Five before Midnight

This site is dedicated to the continuous oversight of the Riverside(CA)Police Department, which was formerly overseen by the state attorney general. This blog will hopefully play that role being free of City Hall's micromanagement.
"The horror of that moment," the King went on, "I shall never, never forget." "You will though," the Queen said, "if you don't make a memorandum of it." --Lewis Carroll

Contact: fivebeforemidnight@yahoo.com

My Photo
Name:
Location: RiverCity, Inland Empire

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

The Rise and Fall of an RPD Officer, According to One of Them

******UPDATE******

Neo Nazis, counter demonstrators, police show up in force in Casa Blanca. More to come.


















[The front of the Robert Presley Detention Center in downtown Riverside that houses inmates awaiting trial like former Riverside Police Department Officer Dave Reeves, jr although he's residing at Smith Correctional Facility in Banning. ]




The arrest of former Riverside Police Officer Dave Reeves, Jr. is being discussed in different venues including here. One officer who knew him wrote about his impressions of the situation which he defined as an officer who spiraled out of control after several years in the police department due to emotional problems stemming from an alleged addiction not to illegal drugs but to ones that can be obtained through a doctor's prescription. Here Reeves is discussed in the past tense which might be fitting because his life as he knew it is now over.

(excerpt)



I would like to add by saying that drug addiction, particularly to pain killers, can and will cause people of all occupations, races, and life statuses to make dumb desperate bad choices. Cops aren't immune to depression, drug/alcohol abuse, suicide ect..especially after we become one. In Daves case, some of these issues came up after he became a cop, after an injury caused by an accident. I, like all of us who knew Dave, was completely shocked by these robberies, and how far over the deep end he went with his addiction. I'm still in shock because I knew Dave before he went downhill. And, yes, I do feel betrayed by what he did because our department, as well as LE in general, is now taking a beating over this.



In fact, law enforcement officers are at higher risk of drug addiction and suicide than the general population, according to studies that have been done. Some studies based on statistics have stated that an officer may be 2-4 times more likely to by his or her own gun than by being shot by someone else. And the number might be even higher because some "accidental" shootings usually during "gun cleanings" might actually be suicides. Some police officers might have been shocked by the robberies even those who might have known about Reeves' problems including an alleged addiction to pain killers, a euphemism for legal narcotics that are considered controlled substances.

It would have happened easily and not taken nearly as long as many people expect for a person like Reeves to become addicted to pain killing drugs as many of them are as addictive or even more so than illegal drugs like heroin. Stories abound including those involving famous athletes and celebrities of reliance on drugs to mask physical pain or painful emotions and of what happens when people ignore the dangers of overdoses of a drug or combination of drugs which prove to be fatal. Example after example has been broadcast in the national spotlight about celebrities who take drugs, go to sleep and never wake up.

The fact is that many police officers suffer injuries on the job and they also like Reeves suffer off duty injuries including orthopedic injuries that necessitate the taking of pain killing drugs including narcotics to function or make physical pain bearable. The SEIU, which is Riverside's largest bargaining unit, entered into an MOU with the city on its drug policy including drug testing that is a fairly strict, "zero tolerance" drug policy. I asked a member of the SEIU about the police department's drug use and drug testing policy and if it was similar to that used by his union. He looked shocked and said, no because in his opinion, if the police department's officers were under the same policy as the SEIU, many would be unable to work and police the streets. Is that the truth, or an exaggeration of the injury rate in the Riverside Police Department and the use of both over the counter and prescription medication by police officers, not just for injuries but for other medical conditions? And if is the truth than how is the department handling this issue?

Reeves' actions are his own and he bears responsibility for what he has done and yes, his actions are going to leave many police officers including close friends in shock and upset and feeling betrayed by what he has done. It's going to leave the agency and its officers feeling as if they are being painted with a broad brush, but that's partly because law enforcement departments tend to be cohesive but insulated and often very isolated organizations surrounded by the public they protect and serve.

But if Reeves was indeed a drug addict dressed in blue, then it brings to light issues that are difficult to grapple with or face in a profession that is encharged with arresting people involved in both the buying and selling of illegal drugs or legal drugs sold or used illegally. What does a department do about its own employees who are equipped with badges, guns and police powers who are drug addicts? Does it go the punitive route or the rehabilitative route? What route was taken with Reeves? And which thought came first when the department uncovered the depths of his problems if it ever did?

And this dilemma mirrors the conflicting attitudes in different states including California about drug addiction. Voters in California for example passed Proposition 136 which was intended to promote rehabilitation of people addicted to drugs over punitive measures. But with police officers, you have the additional factor that because they are public safety employees who interface with the public in different ways from taking reports or interviewing crime victims and witnesses to using lethal force, they are not only a danger to themselves if they are addicted to drugs but to other officers and the public at large. They also put the cities and counties that employ them at a higher risk of civil liability if they commit either accidental or purposeful police misconduct while addicted to drugs or if they fail to act in their capacity in situations because their judgment or other faculties are impaired.

Reeves became a police officer in 2002 following a father and an uncle onto the force. Not long after he had an off-duty accident and severely fractured two cervical vertebrae. Although he apparently recovered enough to return to active duty at some point, unfortunately, neck injuries by nature never really go away and can be a source of great chronic pain. Apparently, according to a lawsuit he filed against the city about a week before his arrest, Reeves reinjured his neck late last year. Soon after, the department decided to drug test him and he was ordered by Capt. Michael Blakely to first undergo field sobriety tests and then submit a sample for testing. In his lawsuit, Reeves denied being under the influence of drugs or even having used them during that day in January 2009. Because that lawsuit was filed on his behalf by the Riverside Police Officers' Association, the public has some information about what was taking place behind closed doors in one of the most secretive environments in a profession filled with secrets.

Some years ago, the police department allegedly offered one-chance drug rehabilitation to officers who failed blood and/or urine tests to avoid job termination. And there has been officers who have gone to rehab and returned to work, never looking behind them. It's not clear whether Reeves ever asked for any assistance with his problems or whether he was offered any by the department. The answers to those questions are shrouded in secrecy with the rest of his personnel record. It's not clear whether Reeves was working his assignment in patrol including in Casa Blanca while allegedly addicted to drugs or whether he was removed from the streets early on. If drug addiction truly did Reeves in, when did it first start? Back when he suffered his first serious injury, or when he suffered his second one?

A person gets addicted to drugs through their own actions but if there was an addiction to narcotic pain medication here as this anonymous officer states, then were there physicians who monitored his condition while prescribing him medications to see if he had developed any dependency or addiction? Did his family members notice anything wrong with their loved one? This officer mentions that he had many friends on the police force. Did any of them notice anything wrong before he spiraled downward and self-destructed in a major and highly visible way, a way that not even the state's confidentiality laws regarding peace officers can hide any longer?

There are signs of drug abuse that can be subtle and there are others that are not. And even if people suspect, then know and then try to approach or help the individual, it's very unlikely that their assistance will be accepted or their questions even wanted.


While this is most likely and certainly hopefully an example of an individual example of serious criminal conduct by a police officer and not an institutional one, no man and certainly no police officer is an island. Each individual one such as Reeves is interlinked with other officers and interwoven into the organizational structure of the law enforcement agency that employs them. One wonders how Reeves' problems ever came to light and when. Did any of his peers notice any problems and do they work in an environment where they can report them to supervisors? Did his supervisors notice anything wrong with him or his job performance while he was allegedly addicted to drugs? Was he ever given an option of going to rehab which has been offered to officers in the past? And what about the department's Early Warning System which was created after the Mayor's Use of Force Panel recommended it in 1999 and then later tightened by the State Attorney General's office during the five year stipulated judgment.

Very few of the department's officers are believed to be tracked by the department through this computerized system at any given time but was Reeves ever included in this group and would it have made a difference in his situation if he had been? There are many questions to be asked that perhaps will never be answered. And can't be in the State of California, which leaves many of its residents in cities where tragic incidents like this happen left wondering what is going on.





He also writes about Reeves, jr.' career before his arrest. His work as an officer in a neighborhood where his work was lauded by officers, complained about by more than a few residents (as he received the second highest number of complaints of any officer there)but then it's not rare for police and community residents to have different perceptions of the same officer.

He talks about the familial connections for Reeves and attributed his downfall to the injury that he suffered off-duty and what he said was the department's handling of it.


