Five before Midnight

This site is dedicated to the continuous oversight of the Riverside(CA)Police Department, which was formerly overseen by the state attorney general. This blog will hopefully play that role being free of City Hall's micromanagement.
"The horror of that moment," the King went on, "I shall never, never forget." "You will though," the Queen said, "if you don't make a memorandum of it." --Lewis Carroll

Contact: fivebeforemidnight@yahoo.com

My Photo
Name:
Location: RiverCity, Inland Empire

Thursday, February 03, 2011

River City: Anatomy of a Football Game


[Sedgwick River came back in force and was still active 12 hours after a brief rain storm. One elected official said that the city will attempt to use FEMA funding to repair it after receiving many complaints from students having to cross it to attend several schools when it's flooded.]






River City Hall Drops Two CPRC Commissioners in Political Melee

Politics Still Rules Process as immunity challenges denied


[The Community Police Review Commission remains the political football of City Hall during the annual appointment process for commissioners]




[The City Council, here having a discussion on ahem, ethics underwent its appointment process for the CPRC ]




Contrariwise, if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic.

---Lewis Carroll






It doesn't matter what they say
In the jealous games people play
Our lips are sealed
Pay no mind to what they say
It doesn't matter anyway
Our lips are sealed

There's a weapon
We must use
In our defense
Silence


----The Go Gos





Some people walked out at the end of the annual exercise in appointing Community Police Review Commission in absolute shock at the outcome but I wasn't one of them. I looked at it two different ways. As a city resident, it was pretty appalling, but as a blogger who writes about politics at City Hall, once again very interesting material to work with once again from the halls of power. It was a very sad day for the CPRC which has seen a lot of them as it nears a critical anniversary but once again City Hall was showing that there's something else that puts Riverside on the national map besides high unemployment and errant water studies (as city officials discussed another study released) and that's what goes on inside its power structure.

It's a shame because Riverside has a lot of positive qualities but they're mostly out in the communities and neighborhoods and not on center stage where essentially how City Hall has carried out some of its business has put Riverside on the national news radar and not in a good way.

After watching this process for the past 10 years there's never been a shortage of constant reminders of just how political the commission remains at City Hall which has adopted it as one of its favorite playthings. And given the past 10 years of observing and witnessing what's been happening at City Hall including its ever evolving Seventh Floor complete with its own revolving door, it's nearly impossible at this point to really be surprised by anything that happens there. Because what the city government provided was a lesson plan in the more things appear to change, the more they remain the same.

As if hearing that the city manager "persuaded" a class of employees into cutting their deferred compensation when he gets to hold onto most of his due to his unique contract language hadn't been a reminder of that. Even though he gets far more than the $3,000 figure cited through his ahem, contract language he still gives up only a small percentage of it. But then one elected official at the belated reception for the new Community Police Review Commission manager actually called their loss of deferred compensation a "slight pay cut". In itself, the use of some rather interesting language that's not really accurate.

But anyway, the CPRC appointment process pretty much the way that it was anticipated to go. After all, when the process regarding incumbents is changed behind the scenes with no one knowing when or explaining why and certainly not allowing public comment yeah, people are going to think that there's some ulterior motive behind it. Good things involving community volunteer positions on the boards and commissions which are supposed to serve as very transparent mechanisms of participation by city residents just don't happen veiled in secrecy behind closed doors. But people thought, no the city just wants to give every applicant a fair process and that's not a bad thing but then again, it was pretty clear after watching the process itself that took place what whoever made the changes was actually thinking something else entirely. And it provided a very salient lesson from a very old history book for those in attendance.

In fact, the two incumbents didn't even know they were up for interview until told by other people besides the city officials who should have notified them much earlier than they did. They might have had questions about why they were suddenly and without being duly informed subjected to a completely different process than existed with their predecessors and a completely different process than incumbents in most of the city's boards and commissions. Does that make the changes in protocol bad in themselves? No, they might even be good, they might even be useful, they might even be fairer but the lack of communication about them and the complete mystery which surrounds how these changes took place and when just served as an overture to what took place afterward.

