claim at the forum. He most absolutely did push for it when he sponsored the motion that put that issue on the table, and the intent of the motion was to restrict who could pull items from the consent calendar.

At least Betro didn't promise he would "look into" that decision that was made as that's the least adhered to campaign promise made by elected officials so far. No one has looked into it.


But check this minute order from July 12, 2005 yourself. It takes some scrolling down and the agenda item numbers (in this case #55) aren't numbered but you'll find it under City Council Rules of Procedure... and follow the voting columns for the motion, the second and the votes cast by each council member on the right hand side. You'll see that Betro sponsored the motion that included restrictions on the consent calendar. Councilman Steve Adams seconded it, and it passed 6-1 with former Councilman Art Gage the only candidate not voting for it.

So former city council members running for reelection again shouldn't engage in revisionist history. The proof is in this case, the minutes. But Betro in his own unique style did spark up some controversy at the DGR by telling the organization which sponsored his appearance that it had to better police itself apparently against bogus Democrats or those not card-carrying or whatever. He didn't get the endorsement, but said he didnt't want it and then complained later that some of the people who asked questions shouldn't have been allowed to ask them including that embarrassing one about the consent calendar because he wasn't seeking an endorsement.




The Mystery of the Disappearing Employees



Riverside is one of those cities where you never know what’s happening half of the time and it’s easy to miss some of the intrigue that takes place and hence, there’s a section in this blog which deals with the mystery of the missing employees. Occasionally there will be an employee profiled who’s disappeared off the canvas especially if the rest of the city clams up about it.

That’s the case with the abrupt departure of former Homeless coordinator Don Smith who is no longer employed with the city and Human Resources apparently won’t even elaborate to their boss’ bosses about what happened. There have been several employees who have left under confusing or even disturbing circumstances including long-time City Hall employee Howard Field and several in Development and even the city’s Human Resources Department. These employees had a common denominator or two which makes one wonder if one of the city’s exorcised ghosts is resurfacing and will be addressed in future postings.

This one came to light involving Smith because people who worked with the homeless or are interested in those issues tried to contact Smith not too long ago and were unable to do so and couldn’t find out what happened or even who to call instead or if the position will be filled. See, that’s typical of the Riverside canvas, is that employees just have a way of disappearing from it…poof…but whether he was a layoff casualty, took a job elsewhere or something else happened. Or if his position’s been phased out, frozen or it will be filled and what will happen to the system of addressing homeless issues and populations that he oversaw.

It’s not lost that the class of employees with some of the largest institutional memories of this city’s history particularly how it’s run and how it conducts business are the ones that are kind of on phase out lately.






The Unwanted Highway to Hell

City residents veto continuation of Overlook Parkway at Public Hearing



A large group of city residents said we don't want a new highway at a public hearing held to discuss an environmental impact report. The emphasis of the hearing was supposed to be whether or not the gates at Crystal View Terrace and Green Orchard Road which had been the subject of many contentious meetings but the concerns shifted to what people view as an attempt to revive the drive to finish Overlook Parkway which was thwarted by residents of two neighborhoods who stand in the path of that construction some time ago. What's interesting too about this process is that part of the planning on finishing the thoroughfare is to put a grade separation at Madison which some say will be funded by the money that had been earmarked for the higher priority grade separation on Third Street that was recently tanked in some small print without the appropriate public hearing.

It's not paranoia that had people concerned. It's the realization that of the four scenarios, the city actually included finishing this street so someone somewhere in the halls of power are thinking about it. The one that would could pit neighborhoods against each other and potentially bring traffic, and create larger problems in the already vanishing green belt area of the city not to mention what it would do to Victoria Avenue, the only street that seems more like a park than a thoroughfare and one of the nicest spots of the city.




Christchurch, New Zealand to lose World Rugby Cup?

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, March 03, 2011

A Heat Wave in Riverside?

UPDATE:

Retired RPD detective files claim against police chief, city manager?





It's Beginning to Look A lot Like 2011.