(excerpt)



He actually strongly resembled a heavier version of Napolean Dynamite. He wears glasses, which aren't in the booking photo. Gangsters in Casa Blanca referred to him as Napolean Dynamite. Dave came from a family of Riverside cops. His father was a well respected Sgt. who retired several years back. His uncle is a Motor Sgt. now. He has two brother-in-laws on the department, both well respected. Dave was a police exporer and cadet for RPD before he became a cop. I worked with all three of them, and Dave was a good street cop before his problems overcame him. An off duty accident several years ago caused a lingering neck injury, which got him hooked on pain killers. The department recently began investigating him for the drug addiction, took him off the street and suspended his police powers. The city doctors were most likely going to retire him for his neck injury, but since the accident was off duty, he was not going to get a medical retirement. Dave didn't want to retire, and he began to have huge family/money problems. His addiction overcame him, and he went over the deep end.

Dave was a friend of mine, and it's hard to read some of the posts here,,,but I don't blame anyone for their anger or disgust. How can anyone justify these robberies. But, he had alot of friends on the department that were completely shocked and saddened by this, and you can imagine how his family feels. Dave wasn't a "Thug" or a "G", he just snapped..that's the only way I can describe it.





So an officer whose entire family appears to have been tied to the Riverside Police Department, who had been involved with the department beginning in the Explorer program and continuing as a police cadet and then later as an officer was not only facing retirement but was ineligible for a medical retirement due to the nature of his injury. An individual who is raised in a family where most of his role models are law enforcement officers might be more likely to identify himself more strongly that way and be more reluctant to surrender that identity. Did that make him more desperate than he would be otherwise? That's a hard question to answer as some people in his shoes commit crimes but many don't so it's likely that other factors came into play here.

This officer writes about shock and feelings of betrayal at the behavior of a fellow officer and friend. No doubt there is a department filled with employees feeling the same way, not to mention a city of residents who are very concerned about what has happened in their midst and some of them may be indicting the entire agency by the actions of one. That's not really fair to do but the department itself could go along way in addressing any erosion of public trust by how it addresses this issue to examine whether there is anything they can uncover through investigation and reflection to prevent future David Reeves before their meltdowns collide with other people's lives potentially placing them in jeopardy as Reeves' actions did last week.

The department hopefully does as it should recognize that police officers due to the stress and physical demands of their jobs are at higher risk for drug addiction among other problems and be more vigilant of any officers heading down a similar path. Because the number one question in many discussions right now is apprehension over whether Reeves is truly an isolated case and whether or not there are other ticking time bombs inside the department. Officers should evaluate each other to see if there's any reason that a person they work with might be in trouble and the police culture which often punishes those who "tattle" should provide a more accommodating environment for officers to report concerns or even apprehension with working alongside certain police officers.

Drug rehabilitation should be a viable option at least for the first offense so there might be more self-reporting or be reported by others he or she works with. At some point, the department must have figured out there was a serious problem with Reeves if what this individual wrote is correct and took steps to investigate, which inevitably brought his situation to a head. Situations like those involving Reeves should be handled as critical incidents subject to investigation and review not just on individuals but much more broadly. The public is most reassured and has the most confidence in the police agencies that protect and serve them when they have the most faith and trust in them that this is being done as a matter of course.

Field supervisors should keep an eye on their charges and be ready to either approach the officer or their supervisors if there are problems suspected much, much earlier in the process than likely was the case involving Reeves. However, considering how strapped the supervisory ranks are because of frozen vacancies and promotions, that might be more of a challenge than it was in the past.

And communities should keep an eye on their officers and if they're behaving strangely or inappropriately, they should report it to a supervisor or file a complaint so that the department has an opportunity to check into what is going on with a particular officer.

But the department should take the time right now to thoroughly investigate this critical incident and check to see whether it's early warning system of identifying and tracking problematic behavior is doing the job that it should be doing in hopes of preventing more David Reeves from c0ming to light in a horrifying way.






Riverside City Council members will be riding a mechanical bull for charity at an event sponsored by Habitat for Humanity.



Hoe-Down with Habitat

When: 5 p.m. Saturday; dinner is 6-7:30 p.m.

Where: Riverside Rancheros arena, 1198 Washington St., Riverside

Cost: $40, includes one drink

Information: 951-787-6754, ext. 120, www.habitatriverside.org







A recall drive against Moreno Valley Councilwoman Robin Hastings appears to be falling short.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



For her part, Hastings said she was "cautiously optimistic" that the recall attempt would fail. "But I'm superstitious. I don't want to comment until after 5 p.m."

Reeder said her committee gathered more than 3,300 names but must collect at least 4,508.

Hastings took office in December. Her opponents say they're angry about her February vote in favor of a 1.8 million-square-foot Skechers distribution center. Her backers point out that the shoe warehouse won unanimous support on the council, and that if she'd voted no, the project still would have been approved by a 4-1 tally.




Don't rush to cityhood. So the Press Enterprise Editorial Board warns Eastvale which is chomping at the bit to do just that.


Riverside County Sheriff's Department candidate Frank Robles has a campaign Web site.




Mayoral candidate Ken Stansbury will be appearing at the Friday Morning Club on Friday, Oct. 23 at 10 a.m. at the Janet Goeske Center on Sierra near Streeter.



Riverside Councilman Paul Davis is hosting a meeting tonight at the Orange Terrace Center in Orangecrest at 6:30 p.m. . There will be city department representatives there and topics will be discussed.



UC Riverside is hosting an all-day event culminating in a 8:30 p.m. vigil commemorating October 22, the national day against police abuse. It starts at 10 a.m.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

City Manager says RPD's Strategic Plan back on track

We interrupt our regular meeting....


Another city council meeting held in Riverside, another public service announcement issued by an elected official on a topic that seems to come out of no where. At some point, the elected official then asks a designated representative from the city manager's office to help him or her deliver his or her announcement. This has been an interesting ritual that has developed over the past few weeks, offering a treat to viewers at the meetings and at home.

A few weeks ago, Councilwoman Nancy Hart informed the public both in the audience and the viewing audience at home with assistance from Asst. City Manager Paul Sundeen as to why the Finance Committee hasn't met in nearly a year and not at all during 2009. People listening and watching left that with more questions than answers as Hart had essentially abdicated her role as chair which is to call meetings to the city manager's office. This issue has become more pressing as more and more people have been discussing it if not in the city council chambers outside of it. One member of the finance committee said that when he's tried to ask when it's going to meet, he's told by Hart that there is no meeting scheduled because there's nothing to discuss. But there is interest with at least one committee member that a meeting should be held which is reassuring to hear.

But that was then and this is now and it's time for another topic to be deemed worthy of being a vaunted public service announcement and this week, the topic involved the Riverside Police Department.

This week, the conduit for the PSA was Mayor Ron Loveridge. The topic? The Riverside Police Department's Strategic Plan, not the current one that was mandated by the state but the new one which was to replace it when it sunsets in December.

This blogging covered the alleged stalling of Strategic Plan 2 which was to have begun earlier this year, not long after Chief Russ Leach told community groups and organizations that the department would be creating and implementing a new blueprint for future development and direction in the agency to replace the first one soon set to expire. Leach said there would be plenty of opportunities for community input to the plan, essentially telling people who attended various community policing forums held across the city that it was "your plan". However, silence followed those announcements and an inquiry into the status of the plan led to information that the plan wasn't moving forward due to forces inside City Hall. This blog posting attracted quite an influx of readers from as far away as the State Treasurer's office up in Sacramento interesting when you consider who is the current treasurer right now.

But what a difference a week makes!

At the city council meeting, Mayor Ron Loveridge pulled up an email from Leach telling him that the department would be working on the strategic plan and that it would be ready to present before the city council by March 2010. His boss, City Manager Brad Hudson stepped in on Loveridge's cue to explain that the plan wasn't mandated like its predecessor but it was something they wanted to do, sounding oh so thrilled about it all just like he did after the embarrassing episode involving the city council's plan to implement the strategic plan in 2006 mercifully was resolved.

At some point the public safety committee chair and city staff would be involved and perhaps there would be some kind of public forum. Hudson always gets this strange expression on his face when he talks about any type of "community input" or "public participation" which is kind of interesting to watch. Every bite on a sour pickle?

But at any rate, this is an interesting development at City Hall which will have to be closely scrutinize in the weeks and months ahead. It's not clear whether Hudson truly embraces the strategic plan part deux or whether someone higher on the food chain than he is gave him a little nudge but the strategic plan is now moving forward, instead of running in place. It's more likely that it was the latter and that individual or individuals should be thanked because the Strategic Plan doesn't cease to be important just because former State Attorney General Bill Lockyer signs off on a mandated reform plan or because the first one is set to expire. And it's not just something the Riverside Police Department needs but is something that every law enforcement agency should have.