That delay in notification of the involved parties just feeds the theory that there was an ulterior motive to it, because again if there had been any integrity, the changes would have been made in a public manner which would invite public input rather than behind the closed door of some office or conference room on the Seventh Floor which is what apparently did happen. And it happened either through the ignorance or the tacit blessing of everyone on the dais even after everything that City Hall put the residents in this city through last year. Even after it should have learned that this kind of behavior behind closed doors has been detrimental to the public trust in the city and one of its departments. Even after learning that losing public trust is so much more easily done than rebuilding it. What the city government showed after an appalling lack of active leadership last year through the most difficult days in the city's recent memory is that collectively and perhaps even individually, it really hasn't learned a damn thing and that's shameful because of the high costs that 2010 incurred on many people including city employees who didn't deserve to pay the price to what others in more insulated positions had or may have done.

After all what did City Hall do, it handed off an "independent" and "sweeping" investigation to one of its employees who probably should have been included in any such investigation because he supervised and many say micromanaged the department head in question. Did anyone at City Hall publicly object to this inherent fox guarding the hen house action?

No.

Did any elected official suggest that a truly outside independent investigation be done?

No.

And did any of them respond when a couple of their direct employees were mired in serious questions about the accuracy or even production of their employee phone records?

No, of course not.


It was left to a community organized coalition and no doubt many irate city residents to ask or try to ask those questions and to try to address those issues. And when at least one elected official was "caught" (or a "got you" as one elected official said was a reason not to hand over public documents when requested) with some serious questions to answer when revelations of some of the scandalous behavior at City Hall came to light, he dismissed it as "old news" essentially patting himself on the back and everyone else for ensuring that it wasn't discovered until it became "old". Some elected officials were at least cognizant enough to realize the peril of that certainly politically and tried to create avenues for ethics complaints to be filed against elected officials later than six months after the alleged incident.

One reason why this matters whether or not the city government even chose to acknowledge that serious problems took place last year is that it's through this process that lessons are learned, often painfully and behavior including that which is deeply entrenched is changed. After all, as the first anniversary of the DUI incident involving the former chief approaches, is the city really taking the steps to ensure that there are not future incidents of scandal? And if so, what are they? So far not much of anything.

The mayoral state of address was very revealing as there was no mention of anything that happened last year and the hiring of Chief Sergio Diaz was treated almost as if he dropped out of the clouds one day. When it's very important for the city council and mayor to both acknowledge publicly and show that they have an institutional memory of exactly how the city's newest police chief got here to avoid trying to make the same mistakes as it did before. It would have been refreshing to hear Loveridge say what lessons he had learned from last year during his speech and the steps that City Hall was taking to avoid any further scandals but since he has spent most of last year acting in public like they don't exist then that wasn't going to happen. That would have shown true leadership from a City Hall where it's completely lacking. Ironic considering how many elected officials have either declared or thinking about trying out for mayor next year.

Not all that shocking after the year that just was, but pretty disappointing anyway and it's left people shaking their heads as the news spreads about what happened during the appointment process for one of the city's most compromised boards or commissions. It's interesting because it left people hoping that the governmental body and the city itself doesn't hire or promote employees through the same process that it appoints board members and commissioners but then wait, that's how the police department and city ran its promotional system for at least the past five years at its highest levels, according to a lawsuit filed by two now retired police lieutenants. And there were similarities between the process and priorities behind those selections for CPRC commissioners as was done with the department's upper echelon promotional system so maybe what happened in the conference room at City Hall really shouldn't have been that surprising.

Still, I was pretty much sitting in the chair during the process waiting for the power plays in a couple cases to begin...as they often had done before because that's what the rule book states and no one's willing to write a new manual at least not so far. It's to the point where they should not have applicants come in and do interviews but maybe just run the names through the city council like they do in the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee because it's clear that the interviews themselves for the most part are a waste of a perfectly good day.

Even though this year produced some of the better questions asked by council members, it was pretty clear that no one really paid attention to the answers. The only unintentional comedic relief was when Adams asked what could be done to bridge the gap between the police department and the CPRC (which ironically, Beeman provided the best answer and explained mechanisms to do that, alas ones vetoed by the commission or its staff itself) which is pretty funny considering his own sworn testimony and some of the revelations that came out about him in two lawsuits filed by former police lieutenants that were settled last year.