[After a long dormancy period, work has diligently been done on the downtown library in Riverside, the butt of jokes by City Hall not long ago]




[The Riverside Museum before its new face lift, not bad to look at but would you want to be next to it in a major quake?]





[The Riverside Metropolitan Museum undergoes a face lift]



Press Enterprise Columnist and musician Dan Bernstein wrote several columns about the neglect of City Hall towards its downtown library facility which had degraded to the extent that it had become the butt of humor at city council meetings. But it's no joke to the employees who work there (and had already been given a gag order on talking by a former library director) and to the people who patronage who are from all age groups and walks of life. They have really good programs there from those who kids to the AARP helping people with their income tax returns.

Women were told by library employees when the bathroom was out of order to walk to the Mission Inn or City Hall to use their bathrooms. Men were using the women's bathroom (and surprising women) when theirs was out of order. A library director and the system director did finally open the staff's bathroom to women until the bathroom was fixed and said that men weren't allowed to use the women's bathroom. The roofs leaked and huge portions of the second floor had been vacated and cordoned off.

But Bernstein's columns did make a difference, not to mention it's an election cycle which always helps, and the library has seen renovations done including painting on the second floor. Issues with backup (from a sewer system venting gases back past a toilet's trap) backing up and making the place smell like a sewer are hopefully being addressed.

The downtown library serves an important function and Bernstein's right when he said that any person coming to Riverside if they saw the library might say "beam me up Scotty".

But what a difference one year makes

Speaking of libraries, it seems that Marcy is going to be a restaurant. One wonders how much renovation of this historic building will be required given it wasn't designed to house one. If it's to be "preserved" as part of the deal, how much of it will be left after the required renovations?

I guess we'll all find out down the always winding road that leads back to River City. But at least in recent weeks, it's clear someone changed the course of the S.S. Hudson and got some basic renovations done to the library which sorely needs much more than that to do it justice.




Oh What Tangled Webs We Weave...

Did Riverside Police Department Brass Muscle a Deputy Chief onto the Sidelines?




[Was he ordered to retire to put him out of running for the chief's spot?]




[Deputy Chief Mike Blakely (l) with Chief Sergio Diaz at a RUSD meeting]






[The top candidate for chief lauded by City Hall...until the release of his cell phone records]





[Oh, the irony if it's true that former Asst. City Manager Tom DeSantis ordered Esquivel to retire...only in River City]




This blog wrote last year about dual claims filed against the police department and city by Former Deputy Chief Pete Esquivel and Officer Neely Nakamura involving allegations of extortion and retaliation against them by members of both the police department's management team and city management employees.

The claims were denied by the city which is pretty much routine and Nakamura filed a lawsuit in Riverside County Superior Court through lawyer Michael McGill from Lackie & Dammeier and McGill, a police firm that's been through some interesting upheaval itself in the past few year.

The lawsuit outlines a chain of events detailed below that allegedly took place that were similar to the versions in the earlier claims that stemmed from the Feb. 8, 2010 traffic stop involving former Chief Russ Leach and its aftermath. To call it disturbing in its content would be a tremendous understatement, the allegations are pretty horrific and if as alleged, paint a truly disturbing portrait of what was going on in the upper echelons of power both inside the Riverside Police Department and City Hall's Seventh Floor as well.

An RPD that wasn't built overnight.

As you know, Leach was pulled over in his black Chrysler 300 by two officers who were heard on the COBAN video recording as talking about what a political train wreck it was, even waving another officer away from the scene. They were right in their assessment because even though these were relatively new patrol officers, they knew where they were working and about unwritten rules about preferential treatment even as City Manager Brad Hudson and a choir of his followers claimed otherwise. The fact that City Hall already apparently had a loosey goosey policy in place to have all police interactions with "high profile" folks reported to the city management tells you that.

But for Deputy Chief Pete Esquivel, he apparently didn't learn about the traffic stop involving Leach and how it wasn't handled until the next morning despite being in charge of field operations (including patrol) and investigations. Sgt. Frank Orta (now medically retired) told CHP investigators that he was fearful of Esquivel's request to talk with him after he had been instructed to write his infamous "traffic collision" report on the Leach incident. But he had been asked to sign it because Lt. Leon Phillips hadn't done that, not only hadn't he signed Orta's report as his supervisor but he had informed Esquivel that he wanted his name removed from the captain's candidate list.