But the city and police department need to bring some more transparency into this important process. Here are some ways to do this.


1) Bring the issue for presentation and input to the entire public safety committee in public at City Hall not just to the chair of that committee, Chairman Chris MacArthur to be discussed behind closed doors.

2) Bring the plan back to the city council for presentation at an evening meeting with plenty of time to outline the plan, take comments and have discussion.

3) Rather than have one "public hearing" as suggested by Hudson, have meetings throughout the different neighborhoods, at least one per Neighborhood Policing Center to receive as much input from the public as possible and to reach all different groups of people.

4) The police chief personally should be coming to these public meetings as the main architect of this Strategic Plan at all its stages.

There was discussion about how the public utilities belongs to the people and well, so does the police department. It should be treated in that fashion rather than as some shiny toy that some politicians, past or present including former Councilman Frank Schiavone and their direct staff get to play with when they feel like it.

There will be much more coverage of this issue in the future because after all, another week, another opinion on whether or not there will be a strategic plan or not. Kind of like picking from daisies to determine whether someone likes you or not. It's unfortunate that City Hall has to take the more dysfunctional route towards getting on board to get something like a strategic plan done but at least it's getting done. That's the important thing and there will be regular checks done through this process to make sure that there's no backpedaling by any of the parties. Because we all know that has happened in the past too.




The Jolly Councilman

In other council business, Councilman Steve Adams left the meeting for a while and came back some time after public comment (so alas, there was no editorializing this week) in a much more jolly mood than when he left. He discussed the businesses at the Riverside City Walk in some sort of promotion drive for Shop Riverside or something like that mentioning a nail salon. He waxed about getting pedicures and well, getting waxed at this establishment. Perhaps a little bit more information than the viewing public wanted to know from its elected official. But never a dull moment at the city council meetings.

City Attorney Gregory Priamos was gone for a while too but didn't come back more jolly than he had left. There was no reportable action on any of the lawsuits on the docket during the closed session of this meeting.




Snapshot of a City Committee


Mayor’s Nomination and Screening Committee

Chair: Mayor Ron Loveridge

Members: Governmental Affairs Committee
Councilmen Andrew Melendrez, Steve Adams and Rusty Bailey

Meetings: Tuesdays as required. It has met more times this year than the Finance Committee.




(Riverside, CA) The Mayor’s Nomination and Screening Committee met at 1 pm on Oct. 20 to select applicants to interview to fill the Ward Three vacancy on the Community Police Review Commission. The mayor and city council seem to be moving much more quickly with filling the vacancy created by the resignation of CPRC Chair Sheri Corral than they did when filling the Ward Two vacancy that remained vacant for nearly six months. In fact, the current Ward Two commissioner Rogelio V. Morales has just been sworn in.

The qualifications of the applicants based on what they submitted as part of their initial applications was quite weak, partly due to the fact that five of the six applicants were submitting applications for multiple boards and commissions so they didn’t tailor their responses to the questions specifically to the CPRC. Only Deborah Wong who was one of the original applicants for CPRC in 2000 submitted any information pertaining to the CPRC.

According to the report submitted by City Clerk Colleen Nicol, there were six applicants from this ward who applied for the CPRC. They are listed below.


George Perez

He’s employed by U.C. Riverside as a store worker and purchaser and has lived in Riverside 50 years. A former member of the Community (now Human Relations) Commission


Robert M. Righter

A 10 year resident, Righter works for Home Depot and moved to Texas for a while and then came back to Riverside.


Dale Roberts

A senior analyst at JPL in Pasadena, Robert stated he had no specific experience except family members who were in law enforcement or in the military.


Tonya D. Snively

She has lived in Riverside for over 37 years and wants to be a city council member some day. She works for Tom Ford Fragrances.


Lilliam Snow

She’s lived in Riverside about one year and calls herself a “volunteer in need”
.

Deborah Wong

A professor at UCR who has lived in Riverside for 11 years. She is chair of the Riverside Coalition for Police Accountability. She stated when the commission was six years old, that it was at a crossroads.


Janice Bielman: A neighborhood watch captain and member of the Magnolia Area Neighborhood Alliance, she once worked for a retail mangement/loss related business.


After the usual conferring among themselves and asking each other which candidates they knew or didn't know, the committee members finally chose for intereviews, Bielman, Wong, Roberts and Perez.

The date which will be set aside for city council members and the mayor to interview the applicants for this appointment to the CPRC have not yet been announced. But it seems like the process for filling this latest vacancy is going much more quickly than it did when the city council was trying to fill the position vacated by Jim Ward last March.




The death of Riverside County Supervisor Roy Wilson has forced the rest of the body to jettison much of its business.



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)


Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has yet to appoint a replacement, giving supervisors little leeway in approving items that require four votes.

Supervisor Jeff Stone was absent Tuesday, leaving just three supervisors to handle the county's business.

As a result, they had to delay more than a dozen items, ranging from an amendment to the Sheriff's Department contract with Palm Desert to the allocation of Homeland Security grant funds.

The county has critical things on our agenda, Supervisor Bob Buster said.

"It does create a set of problems," he said. "You don't know when the governor will make his appointment."

Budget adjustments, sanitation and sewer deals and changes to construction contracts are among the things that require a four-fifths vote, county spokesman Ray Smith said.

There is no deadline for the governor to make his decision, and for weeks supervisors have urged Schwarzenegger to tap a replacement. Wilson resigned just days before his Aug. 26 death.

Wilson, the county's fourth-district supervisor, had recommended State Sen. John Benoit, R-Bermuda Dunes, to succeed him. The remaining supervisors have backed a Benoit appointment.

Other names floated as possible successors include former state Sen. Jim Battin, former Assemblywoman Bonnie Garcia and former Palm Springs Police Chief Gary Jeandron.






On the campaign trail with the candidates running for the Riverside Unified District School Board.



The city council approved a large-scale public utilities project that cost nearly $20 million and is intended to avoid blackouts several years from now.





The Press Enterprise purge continues




About 30 employees have been let go from the Press Enterprise in recent weeks, mostly reporters, copy editors, editors and one photographer. And in a new move, the publication owned by Belo Enterprises in Texas is firing reporters and then offering them opportunities as free lance writers, something readers will see in the Press Enterprise more in the future.

There's only one reporter left in Riverside and Riverside County has no general reporter as the newspaper continues what some say might be its death spiral. Could there ever be a day when Riverside doesn't have a daily newspaper? Five years ago, could you have even entertained that question?


One of the reporters there who is left will be hosting a live forum on the issue of medical marijuana, one that's come up here again in recent weeks.

It's being held today from 2:30 p.m. -4 p.m.





A Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputy who had been missing was found dead and will be the subject of an autopsy.








The Riverside County District Attorney's office said keep that search warrant sealed in the case of a search involving the home of a San Jacinto councilman.

Isn't it interesting how the only warrants that ever seemed to have to be sealed are usually those involving politicians? But then even though the office still technically has a public integrity unit, it seems to go after activists more than well...public officials.



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



Prosecutors called the release order "unlawful and without authority" and said it will hurt their investigation. The targets of the investigation have not been identified.

In papers filed Monday with the Riverside-based 4th District Court of Appeal, prosecutors claim "the First Amendment opens no doors to warrant proceedings," and asked the appellate court to halt the release order issued by Riverside County Superior Court Judge Helios J. Hernandez II.

Hernandez originally upheld sealing the warrants in Aug. 26, but reversed himself and granted their release on Oct. 6 on a renewed motion from The Press-Enterprise.





Meeting in Ward Four



Councilman Paul Davis is holding another public meeting at the Orange Terrace Community Center in Ward Four. It's Thursday, Oct. 22 at 6:30 pm. There will be department headsin attendance and particular issues will be the focus of discussion.

So Ward Four residents should head on out there. But what would help a lot of people would be if the RTA would start a busline that actually goes to Orangecrest rather than bypasses it.





Annual Meeting and Neighbor hood Caucus

Saturday, October 24, 2009

9:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m.

Bordwell Park, 2008 Martin Luther King Blvd.


Special Presentation by Mayor Ronald Loveridge



Seven (7) RNP Board seats will be up for election, three (3) are in Area 4.

Please see attached document on election information.

Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, October 18, 2009

Grounded: Riverside's Finance Committee and the RPD's next Strategic Plan

The Riverside City Council has called for another meeting to be held on Tuesday, Oct. 20 at both 3 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. at City Hall. Already discussed is the plethora of civil litigation which is set to be discussed behind closed doors in the conference room just off of the newly renovated city council chambers. No less than 12 agenda items are on the closed session docket and that is a bit unusual for the city council to be so lawsuit orientated but tis the season. Along with the increasing number of police lawsuits and the usual round of litigative jabs that Riverside's lobbing at a growing number of other cities in Southern California, there's some Redevelopment legal action as well.

This agenda also includes items that will be held in open session including this one discussion item on the construction of two energy resource centers that are set to be built for Riverside.

In addition to that one discussion item, there are eight consent calendar items which is a laundry list of items that can only be pulled by those on the dais for further discussion. As far as the consent calendars go, this one's rather paltry. Unless there's some major discussion during the discussion item or one of the consent calendar items get pulled or another crowd comes out for public comment (yay!) or Mayor Ron Loveridge starts talking about the League of Cities again, this week's evening meeting could clock in at a trim 90 minutes.



And what of the Finance Committee?


And then there will be time set aside at the end for mayor and city council comments although it is unclear whether or not there will be any status report on the latest chapter of the Mystery of the Disappearing Finance Committee. At the Friday Morning Club, former councilman and mayoral candidate Art Gage did ask the people sitting there when was the last time that a finance committee was held, one person thought that there might have been a meeting held this year. However, that hasn't been the case and the last meeting was actually held last year on Dec. 8. People at the meeting were kind of shocked at that news. Which makes sense because why does a committee exist even though it never meets? While it's true that Riverside's leadership often goes down its own beaten path, it's strange that there are individuals on the dais who are taken aback by city residents asking questions or expressing concern about meetings being scheduled and posted on the city's Web site even though these meetings never actually take place.

As we all know by now, this committee's been missing in action since it was apparently enclosed in mothballs and stashed inside some closet at City Hall somewhere, waiting for some enlightened city official to take notice and resurrect it. That day still hasn't come but it's interesting listening and reading comments about the plight of this standing committee from individuals who have read the postings on this site.

What's interesting is that the meeting that took place before that one on Sept. 8, 2008 had this agenda item on it. And what is this agenda item? It's a report being presented by Asst. City Manager Paul Sundeen on interfund loans. It isn't a very impressive report in terms of the quantity of trees killed to create it, checking in at only three slender little pages but it's full of implications for the future financial accountability of Riverside's City Hall.

And what of the recommendations?



(excerpt, report by Sundeen--red ink is my contribution)



Obtaining the approval of the City Council for the expenditure of funds and a related interfund borrowing if necessary, is very important. These approvals are now obtained. Staff recommends that the specific fund from which money is borrowed is incidental information and need only be disclosed once a year in connection with the preparation of the annual financial statements. Alternatively, any changes in the borrowing could be disclosed as part of the monthly summary currently provided to the City Council.



So being accountable to the city council on interfund borrowing involving specific funding sources such as the use of the city's sewer fund to buy up businesses in the downtown is seen as being "incidental information"? Perhaps it is to "staff" which is a rather generic and vague term for the city manager's office but it should not be viewed that way by the mayor and legislative body which oversee the city manager's office. Not that interfund borrowing is necessarily a bad thing. However, there needs to be an accountability mechanism in place to oversee it as well as the transparency of having this business transactions including borrowing from funding sources to use elsewhere be disclosed to the public. And it's interesting how the "advantages" of Sundeen's proposed changes are presented but the disadvantages such as reduced accountability and the limits of monies in the funds that can be spent on what the money in those funds is actually designated for were not mentioned.

That shows inherent bias by Sundeen and his department because when they listed their recommendations, they didn't provide a more objective perspective of advantages and disadvantages. In some circumstances, it could be seen as asking the fox for advice on how the hen house should be secured. Not that the finance division of the city manager's office is necessarily in the role of the fox, but the perception leans more in that direction when mechanisms of accountability and transparency are being stripped away, mostly by those the public has entrusted with fiscal responsibility and that is the city council.

According to these minutes, the Finance Committee without formal motion agreed to have Sundeen and the city manager's office disclose any changes in funding in the monthly reports provided to the city council. But by doing so, did the Finance Committee ensure its further decline to the point of near extinction? After all, the city council just appears to have kept giving away pieces of its control of the financial accountability of the city manager's office in this city.


What were some of the things the currently defunct standing city council committee has done? It's done budget reviews of city departments, addressed community block grant funding, evaluated various interfund transfers and tackled other financial issues that arose from the perspective of a portion of the legislative body set up in part to address issues involving the city's finances. And the Finance Committee is apparently the latest casualty because after all, people walked away from Chair Nancy Hart's comments believing that she was essentially waiting until the city manager's office notified her it was okay to meet. And if she's waiting for those instructions, the day for the next time the Finance Committee meets could be a long time coming.

This once critical committee also received annual budget reports and annual audit reports done on the city by different independent firms including in those years listed below. Of course, given that there hasn't been any finance committee meetings this year, there of course hasn't been a meeting of the finance committee to receive this report.


2007 annual audit presented in January 2008

2006 annual audit not presented to Finance Committee in 2007

2005 annual audit presented in January 2006

2004 annual audit presented in February 2005


However, the Finance Committee has not met once this year to discuss any of the above issues or any issues at all for that matter. But then that's possibly because the issues that it used to discuss in the open so that the public could attend the meetings are now being discussed by the city staff behind closed doors with limited opportunities for public comment before these issues get to the city council and wind up on the consent calendar because the city council's made up its mind on most of the issues which come before it by the time they get there.


The next Finance Committee meeting is tentatively scheduled on Monday, Nov. 9 at 2:30 p.m. but it's unlikely that it will actually take place given the track record of this committee this year under both the chairmanship of Councilman Chris MacArthur and current chair, Councilwoman Nancy Hart who along with Sundeen issued a public service announcement at a recent city council meeting as to why there had been no meetings this year. But it's really confusing to follow because for some reason, City Hall schedules meetings that might never actually be held. Makes a whole lot of sense to most people outside of City Hall. Well, not really but there definitely seems to be people inside City Hall who think it should make perfect sense.

But Las Vegas currently places the odds of the Finance Committee meeting as follows:


The Finance Committee will meet on Nov. 9 40:1

The Finance Committee will meet in 2009: 15:1

The Finance Committee will meet ever again: 9:1


So if you're feeling lucky in city futures, go and make your bet.



Other Committee News



There will be no meeting in October for the Public Safety Committee. The tentative date for the next meeting is here. I'm a bit hesitant to actually post it because it might not actually meet on that date. The public safety committee has actually met five times this year.


Here are the number of meetings scheduled for the other standing committees this year so far.


Community Services and Youth: 9

Development Committee: 6

Governmental Affairs Committee: 7

Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee: 6

Transportation Committee: 5

Utility Services, Land Use, Energy Development: 11


This is assuming that these committees actually met on all the more than tentatively scheduled (but apparently not quite set in stone) dates.




No new Strategic Plan for the Riverside Police Department



As you know, the city of Riverside was forced to enter into a stipulated judgment with the State Attorney General's office in March 2001 after a year-long investigation by that office discovered violations of state laws and a pattern and practice of serious problems within the department in different areas of operation. One of the reforms mandated by former State Attorney General Bill Lockyer was the creation of the five-year Strategic Plan which the department did, putting it into place by late 2004.


The 2004-2009 Strategic Plan mandated by the state is here.

As you can see, it's a comprehensive set of guidelines and objectives that the department had hoped to achieve during the five-year period in several different subject areas. It's a critical tool as it would be in any law enforcement agency to be able to strategize and plan ahead when it's in a period of intense change and growth and it's important to have that blueprint for change, development and reform in writing so that all the involved parties and stake holders understand what is going on and what the future will hold. Most people accept this as simply common sense. However, certain individuals in City Hall do not and that is to the detriment of everyone because a police department without a strategic plan especially in fiscally tight times is not heading in the right direction. And there doesn't seem to be much interest at City Hall in getting it back on track by creating and implementing along with the community and department a new strategic plan.

Now, Lockyer always said that there had to be a three-way partnership in the reforming of the police department and that it had to involve the city, the communities and the department. But there are certain entities that have no concept and certainly no care of what that really means and unfortunately, those people hold positions of tremendous power over the department's future and the process (whether for good or bad) used to get there. And so it goes...