Because if an elected official is really as alleged vetoing the chief's promotions and harassing and threatening union leaders who don't support him politically, and has never been a behind the scenes supporter of the commission, then maybe they should be answering the question themselves rather than asking it. But for the most part, the questions were better than in previous years...too bad it didn't really matter because those who provided the most thoughtful, less crowd pleasing responses, those who answered them best were among the first eliminated from consideration.

That didn't have to discuss it because unlike with more ordinary business, they didn't have to explain their votes or even discuss...almost as if the commission appointment process was just another item on an overcrowded consent calendar.

The city council and the mayor talk about how transparent (and the more they have to talk about it, the less it usually is) the process is, yet they cast votes written on slips of paper (presumably to prevent bloc building) and that's all that's said on the votes. No insight as to why they pick this person over that one (though it's clear that some of them didn't really want to explain and it's not hard to understand why)...it's really not much different than if they held the deliberation or votes in closed session rather than an open meeting. It doesn't leave much to trust in the current process and it's been interesting trying to explain over the past 10 years how it works or is an example of democracy in action to those individuals witnessing it for the first time who walk away from it with a much different impression.

That's what has happened during this process many a time because it really does provide a look at what the elected government in this city is really all about and you wonder if it's this sad a display in public, what's it like in private? Because it's hard to walk out of a process like that and not really be concerned about how the government's being run especially with a couple of them but then you have to remember, the city council in the last five years has farmed out most of its accountability powers and responsibilities to its administration.

It sat by and allowed a police department for example to be run by civilian managers who mainly seemed to be more preoccupied with decking themselves out like police officers and micromanaging that department down to its last dime. And it's pretty clear now what kind of affect that had on a department which has three management team members including a chief from outside the city.

But then most of us who've been paying attention to the dilution and micromanagement of a civilian oversight mechanism like the CPRC aren't exactly shocked by what transpired in 2010 in this city. Maybe that's why most of the governmental officials were silent when it happened, out of shock but then again, some of them dismissed it all as "old news" and probably patted themselves for their lack of transparency in terms of the public knowing.

Because the public are left in the dark about what rationale the elected officials are using when they're making appointments or as was clear in this case, rejecting them. And the city government's certainly not concerned enough to change the process to create greater transparency.


Then again, it seemed likely that some discussions had taken place already and if this process was held behind closed doors, it's likely that there might be more discussion about the votes. What's clear is that not one of them feels comfortable or that it matters to discuss them in public before the votes are cast. In some ways that's unique to this process certainly in recent years but it's also not that much different from city council meetings in generals as the years pass.

That's why people think that going to city council meetings in general on most issues is a waste of time because they know when the council members and mayor sits down, the minds have usually been made up and the discussions that truly matter have already taken place. With people much more important than mere mortals who only have the power of the vote, but have shown in the past three election cycles that they know how to use it and how to grade their political officials. How can members of the public stack their opinions on issues with the really important constituents like developers and why bother to provide an assessment when asked about commission appointments when it still comes down to politics or elements like who's friends with who, who burned who years earlier or whether a person played golf or was on a particular soccer team.

And when you have city council members boycotting public comment because they don't like what people say (and they don't realize that their departures are caught on camera for the viewers at home), then what you have is a city council that's not in touch with all of its constituents, not just those on the city's Rolodex to phone when they need them to "me too" an item that the city government wants to pass that they think many people might not like or have questions about. One of the most popular questions I receive when meeting people who watch the meetings at home is why even bother going to the meetings because the city government doesn't seem interested and have even appeared hostile to people appearing unless they are there to applaud them even when they haven't done anything. That's a reason why the fact that so many incumbents have been voted out in recent years is hardly surprising and it's not likely the city's seen the last of that sentiment. They get voted out no matter who endorses them, something for incumbent city council to keep in mind first of all when they choose to do blanket endorsements of each other and then watch "their" choices get handed pink slips. But even those who defeated them haven't learned that lesson so it's not realistic to think that those who have engaged in that tradition longer to have done so.