That should have rang more than a few bells but alas, apparently not.

Deputy Chief Esquivel allegedly expressed concern about being ordered to sign a police report and the manner in which the Leach incident was handled. He was concerned that laws were broken in the process, that DeLaRosa had failed to take action and that he was being purposely left out of the loop.

DeLaRosa was named acting chief by Hudson and Asst. Chief Tom DeSantis after Leach went on medical leave. DeLaRosa also became favored for chief position because City Hall considered him a team player. He was seen as being easily influenced and was uniformly praised by city officials as being the best fit for the city. This was of course before records from his city issued cell phone tied him to the scene of the Leach traffic stop.

It's a bit odd that those in City Hall who are paid six figured salaries including Hudson who was the highest paid city manager in the state behind that guy from Bell wouldn't even consider that DeLaRosa as second in command behind Leach might have ties to what happened that early morning at Arlington and Rutland. One would think that since the city management was doing this "independent" and "sweeping" investigation of the incident that they would get DeLaRosa checked out before putting him in the interim spot.

But you could hurt your head trying to figure out why Hudson and DeSantis did or didn't do the most basic and sensible actions.

Esquivel alleged that he was a viable police candidate in opposition to DeLaRosa and that he had to be discredited by City Hall. So that they would dig up dirt and muddy up his name to get Delarosa promoted to chief and retaliate against Esquivel, according to the lawsuit.

In early March, Esquivel called in for interview lasting about 90 minutes purportedly as a witness but he felt he was a target. It was about Leach’s vehicle’s status and location which was an evidence bay at the Magnolia Police Station behind shielding almost as if there was an attempt made to hide it. He said before he got involved, the car had been placed in the evidence bay “for repair” rather than being locked down as evidence in connection with any investigation. Esquivel ordered the car be locked down and not touched.

At some point, allegedly Deputy Chief Mike Blakely (then the Personnel Captain and in charge of Internal Affairs) had illegally obtained transcripts or phone numbers from Esquivel’s phone and Esquivel during that interview was asked about a number he had called frequently despite it having nothing to do with the investigation. Under orders, he said it was Officer Neely Nakamura’s number and they had an intimate relationship private and unknown to the rest of the department. It was a lawful relationship, consensual and both of them did their jobs. That it didn't violate department policies and procedures.

Esquivel was apparently called back in for an Internal Affairs interview as a subject officer by a lawyer, Lt. Mike Cook (who heads Internal Affairs), Sgt. Frank Assumma, Sgt. John Capen and Delarosa who has a subject of the Leach investigation probably shouldn't have been there. While it's true that a police employee can't be compelled to answer questions by someone lower in rank than them, having DeLaRosa who was ultimately also investigated as well present during the interrogation appears to be an inappropriate and highly questionable practice by the department.

Esquivel said he gave the same answers as in his CHP interview on the Leach incident. He said he pressed DeLaRosa to do the investigation and not cover up the investigation. Esquivel showed investigators the text message he got from Delarosa ordering him to sign the traffic report written by Orta.

On April 9, 2010, Esquivel was speaking with plaintiff Nakamura on the phone as she was on her way to work where they were both assigned at the Riverside Police Department's Magnolia Station. He saw Assumma and Capen in the parking lot, unusual since they worked in another building. Esquivel was contacted by Delarosa and told that Internal Affairs needed to meet with him this afternoon and to make himself available to them. Again the assignment of one subject officer on an investigation into a cover up being assigned the chief's position and thus given the job of telling another alleged subject officer to be available for an Internal Affair investigation is just unbelievable.






Riverside Police Department's Administration Headquarters
Orange Street, Downtown Riverside where some intrigue involving management took place in early 2010




Assumma and Capen illegally accosted and detained Nakamura as she left work vehicle in parking lot, according to her lawsuit.