There is no controversy there, that's just fact as unfortunately some of us found out within several months of the dissolution of the stipulated judgment in March 2006 when a certain entity at City Hall was told by a legislative entity above it to carry out simple instructions to ensure the continuation of the successful implementation of the Strategic Plan. Instead, these individuals tried to change the instructions they were given by their bosses and even derail the process completely. Whether that was willful behavior or simply because they didn't know any better, what the city manager's office pushed during the summer of 2006 wasn't exactly what the city council had ordered.

Fortunately, enough city council members, okay two of them, later began paying attention and they managed to stir the S.S. Hudson on the right path. That might have been before Gage had his alleged conversation with Hudson who had promised then to stop micromanaging the police department. But two years after that alleged conversation, his office appears to be doing exactly that with questions raised about whether any allocated money can be requested and/or spent by the department without having to be approved by Asst. City Manager Tom DeSantis first instead of the police chief. And as most people know, the police chief is the person usually responsible for the budget including allocations and expenditures and it's the chief who usually holds the purse strings.

But apparently not in Riverside. Gage also made the comment that Riverside might be the only city in the country where the police department is run by a city manager. People at the Friday Morning Club meeting were more than a little taken aback by that revelation.

But once again, another strategic plan is endangered and that was to be Strategic Plan part 2 which was proposed by Chief Russ Leach as an objective of the police department at public forums earlier this year. He told city residents at these forums that he was going to get public input on what should be included in the next five-year plan as he had with the previous one. But there will be no plan because apparently, City Hall said no and vetoed it.

Just another way that City Manager Brad Hudson has shown his lack of interest in the forward progression of the police department just 3 1/2 years after the dissolution of the judgment against the city. That's unfortunate but after all, Hudson arrived late on the scene of the police department's reform process and perhaps is unaware of how important it is to avoid making the mistakes of the 1990s now in the 21st Century.

The police department has seen difficult times in the past several years with vacant positions not being filled due to budget cuts including more than a dozen supervisory positions and the department having to shuffle the remaining supervisors around in the different divisions. And now not only is it losing staffing but it has no forward plan that was created through discussion and input by all the involved stake holders. That is what you get when you put the city manager's office in charge of the police department.







A third man has died after being tased by police officers from agencies in the Inland Empire.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



The man was taken to a St. Bernardine Medical Center where he was pronounced dead, according to the San Bernardino County coroner's office. An autopsy is pending to determine the cause of death.

Friday's fatality occurred at a residential mental health center listed as one of the partners of the county's Office of Behavioral Health. Orchid Court is a state-licensed assisted living facility.

The incident marks the third time in less than three months that a suspect has died shortly after being stunned with a Taser by police in the Inland area. Jonathan Nelson, 27, of Rancho Cucamonga was stunned twice on July 30, once by deputies in Hemet and again in a Riverside County jail cell.

Terrace Clifton Smith, 52, of Moreno Valley was Tasered by police and suffered a fatal seizure on Aug. 9.







Civilian oversight and review is a very rare thing in Iowa.


(excerpt, Des Moines Register)



Iowa City's Police Citizen's Review Board is the only such body in Iowa and one of about 60 nationwide. The group fields complaints about police directly from the public. Though they have the power to subpoena records and documents, the board primarily reviews the findings of internal police investigations of incidents.
Advertisement

"We provide another check in the system," said Donald King, a former security guard who is vice chairman of the board. "We're another set of eyes for the public."

Though advocacy groups occasionally call for a similar board in Des Moines, home to Iowa's largest police force, the idea has never taken root. The most recent cry for police review came after Octavius Bonds and Erin Evans, a Des Moines couple, said they were victims of police brutality after a 2008 traffic stop.

The officers involved, Mersed Dautovic and John Mailander, both rookies, resigned under threat of termination. The attorney for Bonds and Evans, Peter Berger, called for civilian review of police after a jury acquitted his clients of interference with police and assault charges in March. The couple has also filed a civil suit that alleges the officers violated their constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishment, unlawful search and seizure and infringements on their due process rights.

Des Moines Police Chief Judy Bradshaw believes police face strong internal and external scrutiny and a civilian review board would strip the department's managers of authority when governing officers.

"I believe if the public trusts us to investigate murders, the most immoral crime, they should be able to trust us to hold ourselves accountable," Bradshaw said.





Miami-Dade County in Florida kills civilian review.


(excerpt, Miami Herald)



Funding for the Independent Review Panel ended Oct. 1. It's the only county office to be eliminated in the mayor's budget.

In a last hour attempt to keep the panel operating, a resolution sponsored by Commissioner Barbara Jordan passed 11-1 on Tuesday asking the mayor and county manager's office to report back to the commission in 30 days with possible sources to fund the IRP with a reduced $450,000 operating budget.

While the commissioners wait for the county's findings, layoff and reassignment letters are being handed out to IRP's four-member staff.

``I received mine,'' said Eduardo Diaz, IRP executive director. ``It says to report to the Water and Sewer Department.''

Diaz expects the office to be open until Oct. 27, but ``technically as of the first we no longer exist,'' he said.







Information on upcoming anti-Nazi Rally in Casa Blanca




Media and Public Update: Rally Against Hate on October 24 in Riverside

A Riverside rally at 10 am on October 24 sponsored by dozens of community organizations will express "rejection of Nazi intolerance, racism and violence," reports Kevin Akin, spokesman for the community coalition. Nazis from the "National Socialist Movement" (NSM) have announced that they will be demonstrating in Riverside on Saturday, October 24, and the coalition intends to show that the Inland Empire rejects the Nazis.

"Our rally will be entirely peaceful," states Akin. "We will rally on the other side of the street from the Nazis, and we have been assured that there will be a large enough police presence to keep the Nazis from crossing the street. We will have an orderly, peaceful, disciplined demonstration, and will not permit anyone to participate who engages in violence or attempts to provoke violence. Our message is too important to let disruptions draw attention away from it." He says that the message will be conveyed through chants, singing, and signs in both English and Spanish. Some of the signs being prepared feature such slogans as "Tolerance Yes, Hatred No," and "Inland Area Rejects Nazi Hate."

At the same time as the community rally at Madison Street and Indiana Avenue, a picnic and play event for children will be held four blocks away at Villegas Park. When the Nazis leave, the demonstrators will march to Villegas Park and hold a "victory rally" with live music. Organizers ask that children not attend the rally at Madison and Indiana, but stay with a relative or guardian at Villegas Park until the march arrives. Demonstrators are urged to park at or near Villegas Park and walk to the rally. Organizers ask that each person bring a can or box of food to donate to local food banks, and put the food in collection boxes at Villegas Park.

Akin reports that organizers have been in contact with the Riverside Police Department and have secured permission to use the bandstand area at Villegas Park from the Riverside Parks and Recreation Department. He estimates that "about 40 monitors will help keep the demonstration orderly and effective." Final details of the "Rally Against Hate" will be settled at a meeting of representatives of sponsoring organizations on Wednesday, Akin reports.

For more information: Kevin Akin (951) 787-0318, cell (951) 675-2813 kevinakin1950@hotmail.com







Meetings on the proposed high speed train may be coming to a venue near you.



Meeting Info


Five public meetings are planned to discuss the planned high-speed rail route.

Monday: Murrieta Public Library, Eight Town Square, 24700 Adams Ave.

Tuesday: Corona Public Library, West Room, 650 S. Main St.

Thursday: Bobby Bonds Park, Cesar Chavez Community Center, 2060 University Ave.

Nov. 2: Ontario Airport Administrative Conference Rooms, 1923 E. Avion St.

Nov. 3: Feldheym Central Library, Kellogg Room, 555 W. 6th St.

Source: California High-Speed Rail Authority

Labels: ,

Friday, October 16, 2009

The Riverside Police Officers' Association sues the city

“It was a good shooting and that…he did not need an attorney and is not entitled to an attorney.”

---Departmental Captain John Carpenter and Sgt. Patrick Watters to Officer Daniel J. Floyd after he requested legal representation during questioning by investigators, according to the RPOA's lawsuit.



“They are a jumbled mess of conclusions of law, and the facts that are provided are contradictory and ambiguous.”


---The city in its motion for demurrer in the RPOA's lawsuit against the city.



"I can change that direction by not going into office to make friends inside Riverside City Hall in order to have a bigger political future for myself by 'playing the game'".

---Mayoral candidate Ken Stansbury on his Web site




"Brad Hudson can't run the police department. He's not qualified."

---Riverside mayoral candidate and former councilman, Art Gage at the Friday Morning Club meeting.




"All I can say is that drug addiction can cause people of all races, occupations, and statuses in life to make bad, desperate choices."