But the CPRC has always been a popular football to toss around and try to intercept in the pass.

That's why in the end it doesn't really matter how much politicians at City Hall and their staff manipulate mechanisms like the CPRC and the newer toy, the Ethics Code and Complaint process. Doing so doesn't seem to help their own political survival either.

Because the votes cast would be public either way...only in a closed session, one can bet there'd be a lot more discussion and debate over candidates especially in close votes where there's no majority decision or result.



It's no less the political football that it was when it was created in 2000, out of political necessity and a lot of good intentions and it's no less than it was in November 2004 when about 60% of the city's voters passed a ballot initiative to put it in the city's charter. That action was done in an attempt to put its use as a political football by City Hall behind it, but it appears that the Seventh Floor politics and those who play them were just getting warmed up. Not much of a legacy for the commission which turned 10 years in January.

But what the city government doesn't know yet is that the more they grab onto that football, the less powerful it becomes because in actuality, the CPRC doesn't get its power from the political actions of politicians who themselves have been pretty interchangeable at the voting polls recently but for the community which has frankly lost faith and lost touch with the commission years ago. And the actions taken by the powers that be on the Seventh Floor aren't going to change that. What today's selection process has done already is generate talk that the appointment itself needs a charter change and what the community is talking about is well, if the city government wants to make it their political process, then the communities can make it all about politics beginning on the campaign trail this year.

What was striking about it, is that you had elected officials espouse one quality they prized most in commissioners before they eliminated candidates who held those qualities without any discussion of their actions. Take the councilman who was so concerned about those signing on knowing how much time the commission would require from them. He then turned around and voted for two candidates who appeared to have the least clue about how much time the commission would take and eliminated two incumbents, one who worked in a political campaign of the former councilman he defeated in his own election. Another councilman voted for at least half of those on the applicant list at least once, changing his selections completely each of the first three rounds of voting.

And who could forget the council members who said training, training, training was paramount and not just here and then they ejected the candidates who pushed for more training, the incumbents. Don't be surprised if some of the ideas that the incumbents provided are adopted by the council and credited to City Hall though given its track record at actually carrying out that kind of process with the CPRC, it's really difficult to be that impressed that anything will actually happen. And that the CPRC will be left with a third of its membership brand new with one of the only commissioners with experience and interest in mentoring newer members left on the sidelines.

What the city council and mayor collectively showed in this process was that they don't get it, they don't understand why the CPRC came to be, its tumultuous history

The only thing surprising was that at least five city officials appointed Robin Jackson for the first spot, the new candidate in the mix who gave by far the best all around interview in a pool which was far from "outstanding" as Councilman Chris MacArthur said. The former Santa Ana Police Department officer turned RCC photography instructor gave an interview that clearly showed she had prepared for her interview by doing research, had a lot of diverse skills to offer and was clearly interested by selecting the commission as her choice rather than as an also-ran or not even listed as an interest at all. And to a lot of people's amazement, she won appointment in only one round of voting even though she produced one of the best interviews in years and the interview seemed to be the most reflective in terms of her personality of all the candidates.

But as far as going based on the same qualities which they embraced in her, they stopped doing that after the first vote and adopted tried and true (and if you've followed this process for 10 years, you've seen all these tactics) and very political choices in the following rounds. They weren't particularly difficult to pick out either but what was disappointing is that they are the same political games. One candidate picked, Ralph Johnson, a former San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department seem to give the impression that he was applying for a job on the police department rather than a spot on the commission which provides oversight. And he didn't relate anything on his rather impressive professional resume in regards of his law enforcement career or his interview about community involvement.

Jane Adams, the other candidate who won after several rounds of narrow voting didn't even have the CPRC listed on her application as one she was interested on and she gave a good interview for applying for one of the other boards and commissions that she was clearly more interested in but didn't offer much up in what she would bring with the CPRC or seem to know much about it. It's a much steeper learning curve for people who don't seem very interested in the CPRC in particular rather than commissions in general.