Capen was observed in the parking lot acting in a nervous manner looking around and making furtive movements between the parked cars. As Nakamura arrived at work, he walked between her as she exited her vehicle and said “you have to come with us” Nakamura knew that the two sergeants worked for Internal Affairs and was fearful of their "henchmen reputation for harassment and threatening behavior". Nakamura nervously smiled and tried to ignore Capen. He then stepped in front of her and demanded, “you have to get in the car” Nakamura replied with an uneasy “are you kidding,” Capen said he wasn’t kidding and she had to get in the car now. Assuma held open the back door and indicated for her to enter the vehicle. Capen directed for her to sit in the front seat and Assumma to sit behind as if she were a suspect who would try to escape.






[The downtown police substation which houses the department's Internal Affairs Division





Nakamura was taken to Internal Affairs for several hours of interrogation by Cook, Capen and Blakely. She was repeatedly told she couldn’t leave and had no option but to speak with investigators. She was also told she couldn’t leave until they spoke with Esquivel and had chance to compare notes, presumptively to determine if she were lying. She couldn’t go to bathroom with her personal phone and she was escorted by Assumma who stood outside door. The investigators told her she was a witness and the investigation had been related to whether Esquivel was properly notified about Leach incident.

Nakamura was shown phone records from Esquivel's phone She was asked why she spoke to him so often. She was forced to reveal when her private relationship began, forced to reveal private and confidential information that occurred off-duty and had no connection to her employment. She was forced to admit she had sexual intercourse with Esquivel while off duty. She was also asked about whether her spouse knew about it. She alleged that illegally forwarded copies of intimate messages and photographed copies were made from her phone. Contents of her interview were allegedly circulating around the department within several days.

While she was detained, they took 30 minutes and 15 miles to reach Esquivel and said they needed to talk to him immediately. Blakely said in his office he had a “distasteful matter to discuss” Esquivel said the relationship was private, didn’t interfere with departmental policy and he wasn’t going to discuss it further. Blakely added to Esquivel that it wouldn’t be smart to let this get out and that the interrogation was painful with Nakamura crying. Blakely indicated that it would be incredibly damaging and humiliating if this would get out. Blakely also indicated that unless a deal could be arranged it was the department's intention to immediately relieve him of duty, put him on administrative leave and take away his gun and badge thus relieving him of his police powers.

Blakely told Esquivel there is another way to handle this situation saying that he had a resignation form and if Esquivel signed it nothing would be done and all this information would not get out. Blakely said it would be very embarrassing for him and his family if these details got out and indicated he wasn't bluffing. Esquivel then asked who was behind this and Blakely indicated that they were reporting directly to DeSantis. Esquivel then used his mobile phone to contact DeSantis and indicated that the two needed to talk immediately. DeSantis responds that he should come over and talk with him. As Esquivel gets up to leave, Blakely indicates that he can’t leave the office alone and that they are going to escort him to DeSantis.

Esquivel met with deSantis who says that they no longer need his services and Esquivel asks if they are going through this effort to get rid of him because of the Leach incident or are they trying to muddy up so he can’t be a contender for chief. DeSantis indicated that the city was inundated with calls for support for Esquivel from the community. Esquivel asked if he had any chance for the job and DeSantis said no and to not bother putting in for it.

DeSantis convinced Esquivel to retire and he did and was given 30 days and his letter was typed up and his name spelled wrong. He was acting chief for a while (in contrast to being pressured to surrender his gun and police powers earlier) and given a expensive retirement party on his way out.

Desantis himself would be out of his job and placed on administrative leave in a situation which was about as ironic as could ever be leaving those in the city who knew about it commenting that he wasn't exactly in the best position to make any decisions here.

But the allegations that were alleged in this lawsuit are very disturbing and should see their day in court when those involved are called upon in a public forum called a trial to testify to what happened. Because the city's residents need to know what's been going on behind closed doors at the police department's Orange Street Station and the Seventh Floor at City Hall including the handling of the department and its management by Hudson and others at City Hall.