---"Shockwave" at the Press Enterprise Web site





A former RPD officer arraigned on 12 felony counts



Riverside Police Department officer David Reeves jr. was arraigned in Riverside County Superior Court on 12 felony charges including four counts of robbery, one count of attempted robbery, burglary and Assault with a deadly weapon, an gun. All the felony charges have enhancements involving the use of a gun to commit the crime. His charges stem from three armed robberies in Riverside and Moreno Valley, all of them auto parts stores within the past two weeks.

He also faces one enhancement of stolen property/public service which is PC F496(A).
Bail is currently set by $500,000 and Reeves intends to retain his own private counsel before his arraignment which has been rescheduled for Oct. 30.





The Riverside Police Officers' Association vs the City of Riverside




This labor development has been in the works for months but the Riverside Police Officers’ Association finally sued the city of Riverside on behalf of six of its police officers, alleging violations of due process in relation to state law and the Peace Officer Bill of Rights Act by other representatives of the police department when these individuals were interrogated involving internal investigations being conducted. It may or may not be followed by another similar lawsuit in relation to interrogations and procedure involving the investigations of officer-involved shootings. The RPOA last sued the city over investigative protocol for officer-involved deaths and/or shootings in August 2003.


The officers listed as plaintiffs in the action are Daniel J. Floyd, Sanchez Lopez, Juan Munoz, Paul Turner, Sgt. Ron Whitt and Giovanni Ili. These actions were alleged to have taken place January, February, March and December 2008. Below are a list of allegations made in the lawsuit.


According to the lawsuit, representatives of the police department interrogated and investigated petitioners without informing them about the nature of these interrogations and investigations and subjected them to offensive language, threatened punitive action, actually took punitive actions against petitioner and denied them representation during the interrogations and investigations. An investigation is currently open into the violations of this Act.


Officer Daniel J. Floyd

According to the lawsuit, the 2008 shooting by Daniel Floyd and David Reeves, jr. happened after they intervened in a drug sale. Floyd tried to detain seller. The driver tried to drive away and Floyd attempted to break windows and shut the vehicle off. The driver stopped vehicle and Reeves walked in front of it. The driver began to drive vehicle towards Reeves and Reeves shot that individual.


Floyd requested counsel from Vince Morris prior to an internal interrogation by department and DA. Department Captain John Carpenter and Sgt. Pat Watters told Floyd, “It was a good shooting and that…he did not need an attorney and is not entitled to an attorney.”


Because even though the witnesses and involved officers had yet to be interviewed, the investigation apparently was in a sense done. Which makes you wonder why so many officer-involved death investigations are over a year old now without reaching the Community Police Review Commission if the decision is made whether it's "good" or "bad" by supervisors and management personnel within the first few hours. Not that communities believe anything differently than this happening because the perception is strong that officers will back other officers no matter what and statements like these when they slip out in interrogation rooms and later through lawsuits don't exactly challenge that belief in a meaningful way. But anyway, the main point is that Floyd was apparently denied an attorney and if so, that's a violation of due process for criminal investigations and possibly of state evidence codes and the Peace Officer Bill of Rights as well. And that's what is being contested in this lawsuit.

But then you really have to forgive the lack of knowledge of these laws because Hudson and DeSantis probably haven't gotten to those pesky legal issues in their crash course they took when they decided to become police chiefs.

Julio Jaramillo, an attorney with the law firm on contract with the RPOA attempted to enter interrogation room and represent Floyd but Sgt. Derwin Hudson blocked him and informed them “You can’t come in…he doesn’t get an attorney because they are treating him as a witness.” He also said, “it’s not coming from me, they told me not to let you in.”

A side note, what's fascinating about Jaramillo representing Floyd is that when Jaramillo a former Santa Ana Police Department officer worked for the Riverside County Public Defender's office several years ago, he represented a woman on trial for battering Floyd and resisting arrest during an incident in Casa Blanca in October 2004. He cross-examined Floyd during that trial for over four hours. That experience provides a touch of irony in this case as he has clearly found himself on the other side of the proverbial coin but he's very acquainted with Floyd going into the interrogation.

A few days later Floyd was contacted by the department, to be interviewed to “clear up a few issues” and Floyd was not informed about it and the interview lasted 10 minutes.

Since this incident, management had stated “made a mistake by allowing [Petitioner Ili] to have an attorney. Will not allow attorneys in the future.”

This particular case is extremely fascinating for reasons included in relation to the allegations in the lawsuit but also because of the city's representation of officer-involved shootings (and deaths) being "criminal investigations" with "crime scenes" which need to be preserved from among other things private investigators hired by the Community Police Review Commission. But the funny thing is that here, the city's taking the same position that it did in a motion for summary judgment that it filed against a similar lawsuit filed by the RPOA in 2003, and that's insisting that as far as the officers are concerned, these type of onduty incidents are not criminal investigations.

According to the city, the officers are victims and witnesses, not criminal suspects and the purposes of their interviews is not to interrogate potential criminal defendants but to get information that is equivalent to what would be provided in a written report. This may or may be what's really involved here, but it's always been the city's position in legal documents that officer-involved shootings and/or deaths are not criminal investigations. The city and some department heads have rhapsodised on about how these are sensitive criminal investigations when its legal position (and probably procedural as well) is that if anyone is being subjected to a criminal investigation, it's the person who was shot and/or killed by the officer. If that person is deceased as in a fatal shooting for example, then that person can never be charged with a crime. So that criminal investigation as the city defines it is over.

It's ridiculous to continue to hold the CPRC hostage over its officer-involved death investigations by claiming that these cases involve sensitive criminal investigations when the city makes it clear over and over in responses to litigation filed by the RPOA that it believes the opposite. It did this during the RPOA's lawsuit filed in 2003 and it has already done so with the current one filed in autumn 2009, roughly one year after first the city manager's office and then the majority of the city council by vote essentially brought the CPRC's ability to effectively carry out its charter mandate to investigate incustody deaths to an end.

And if these officer-involved deaths and/or shootings are indeed criminally investigated by the department, then get these officers their attorneys already or be quiet when selling the city residents a stolen bag of goods about things like the integrity of the crime scene being jeopardized by CPRC investigators. Because the city is trying to have it both ways and it can't.


Officers Sancho Lopez and Juan Munoz


On Feb. 22, 2008 Department Sergeant Denny Corbett called Lopez in his office to discuss why Lopez and Munoz did not take police reports on a vandalism. After that meeting, Lopez went to write the report. Lopez is informed that Lt. Guy Touissant wants to speak with him. Lopez went to meet with Toussaint. Toussaint immediately yelled at Lopez stating that he was “pissed off” and that Lopez had blown Corbett off and that his answers to Corbett were “bullshit.” Toussaint accused Lopez of lying and threatened that he would “do Juan and Lopez”. Toussaint pushed a copy of PC 135 towards Lopez and said he was thinking of calling DA to file criminal charges against Lopez and Munoz for destruction of evidence.

Toussaint then allegedly threatened to remove Lopez from FTO program and retrain all his trainees.


“You make a blue rag look like shit”—Toussaint allegedly said to Lopez.


Ten minutes later, Lopez was called in by Toussaint and given a chance to “make it right” by going back to reporting party and taking report. Corbett later apologized to Lopez for the incident and said that Lopez and Munoz would receive a negative preliminary investigations report. Lopez and Munoz were told they wouldn’t be allowed to ride together until the investigation was over. Lopez was never given Miranda or Lybarger (a compelled statement can not be used against him by criminal investigators or prosecutors although this doesn't apply to federal agencies) before being threatened with the criminal charges, according to the lawsuit.


Officer Paul Turner


In March 2008, Turner was called into the department watch commander’s office and interrogated about a traffic collision hit and run that Petitioner Turner disputes the occurrence of though it doesn't elaborate on whether Turner was involved in it or took a report on one. If it were the former, then the allegations of him not being mirandized or given the Lynbarger admonition would make more sense than if he were just there taking a report or had actually witnessed it.

Still, Turner allegedly had asked for a RPOA representative and was denied. He was never advised that he was under investigation by the department. He was never given Miranda and Lynbarger admonition prior to being interrogated by the alleged criminal hit and run violation.


Officer Giovanni Ili

He was involved in an officer-involved shooting. At first management denied Ili access to RPOA representation but then they finally relented. The department or city's attorneys later called the denial of attorney a "harmless error".



Sgt. Ron Whitt

On Dec. 17, 2008, Whitt was reassigned from Special Operations Bureau to the Field Operation Bureau. He was informed that the reassignment was due to a “perception issue” and if he failed to be reassigned voluntarily, he would be “packaged up and mov[ed] anyway[s].” Whitt lost his 3% bonus pay that came from that assignment and he wasn’t provided with an administrative hearing to appeal it.