Hart and others said it all though in the interview when they said they had to get the losing applicants on the other city boards and commissions without realizing the irony in that, this was how they stacked the CPRC's new appointments already. She beat out Andrew McManus, a sometimes bail bonds enforcer who didn't really give the impression he was that interested in the commission either. But then most of the city council isn't either so maybe that's why they relate so well to picking applicants to whom the CPRC's not on the radar or who don't seem to know much about it when there's much research available not to mention meetings to attend each month.


The selection process began auspiciously enough when the city council and mayor decided that rather than automatically appointing incumbent board and commission members to second terms, they would put them into the general pool. With the CPRC, the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Commission started with a list of applicants to that commission, winnowed it down to 13 with both incumbents Chani Beeman and Peter Hubbard and then the phone calls started being made to select applicants in the applicant pool for the city's other boards and commissioners and another group of them including those who hadn't even considered going out for the CPRC were added to the interview pool. That's nothing unusual, as that's happened before with even new applications being added to the CPRC applicant pool itself.

But there were questions asked why Beeman and Hubbard were required to go through the reappointment process that was different from all prior reappointment processes and in what public venue, the city council and mayor voted to change that process? Both the Planning Commission and Board of Public Utilities were treated in the same fashion and the handling of the CPRC's appointment process might be a preview for what's in store for the incumbents of those boards and commissions including one member of the Planning Commission who already sounded as if she were in trouble at the Mayor's Nomination and Screening Committee meeting last month. But the talk was already starting that the incumbents at least those for the CPRC were in serious trouble.

And ultimately both Beeman and Hubbard were voted off the commission by a city council and mayor who seemed more intent on voting people off than in voting people on, as evidenced by some of the comments made by council members including Councilwoman Nancy Hart who said, we've got another one out....and so forth. The meeting which has been audio recorded one hopes is pretty eye opening as it is clear that elected officials who should have been trained in this process stumble over the process even as they fumble the football.

Any beliefs that it would be otherwise were more than defused by what transpired at the end of the all-day interview process. The ability of elected officials to engage in that is greatly facilitated by the fact that there's zero discussion at least in public about why political officials cast the votes that they do.

And both incumbents who were tossed by City Hall, clearly read the writing on the wall during their interviews. In fact, there were rumors that Hubbard thought about not putting in for reappointment. Clearly Beeman knew she was short at least two votes even before she opened her mouth and Hubbard, well his ejection from the commission came later in the voting rounds as the voting itself became more strategic. That was clearly seen by Councilman Rusty Bailey who grappled badly with that process picking different selections with each voting round clearly behind the curve. What's with this? I'm picking this person because they have the best qualifications, no wait, these two people do....no I really mean that these two completely other people do. For being an expert on civics and government as an educator in those subjects, Bailey still hasn't picked up the basics on what politics is really all about and how it's played in River City.

But that's not nearly as good as well I pick this person even though they know nothing about the CPRC but they.....oh wait, round two...got to pick this person because official A and official B picked this other person so I'll pick my choice and not the person competing for votes because I don't want either to beat the one I really want....omigod...this person has this association with me? Cool, he gets my vote. Then there's the, I'll vote for this person...didn't get it...drat...okay who did the mayor vote for in the last round...because he was the last name read in the tallying.

Then there's grrrrrr, I've been waiting for this day FOREVER and even though I pointed out that A is the most critical qualification, I'll pick two commissioners least likely to understand A because those who do, grrrrrr....I wouldn't vote for one of them if caught in the 40 day super storm that the meteorologists are predicting...no I won't. And that was one of the incumbents, the ouster of which forced the ouster of the other even though it took some council members a couple extra rounds of voting to see that.

That was probably the most disappointing but most transparent dynamic in a process that actually had little transparency. But the most disappointing vote was Gardner's because he knows the process, he knows the commission including that putting a third of it on a steep learning curve with a new manager is extremely difficult, he went on and on (and rightfully so) about the commitment requirement and he still clearly voted on other criteria besides who was the best candidate for the job. Since he opted not to explain his votes in a public forum, there's still the campaign trail.

And there's an angle to the CPRC which he introduced intentionally or not which will be discussed in part two of this blog posting on this subject along with some further analysis of the appointment process and what it means for the CPRC.