Nakamura's experience as she relates it is beyond disturbing. Not that they questioned her about the relationship in order to determine that it was consensual and not coercion or sexual harassment but the questioning from the excerpt of the transcript included in the lawsuit seems to push the envelope quite a bit on its scope. Cook and the others in the room had already established that an intimate relationship had taken place yet when they go further to ask graphic questions about sexual acts, it appears gratuitous and frankly done with the purpose of humiliation. Women in the police department who have been interrogated on relationships with male officers in the department apparently face more difficult interrogations than their male counterparts.

Are there moral issues with this type of relationship? Certainly and there are professional complications that might exist as well but there's something called professional interrogation tactics which in a situation like this for a "witness" officer include tact and sensitivity and despite new Chief Sergio Diaz' contention that he felt Blakely and the others went out of their way to be sensitive, if the allegations raised here are true, neither of these elements was practiced at all. It's very telling that the excerpt cited in the claims filed by both officers was taken from Nakamura's interview transcript because that gives some indication there that despite the fact that there were two people in this relationship, that Nakamura received the blunt of the humiliating interrogation tactics and that she was most impacted by them, even though she's the subordinate ranking officer in this situation and she's also the woman.

Did they accost Esquivel in the parking lot, order him in a car and then escort him to the bathroom under guard? No allegations have been raised by him relating a similar experience. In fact he was told by DeLaRosa (again another subject officer) to make himself available to Internal Affairs for interview at about the same time as the alleged incident with Nakamura in the parking lot. If this is what happened, then you have a female subordinate officer being accosted like a suspect in a parking lot by two sergeants (who receive direction from others) and driven to a facility where she spends hours being interrogated to tears, being compelled to answer intimate questions and has to have someone take her to the bathroom without her personal phone. You have a male superior ranking officer who at least during the internal affairs was told to make himself available, refused to discuss his relationship further and there's no mention of intimate questions asked of him about the same relationship as a superior officer involved with a subordinate. If this is what happened, then why was the treatment so disparate with the burden being on Nakamura when it should have been on Esquivel because he's in management?

Just that makes one wonder about what other double standards exist not just between male and females but also lower ranking officers and management personnel in general. If these are the facts presented, then these are more than fair questions to ask.

But then there's the interactions that were related afterward, according to the lawsuit, that detail exchanges between Esquivel and Blakely and then Esquivel (who was told he needed an escort this time) and DeSantis probably the last person who should have been placed in any decision making capacity involving Esquivel given his own rocky time during 2010.

The allegations against Blakely are that he threatened to go public with Esquivel's relationship with Nakamura unless he submitted his resignation, essentially that he blackmailed or extorted Esquivel to take an action he didn't want to take by using content of an internal investigation to do it. Those are extremely serious allegations which are criminal in nature and they definitely need their day in court so that it can be determined by a jury whether it finds enough evidence when the case is presented in court that this behavior took place or didn't take place. And that needs to be done to give some accounting either way in a public forum as the allegations were made public. The residents of the city should know exactly kind of police department it had then and what was going on at the highest levels but will the city allow for that kind of process to take place to address the issues that were raised?

But if that's what did take place, then it's really hard to put into words what that would say about a police department that had already seen more than its share of turbulence in the past 10 years. It's the kind of thing you almost pray won't be true and hope it's not going on inside a law enforcement agency but how would you ever know, if the matters that have been raised her are kept behind closed doors?

A lawsuit is about as public as you can get and it provides a forum in public to deal with issues that perhaps some wish would be handled in private but if the department used those interrogation tactics involving an officer, it needs to explain them on the witness stand at a trial so that city residents can evaluate them. As to why if this took place was there such great differences in the treatment of a female subordinate officer and a male management employee involved in the same situation. It's clear that if the allegations of the lawsuit are true, then Nakamura was simply the means to an end of what took place after her interrogation which was a power play between different management team members of different teams. They made her cry during an interrogation and if they mentioned that to Esquivel, then it would appear to be used as leverage against him as its purpose.

The city has painted Esquivel as basically a corrupt officer with a thick jacket and due to confidentiality laws, the city's not required to explain what it means by that. Those laws which officers fought hard to gain in the 1970s ironically allow individuals to say that so-and-so did very bad things without further elaboration as well. Sometimes you have to ask yourself, who are they really protecting and if laws set up to protect rank and file officers from management have come full circle.