The legal action alleges multiple violations of governmental codes that were committed by the department's management.

The lawsuit asks that the court issue a permanent injunction against further violations of the act and that the city pays attorney's fees, back pay to the officers with interest and reinstates Whitt to his old position in the Special Operations Bureau.




The city responds

The city filed a motion to demurrer to try to throw the lawsuit out and in it, states that the petition should be denied by the judge because it is “uncertain, vague and ambiguous, unintelligible and contradictory”. The city alleged that Lopez wasn’t interrogated but was questioned and admonished in the normal course of duty and that initially denying Ili an attorney was a harmless error. The city stuck mostly to semantic issues when addressing the allegations in the lawsuit rather than substantive.

The city also argued that the lawsuit was formulated incorrectly in violation of a state rule of court.

“They are a jumbled mess of conclusions of law, and the facts that are provided are contradictory and ambiguous", the city claimed.


The attorneys for the city also claimed that both Floyd and Turner knew they were being interrogated while they had claimed they did not. Even if the people weren’t notified, it was a harmless error on the part of the department.

Toussaint’s reprimand was called an “informal verbal admonishment" given to an officer by the city. It's interesting that the city didn't challenge the actual content of this reprimand or challenge Toussaint's alleged use of colorful language. If that's the case, is using profanity the city's idea of an informal reprimand and the lack of the use of such language called a formal one? Of course, it's just as possible that Toussaint never said these things but then the city really should be defending him on that if that's the case as that would be the appropriate action to take.

This lawsuit is just getting started as the RPOA is currently accepting nominations from its members in anticipation of the upcoming biennial president's election. A couple individuals were thinking of running including one patrol officer who said he would carry the patrol division but that he probably wouldn't run and a sergeant and a couple members of the RPOA board or committees both long time members who might be thinking about it as well. The election if called will be held probably in November with the new term starting at the beginning of next year.





It's raining Police law suits at Riverside City Hall


If you happen to look at an agenda of the Riverside City Council meeting that is going to be held Tuesday, Oct. 20 at City Hall, you'll notice that the list of closed session items has increased a bit in the past month or so. This week, there's a plethora of litigation and "anticipated" litigation. And there are included on the docket two lawsuits filed involving the police department on the wake of discussion talks by the city council at an earlier meeting about the lawsuit filed by Los Angeles Police Department Sgt. Wayne Guillary against the department alleging racial profiling and excessive force during an incident in late 2008.

Just look at the agenda where there are two lawsuits filed by individuals in the Riverside Police Department. Both of the lawsuits including the most recent one filed by the RPOA will be covered in future postings of this blog. But as far as the city's concerned, most of the discussions involving the lawsuit filed by Lt. Tim Bacon and Lt. Darryl Hurt and the lawsuit filed by the Riverside Police Officers' Association (which is outlined above), all the discussion will take place in absolute secrecy behind closed doors. In fact, if you click the above links, there's actually nothing about the lawsuits except the parties involved and the case number, plus a bunch of generic language which is part of a form letter.

But just like any lawsuit, there's a lot going on behind closed doors and inside court rooms in both federal and state court with these case. The issues arising in both lawsuits and any future ones that are filed will be the topics of analysis and discussion in the weeks and months ahead as the police department faces a multitude of issues. Also to be discussed is the historic role of the city manager in the operations of the police department, most particularly that involving current City Manager Brad Hudson and his assistant, Tom DeSantis as well as the role of City Attorney Gregory Priamos.

Not to mention the diminishing role of Police Chief Russ Leach who doesn't appear to have been given hardly any autonomy by his bosses to run his own department. And this case could be one example of what can happen when city administrators start expanding their role to running individual departments including those in public safety. A police chief like Leach is probably cognizant about labor laws pertaining to peace officers whereas the knowledge of the city manager's office might or might be just enough to fill up the space on a postage stamp because their education is usually not that specific. If there are indeed labor violations such as these occurring inside the police department, then that would because people inside it are either not running the agency or being directed to run it in a specific way by an entity outside of it because police chiefs usually have the experience and acknowledgment of their specific area of management as part of their profession to avoid these problems and Leach certainly is no exception to that.

The lawsuit filed by Lt. Tim Bacon and Lt. Darryl Hurt speaks more through the allegations to whether or not outside entities are micromanaging the police department including Hudson, DeSantis and even then and current members of the city council, all of whom were named as defendants and/or were prominently mentioned in the lawsuit.

Because it's only been three years and some months since the dissolution of the stipulated judgment and the police department has definitely gone off-track. The city council as a body in its worship fest involving Hudson (including city council members who chair committees and wait to be told by Hudson or one of his assistant managers to be told what to do including when to hold meetings) has allowed him and DeSantis to continue to micromanage a police agency. According to former councilman and current mayor, Art Gage, Hudson had been the topic of some discussions on his handling of the police department at least two years ago and at the time, he had promised to stop micromanaging it. But apparently, that behavior is still continuing and it will be the topic of discussion in the continuing series of blog postings, Too Many Chiefs in the RPD's Kitchen.



Micromanagement 101's more humorous side


This one's kind of funny and it involves one of the most micromanaged entities at City Hall which is naturally the CPRC. Either DeSantis or his conduit of choice, CPRC Manager Kevin Rogan submitted a memo to commissioners listing the criteria for when the members of the CPRC could and couldn't wear their own shirts designating them as commissioners which they bought and paid for out of their own pockets. And then telling them they had to turn them into the city manager's office when their terms expired.

Okay, what is wrong with this picture? And you would think that DeSantis would be the last individual in a position to tell people how and when to appropriately represent themselves while wearing uniforms representing the city. Let's put DeSantis in a room with CPRC commissioners and ask them all to raise their hands if they were ever wearing their city or CPRC shirts when someone called 911 reporting them. It's highly likely that only one hand would be going up in that room.





Mayoral Candidate Art Gage appears at the Friday Morning Club


About 30 people congregated at the Friday Morning Club's meeting to listen to former councilman and current mayoral candidate Art Gage who answered their questions and presented his platform to them. They asked questions about issues including the red light photo cameras in the city's intersections, to the financial accountability of City Hall to issues involving trash and utility rates. It's been interesting to see Gage's populist campaign in action. It's difficult to know what to make of it at all but he's provided an interesting counterpart as the outsider to Mayor Ron Loveridge's stance as the ultimate insider at City Hall but given that he is going to have a tough time to win here, he's likely trying to build a base from which to run in 2012 when four-year terms are back in vogue and there won't be an incumbent.

Gage also discussed the city council's apparent decision to allow Hudson, its direct employee to run the city including the police department.

He also said that as mayor, he would within the 30 days bring all the stakeholders involved in the situation involving the CPRC's inability to "do its job" and conduct independent investigations of officer-involved deaths and they wouldn't leave the room until the consensus was reached to allow the commission to do its job. He felt that it was the mayor who was in the best position to help address issues such as that one. Gage was one of the biggest detractors of the CPRC and it remains to be seen if an adversary of the commission might be a bigger asset to it than its so-called "allies" on the dais including Loveridge. Because with friends like those...you won't have a functional police commission much longer.

He also said that when he was a member of the Planning Commission, the Chinatown issue had come before them and the County Office of Education which owns the property including Chinatown could only build on it if it was parking, with dirt to protect the ground or a monument. He felt that the Chinatown should be rebuilt to serve as a site to preserve the history and attract tourists.





Press Enterprise Columnist Dan Bernstein wrote about his visit to Casa Blanca in Riverside where a community meeting was held inviting Riverside County Superior Court Judge Roger Luebs to address controversial remarks he made at the sentencing hearing after a murder trial.


(excerpt)



Longtime Casa Blanca activist Morris Mendoza sat across from the bow-tied judge in a small conference room and told him: "I felt outraged. A lot of people work hard to better this community."

Danny Garcia, a Caltrans manager and CB resident: "I took it personally," and others did, too.

What did Luebs say that so offended this group? "Neighborhood" and "community." He didn't say Casa Blanca, but our story did, since this is where the killings occurred.

"When you say 'community' or 'neighborhood,' " Mendoza told Luebs, "it narrows it down. We've been working on solutions."

This may sound like a silly discussion, but it's not. There's a lot going on beneath the surface, and it can pretty much be capsulized in four words:

"You don't know us."