Most people would agree with the dynamics that played out including the above.

As for the commissioners, Beeman will be fine off the commission because she provided about 90% of the thrust of the rudderless commission in the past two years and she was the most informed applicant, the most committed to the process and she'll continue her involvement in these issues in probably a more effective way. I had my doubts about her especially considering how her reappointment went in front of and allegedly behind the scenes but unlike most people, she took the ball and ran with it, attended more meetings, worked harder and put the most into the process by far than anyone else in the commission. Even when you disagreed with her and often I did, that couldn't be denied.

She earned her reappointment, and she lost it not because she wasn't a good enough commissioner but because she was too good of one and because of politics, pure and simple. It's frightening that someone who could actually work as hard as she did, to serve both community and police (and her son's an officer) well. She had her faults and there were things she did I really disagreed with but she had her strengths and frankly the last thing the commission needed was to lose an experienced commissioner to political game playing. Because it's about three years behind where it should be (and that's mostly due to anticipated and unanticipated high turnover among its members and managers) and it's falling even further behind but since it exists mostly as a political football for elected officials to play with once in a while, that doesn't matter.

And as someone who knows the commission much, much better than all the elected officials put together, every single elected official who didn't vote for her reappointment (and Hubbard's for that matter) should have given a detailed explanation why they did not or they should just be ashamed of themselves and their silence. I never thought I'd say that but she worked her butt off to help the commission become better and more accessible and to improve relationships with the community and the police department outreaching to both community and the Riverside Police Officers' Association and earned a second term.

Since it was clear most of the other applicants were interchangeable (as more than one said, we've got to find other boards and commissions to put them on forgetting that those boards and commissions had applicants who weren't invited to be interviewed). Did they have to vote for any board or commission incumbent? No, but they should all line up and provide reasons in public as to why not right after they cast their votes if they don't actually feel like having a productive and informative discussion on the issue ahead of time.

The commission is too much of a toy by the city government to really benefit from people who actually are truly interested and committed towards carrying out the roles and responsibilities as dictated in the charter. And she was one of the only applicants who wasn't trying to please the interviewing body, taking political risks with some of her candid responses (though not as big as the one Hubbard took when he mentioned the Riverside Coalition of Police Accountability which like any community organization not registered through the city is equivalent to the Mafia kiss). Hubbard had his issues, his conflict of interest which the city council and mayor denied existed before and the fact that he missed meetings and even slept during a couple of them but he became in his own way a political pawn as much as Beeman. In fact, some people walked away believing that elected officials cut some deal to eliminate one to eliminate the other and before any elected official howls about that, think about this fact even though that theory is not a very likely one to explain what did happen.

If you don't discuss or debate your votes on these critical appointments before casting, you really nothing to complain about in terms of how people perceive them. You want to change that, either start having those discussions even if there's conflict and you can't go along to get along on it or just take the process behind closed doors so that at least the discussion takes place if you are too afraid to let the public in on it. Have the guts to talk about your votes before you cast them right in public. And if you've had discussions about the process behind the scenes then share that information too. The people who apply to the city's boards and commission truly believing they're on equal footing deserve at least that much accountability and transparency in the process.


Below are three rounds of voting by the city council and mayor. Each commission appointment required a minimum of five votes. The numbers translate to wards. The fourth and final round of voting was difficult to follow because of all the confusion and disagreement over the vote tally, what the vote tally should be, who just got eliminated and general chaos over the process itself. But that was the round where Adams was appointed.


Ward One:

1: Jackson
2: McManus
3: Jackson
4 Hubbard
5Jackson
6 Jackson
7: Jackson
Mayor: Jackson


Jackson appointed. And only Beeman rivaled her in the interview process as she was clearly a top candidate.

One interesting note about this round is how originally outgoing commissioner, Brian Pearcy was the designated Ward One candidate and I learned this through numerous discussions at City Hall yet only in the first round of voting was it kind of passively made known (but not formerly announced) that all Ward One candidates including the incumbents who were at-large appointments would be eligible for this category. One of many times, the city's been indecisive about its own appointment process. Eh, probably won't be the last.