But what the city will have to do if this case goes to jury trial is come up with some explanation through documentation and testimony as to why if Esquivel's the latest evil incarnate, the department and city (as Hudson has final say on all promotions) elevated him several times in the previous five years including to deputy chief. It's going to be very interesting indeed to hear the city explain that to a jury which makes the city's use of that defense (right or wrong) very questionable at best....and at worst, most expensive.

This lawsuit raises many issues and questions about what was going on in the mad, mad world that the Orange Station appeared to be in 2010 in the face of a new changing of the guard with three outside police employees including the new chief in the mix. A lot in the department depends on the examples they set and the practices they implement and that their actions speak at least as loudly as their lips. It's a huge responsibility for anyone and for this blogger, the jury's still out, not just on the department and its leadership (and there's some hopeful areas and areas of very necessary improvement both) but that at City Hall including the City Attorney and City Manager's office who just seem to love micromanaging the police agency. Everyone's seen the outcome of that and it hasn't been pretty.



Speaking of court proceedings, the criminal trial of former Riverside Police Department is scheduled to start soon as March 17 is the final date that his trial on three misdemeanor charges including assault to commit major bodily injury and unauthorized use of a database can take place.

Although Impola was fired by then Chief Russ Leach in early 2010, he was ultimately given a medical retirement by the city.




The Thirst for Redevelopment Agencies


Two city department heads, Paul Sundeen (also an assistant city manager) and Deanna Lorson stump for redevelopment agencies in the Press Enterprise, an action usually reserved for Mayor Ron Loveridge and other politicians. What's interesting is that both Sundeen and Lorson admit that there's been abuses of it but don't say one word really about accountability beyond saying that the city conducts "independent" audits and turns over information for the state. However, Riverside has not offered itself up for the recent audits of 19 agencies being conducted by State Controller John Chiang. Riverside County's own redevelopment agency is being included in that audit but if problems lurk there to be discovered, then due to connective ties between the county and the city, that might incur a closer look at the city as well.

Even as it's been admitted by a city official that there might be some abuses in Riverside's own Redevelopment Agency practices, instead of focusing any attention on how to address those problems and ensure greater accountability and transparency so that abuses don't happen, the city government's primary focus is on rushing projects through. And continuing to act like redevelopment and redevelopment agencies are synonymous. Lest anyone think that this blog is the only place where these concerns are being raised and the questions are being asked, the Press Enterprise wrote this editorial stating that the city's actions to rush projects through do little to inspire confidence by city residents on the accountability of redevelopment agency use.


(excerpt)

Local governments responded to Brown's plan by approving billions of dollars worth of redevelopment projects before the state could act; San Diego alone authorized $4.1 billion in new projects this week. So Brown has proposed legislation that would give the state three years to review and potentially kill local redevelopment plans pushed through since Jan. 1.

The governor -- not to mention the public -- has legitimate reasons to be suspicious of the sudden spike in redevelopment activity. Local agencies did not somehow discover previously unknown areas of blight and decay. Nor do these proposals all reflect the best possible use of redevelopment money over coming decades.

Local officials wanted to keep their hands on the money, and so rushed to commit the funds now regardless of what other needs might arise in the future. Or officials put the money toward vague, ill-defined proposals that exist mainly to ward off state intervention. The motive was turf protection, with civic improvement at best a secondary consideration.

The state should question the validity of those decisions -- and Brown's proposal is too modest, if anything. The state's legislative analyst has long recommended that the state review local redevelopment plans to ensure compliance with state law. Redevelopment history is rife with abuses of the process.



But it's a bit disconcerting to listen to city officials beg, plead and then rush to push bond issuance through. Some officials in particular almost sound as redevelopment agency reliance is a drug and they need their next fix.

More to come...surely.