You don't know about our library, our park, our recreation programs. You don't know how much we're knocking ourselves out to give kids no excuse for getting hooked up with gangs and crime.

I don't think that's entirely fair to Luebs, who's lived in Riverside for years and does know about some of these things. But as long as there's the perception that a judge is sitting on high and sounding off on something he knows little about, his words -- especially if they can be misinterpreted -- will always trump bigger problems and common interests.

As the meeting went on, Luebs allowed that he should have worded his remarks differently. But that didn't change the guts of what he had to say, and he got no argument when he said it: "Gang violence is a real problem, and the city of Riverside doesn't take it as seriously as it should." It's as if it is "someone else's problem." And not just in CB.

This violence is tolerated, Luebs said. Maybe not encouraged, but enabled and accepted.

The result: Not the same old grizzled gangbangers wreaking the same old mayhem, but "a new generation of gangbangers." This will continue "until we bring other resources to bear ... a broad community response by school districts, services clubs," etc.




What Luebs said here is what he should have said at the hearing, that the gang problems in Riverside are city issues not just neighborhood ones. After all, the latest hate group and perhaps gang in the making, the Neo Nazis just protest in Casa Blanca once in a while, they don't live there.




Hemet is $800,000 in the red




Is the city of Hemet in financial trouble? The financial situation is pretty bleak.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



Hemet also faces the prospect of having to turn over $4.4 million in redevelopment money to the state, said interim city Finance Director Thomas Kanarr.

"That's a big chunk of the reserves we have left in the Redevelopment Agency," Kanarr said this week during a presentation to the City Council.

Revised budget estimates after the first quarter of fiscal year 2009-10, which was July through September, show sales tax revenue continues to be weak and federal grants remain elusive.

Hemet officials failed to get a $312,000 federal grant for traffic enforcement. The city also received less than half of a $772,000 grant sought for more police officers.

City officials plan to reapply for or seek other grants, particularly federal stimulus money.

Hemet has slashed almost 30 police and fire jobs as well as dozens of other positions over the past year.







Another Mayoral Candidate Web site



Mayoral candidate Ken Stansbury who is running as a write-in has gone online.
Ken Stansbury 4 mayor. Go check it out.


He's also appearing at the Friday Morning Club's meeting next Friday, Oct. 23 at 10 am at the Janet Goeske Center on Sierra, near Streeter.

Labels: , , ,

Update: RPD Officer Dave Reeves, jr. filed claim in courts before Arrest

UPDATE: David Reeves, Jr. arraigned on 12 felony counts including robbery, attempted robbery, assault with a deadly weapon and burglary. His bail was raised to $500,000. ********


The Riverside Police Officers' Association sues City of Riverside over interrogation practices involving police officers. More to come...



An update on the arrest of former Riverside Police Department Officer Dave Reeves, jr. after Moreno Valley Police Department officers responded to a 911 regarding an armed robbery at an auto parts store. Several police agencies are investigating Reeves now to determine whether or not he was involved in other similar robberies in at least two cities.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)

Briones said Reeves confronted a customer working on his car outside the store in the 23500 block of Sunnymead Boulevard.

Holding the customer at gunpoint, Briones said, Reeves entered the store and ordered employees to empty the safe. Employees overpowered Reeves, causing him minor facial injuries, he said.

Police arrived momentarily and took Reeves into custody. He identified himself as an off-duty officer and was found with a stolen illegal assault rifle, not related to his police duties, Briones said.

He was booked at the Robert Presley Detention Center in Riverside, where he is being held with bail set at $250,000.

Moreno Valley police suspect Reeves in several other robberies outside the city, Briones said.

Police declined to reveal the motive in the holdup and are pursuing other leads.




A representative from the Riverside Police Officers' Association said that Reeves had been removed from the patrol division before his arrest. He later either resigned or was terminated from the police department.

The comments as they usually do in articles like this just keep on coming and so do other pieces of information.




Reeves Files a Claim for Injunctive Relief in Riverside County Superior Court



According to the court records found on the Riverside County Superior Court's Web site, Reeves filed a claim for injunctive relief against the city of Riverside with the date stamped, Oct. 7, 2009 just one week before his arrest. He had also filed a claim with the state's Fair Employment and Housing organization. The defendants in the lawsuit included the city, Chief Russ Leach, Sgt. George Masson and Capt. Mike Blakely.

According to his complaint, Reeves had been employed by the police department since 2001 and was a member of its union, the RPOA. In 2003, he severely fractured two neck vertebrae while off-duty.

In December 2008, Reeves suffered another neck injury causing him pain which he took narcotic medication to relieve and he was placed by the department on light duty. He had to undergo an examination several months later to see whether or not he was fit to remain a police officer which included obtaining medical records from various medical providers. Personnel Captain Michael Blakely gave him some time off from work. Reeves said that the records from Kaiser Medical Center took longer than expected which caused him to miss more work. Blakely then talked to him about his tardiness and said that he was suspected of using drugs. In his complaint, Reeves said there was no explanation provided by Blakely as to why he thought he was using drugs. At the time, Reeves stated he hadn't been taking any pain medication. At some point, he was compelled to take a drug test by Blakely and so it was off to the Internal Affairs Division.

Reeves said he was forced to ride in the same car as Blakely when he had requested to ride with his representative, RPOA President Chris Lanzillo. Lanzillo and Reeves had wanted to meet in private but were required to meet in the building instead. Blakely had Sgt. George Masson issue some field sobriety tests to Reeves. Reeves alleged that this was done solely to embarrass and humiliate him. He was asked to take a voluntary drug and alcohol urine test. Reeves declined. Lanzillo asked if he could contact Det. Ron Kipp to do the same tests as Masson because as a long-time narcotics detective, he had the experience to do a better job.

Blakely refused to allow that even when Reeves' attorney arrived. Reeves was compelled to undertake an administrative review by Blakely as to why he was tardy and why he showed up to work under the influence of drugs. Blakely also told Reeves that he couldn't participate in any field sobriety tests with his lawyer until after the meeting. Reeves met with a female attorney outside the building in a car with management standing by which led him to feel pressured, he stated. He finally did produce a urine sample to be tested.

So Reeves turns in a claim for injunction release for a drug test done on him a while back and that was filed a week before his arrest for armed robbery. That case is still in the courts, in its early stages without the city having had time to provide a response in return.

Reeves hasn't been charged with any crimes, just arrested for armed robbery, kidnapping and possession of an illegal gun, an assault rifle. He's in custody on $250,000 bail waiting to see what happens next.





Riverside creates yet another advisory committee. This one for bicycle riders.



(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



The city already had a long-term plan for bicycle facilities. In fact, the City Council heard a progress report on the plan Tuesday. But a document wasn't enough for Mayor Ron Loveridge.

"It's a plan. It just sort of sits there," Loveridge said. "We wanted to enhance the biking culture in Riverside."

Loveridge said he was impressed to learn that as many as 12,000 bicyclists per day cross the Willamette River in Portland, Ore., a city that has a bicycle advisory committee. Hoping to boost biking here, he formed Riverside's bike committee, which held its first meeting in September.

Cyclists who are on the committee said they're thrilled to see it come together.

"The Public Works Department has been working, as they put it, in a vacuum for years and years," said Pete Staylor, a member of the Riverside Bicycle Club. "Now they're getting input and suggestions from actual bicyclists."

Staylor, 56, has been biking since he was diagnosed with osteoarthritis in 2002 and had to give up higher-impact sports such as tennis and basketball.

He said his priority is maintenance and improvement of existing bike lines -- filling potholes, evening out pavement, and widening lanes -- "anything we can do to make bicycling safer," he said.







Experience vs new ideas in the Ward One City Council race in San Bernardino.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)



Incumbent City Councilwoman Esther Estrada, 68, was first elected to the council in 1975 and served off and on through the early 1990s. She returned to the council in 1998 and has represented the First Ward since then.

Estrada said progress is beginning to be made on issues such as downtown revitalization and Westside improvements and she wants to see those projects through.

"I'm determined to stay on the council and do the best job I can and still punch away at those things," she said.

But her challenger, Virginia Marquez, 53, questions Estrada's effectiveness. She accused Estrada of being inaccessible to constituents.

"She is out of touch with the community," Marquez said. "She is just nowhere to be found."

Marquez, who cited the deterioration of the city's Westside as her reason for running, said she can bring new ideas to the council.

Estrada dismisses the criticism as typical political sloganeering.

"That's an old argument that any challenger can use and has been used against me in the past," she said, adding that she has defeated those opponents.

Labels: , ,

Newer›  ‹Older