City wide:

1) Mcmanus adams
2) Beeman, Ibram
3) Hubbard Beeman
4) Hubbard Ballance
5)Johnson Hubbard
6) Johnson, McManus
7) Johnson Hubbard
Mayor: Johnson, Adams


Hubbard just narrowly misses reappointment, Beeman is eliminated essentially and notice how Hubbard starts to fall out in the voting.

1) Adams, McManus
2) Beeman, Johnson
3) McManus, Adams
4) McManus Hubbard
5) Johnson, Hubbard
6) Johnson, Adams
7) Hubbard, Johnson
M) Johnson, Adams

Johnson appointed but look at Bailey all three rounds, in three rounds of voting with five choices allowed, he picked five different candidates, changing his vote completely each round.






Chamber of Commerce Organization Refused to Endorse Lunar Festival Downtown






[The Lunar Festival was a great success but where was the Chamber?]



One of the best cultural and entertainment events in Riverside was endorsed and supported by businesses who were members of the Greater Chamber of Commerce but not by the illustrious Chamber itself. Not the first time the Chamber has shot itself in the foot but it missed out on an event attended by at least 20,o00 people including many who shopped Riverside while they were there lending support through their dollars to local businesses including restaurants.

But then given that downtown according to the Chamber appears to be a playground for only a relatively small segment of the population, this development though disappointing in the 21st Century is hardly surprising. The Chamber at the very least underestimated the buying power of the city's fastest growing racial population, Asian-Americans (in part because of the universities and colleges) and at worse, it engaged in behavior worse than that. After all, the Chinese haven't been banned from immigrating to the United States for years now and have been an important fabric of this country and Japanese nationals and Japanese-Americans haven't been interred in camps (permanently losing their economic properties) while sending 25% of their eligible numbers into the armed forces to fight the Japanese forces, since the 1940s. But discrimination still remains in other forms including the issue of invisibility.

But many of the businesses who had their properties taken by the city through threat of Eminent Domain (which the Chamber publicly endorsed) were owned by Asian-Americans and Latinos including relatively recent immigrants and since some of them were leasing the space rather than owing it, they lost their businesses for good. Clearly not fitting the Chamber's and city government's vision of the newly renaissanced downtown.

But will the Chamber become more enlightened by the time the next Lunar Festival rolls around or starts organizing again? That remains to be seen but by being narrow in mind or at least in vision, they miss out on opportunities to benefit from the economic contributions of Asian-Americans and many other peoples who attended the festival in full force and helped make it a success during its premiere year.

The businesses who were smart and inclusive enough to endorse and support the Lunar Festival should also work within the Chamber to change some of the attitudes inside there because that might go a long way towards changing some narrow visioned minds within that organization that purports to be an advocate for small business owners in Riverside.






Riverside Government Discusses Salaries, Keeps Company Cars




Riverside's mayor and city council discussed their pay situation at the most recent city council meeting late in the afternoon after they moved discussion of this and the deferred compensation proposal involving a group of management employees to the end of the meeting. It's ironic watching that discussion take place involving the sacrifices that city government has to make with their deferred compensation when it appears that it at least had a voice in the process and could ask questions in a relatively open environment because they are the top bosses in the city's hierarchy. They didn't have to sit and be told to embrace something and not be able to really ask any questions about it. But considering that at least one unfortunate city employee was allegedly given a two week unpaid vacation not long after asking a question in a meeting with upper management which was set up purportedly as a question and answer session, it's not surprising that there's not much asked in the way of questions.

And purportedly because of the way their contracts were worded, certain upper management employees who persuaded their subordinates to make sacrifices with their deferred compensation pay were allowed to keep most of theirs. Maybe that proposal that was approved after the city council and mayor discussed and voted on their own salary and benefits packages as part of a charter-mandated biennial review, would have gone down a bit easier if the upper management was making nearly the sacrifices that they were "asking" of their employees.

At any rate, many people are kind of a loss as to how the city officials get retirements and some life long benefits while putting in a minimum of five years on the dais and why management employees like Brad Hudson get much more generous health care packages than the employees that he and his team are telling to make sacrifices for the better fiscal health of the city.