Surprise!
Riverside City Hall Delays Third Street Grade Separation


Poor Eastside Gets Sold a False Bill of Goods Again



You read it here last week but Riverside City Hall has decided to delay the Third Street grade separation. This actually was decided in the fine print of the vote taken on the Perris Valley Metrolink line issue several weeks ago. Purportedly because the project fell $40 million behind in fund raising even though at one time it was fourth on the list behind Jurupa, Columbia and Magnolia for the construction.

It's just amazing that when it comes to raising money for projects, the city always runs out of money before it gets to the Eastside which allegedly received no redevelopment funding according to Councilman Andrew Melendrez.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



"It was never clear that there would be sufficient money to fund the project," Councilman Mike Gardner said. "Some monies had been allocated for the project, but it clearly was nowhere near enough to fund it."

Rather than commit more of the $15.7 million local officials would need to contribute, Third Street will be pulled from the list, pending local transportation commission approval and the agreement of the California Transportation Commission.

Complexities with the construction of the crossing -- near Highway 91 and the Riverside Canal -- contributed to the decision to delay it.

"It's a tight fit," said John Standiford, deputy director of the county transportation commission.






[Councilman Andrew Melendrez hasn't yet commented on the cancellation of the Third Street Grade Separation crossing within his ward,.]


Then there's discussion of focusing on the so-called "quiet zones" but according to the maps on that project vote, none of the quiet zones actually fall within the Eastside, the closest that it comes is somewhere on Cridge Street. Quiet zones were requested for the Eastside, according to one resident including by Longfellow Elementary School and Transportation Committee Chair Councilman Steve Adams was advised of this but the response was apparently well, Highland has one. No map I've seen of the "quiet zones" includes any such zones anywhere in the Eastside including the Third/seventh street railroad crossing areas. That's why residents are asking questions about these so-called zones because if the closest one to you is on Cridge Street then how does that impact you?

This intersection was heavily impacted by train shutdowns which often took out either Seventh or Spruce as well for up to 40 minutes or longer. People complained about the traffic jams, the noise, the pollution and what if emergency vehicles had to use that intersection. It's unfathomable that the Third Street grade separation is short funding (as opposed to at least one belatedly added to the list after that which would lead to eminent domain of dozens of commercial and residential properties). Not to mention the Iowa grade separation which came after it on the priority list.

It's truly unfortunate that when it comes to the improvements in Riverside's poorer communities which already house the homeless shelters the downtown and Wood Street areas refused to house for example, that's when the tap runs dry and costs have to be cut.

But it's nothing really new either.





Missing!



Did a Palm Springs police lieutenant kidnap his girlfriend?




Dawn Foster, missing since around Feb. 24, 2011



UPDATE: Girlfriend found in Lake Havasu. Lieutenant held on $500,000 bail.





Riverside Won't Sink...Experts Say







[Soil liquification in a Christchurch suburb after the 6.3 quake on Feb. 22]

Experts have reassured those in Riverside that what happened in Christchurch New Zealand won't happen here. Maps show that most of the liquification potential for Riverside is along the Santa Ana River but most of downtown is still a red zone mostly due to the concentration of older buildings with unreinforced masonry.

To offer appropriate comparison, imagine a 6.3 earthquake with an epicenter in Orangecrest that's two miles deep with a ground acceleration force of 2 Gs. It's certainly possible as Riverside's close proximity to the San Andreas Fault (which runs through San Bernardino and Grand Terrace) and even closer proximity to the San Jacinto faults means that there's probably a whole network of undiscovered fault lines beneath the city.

Just something to think about.





Public Meetings



Monday, March 7 at 4pm the Human Resource Board will meet to hold its elections and cover its business.

Tuesday, March 8 at 2 pm and 6:30pm, the Riverside City Council meets to discuss this agenda.


Wednesday, March 9 at 3pm on the seventh floor of City Hall the Finance Committee will meet to discuss this agenda.



Wednesday March 9 at 4pm the Community Police Review Commission will hold a special meeting on this business including elections for chair and vice chair. Commissioner Art Santore put his name in for both positions and there might be some surprise nominees on the actual election day. Three new commissioners who all sat in the last meeting will be making their debuts.

Labels: , , ,

Newer›  ‹Older