But as this goodwill tour of Hudson (whose reins on this one might be firmly in the hand of Loveridge) is moving from one labor union to the next including the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers and then there's also been concern about certain high level employees pushing for step increases for themselves before there are freezes.

What will be interesting is when Hudson and company take their pitch to the Riverside Police Officers' Association which has three prominent leaders currently at various stages of promotional probation which lasts nine months for sergeants. Primarily because of the history of what's happened with police union leaders in both of its associations in the past several years and probationary status makes employees vulnerable.

Already Vice President and Sgt. Brian Smith has raised questions on the process and he's not the only member of the association to do that but he's the first one publicly. Hopefully President and Sgt. Cliff Mason will join him in publicly asking the questions which frankly need to be asked and discussed in part because the city's climate towards union leaders who ask too many questions hasn't been very kind and in fact, wound up costing money through litigation filed by past union leaders. What will this process due for future recruitment in both the fire and police departments (if it does the same thing) is a question that has been asked, but so far no answers by city management, hardly surprising there.


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)


But Sgt. Brian Smith, vice-president of the Riverside Police Officers Association, said a two-tiered pension system means asking employees to do the same job for different compensation, which could be "very dangerous and problematic in the long run."

He thinks the state's money problems and national economic slump have focused a disproportionate amount of attention on pensions.

"I think (Riverside officials) have jumped on the bandwagon because it's easy to do," Smith said. "The council's going to use this opportunity to force bargaining groups into a different pension system."

He said the 340 or so members of the association have been working on an expired contract for nearly three years and they haven't had raises or benefit increases in four years.




Is Hudson or any of his staff working on expired contracts at the moment? And how much money and benefits was paid off to make former Asst. City Manager Tom DeSantis go away after he resigned after alleged conduct not related to any of the known scandals was reported?



The Riverside Police Administrators' Association shared some similarities but some differences with the rank and file union. The RPAA has already had past leaders who have experienced repercussions due to their labor involvement in raising controversial issues.


(excerpt)



Lt. Ed Blevins, president of the Riverside Police Administrators Association, said he won't know how the union's 23 members feel about pension changes until an upcoming meeting.

"I think for RPAA, the majority of members know that something has to be done. It's just what particulars need to be worked out that is equitable to both sides," he said.



The city council and mayor didn't give themselves raises but to call what they took a "pay cut" was not accurate either because they gave up their deferred compensation which is rather generous considering they don't put in 30 years with the city.

The whole car issue is interesting...but some employees don't get updated contracts for several years and others get cars (though apparently no one has opted to adopt the refurbished Chrysler 300 driven by the former police chief) and explaining the whole system to a person or two who have had their cars repossessed because they can't pay to keep them and have to navigate through Riverside's public transit which takes some getting used to for many people is kind of difficult. Giving elected officials cars for business use, okay maybe there's an argument there but giving city council members cars as their sole means of transit so they can go to Vegas not on business or get their cars towed from Newport Beach or from some off- road field by the city is just too outrageous. And keeping stables of nine or more Chrysler 300s for elected officials and management employees when you have police cars driving around with burned out headlights (though in one case, the light was working about two hours later) and a lot of wear and tear just invites questions about where the city's priorities are and how they got so screwed up.

The most hilarious comment was by Adams who compared elected officials to police officers and they had to have cars readily available to serve the public in the same way. That's just ironic given that several higher ranking city officials allegedly tried to deck their city cars with emergency lights, police radios and police pursuit tires.

I think the best thing to do at this point is to sell the whole fleet of Chrysler and Mercuries and buy or repair some vehicles that are actually more practical for use by the different city departments. And wean some of the highest level employees off of the fancier, gas guzzling expensive cars and have them drive more economical ones or hand them all bus passes. When these folks go around telling everyone else that the city's got to cut its finances because of harsh economic times, it might help if they were driving to those meetings or assigned to drive sensible cars more reflective of that reality. After all, that's what most of the rest of the more ordinary folks are doing.




Election 2011 is also heating up with the fund raising in candidates continuing in earnest and those who so far aren't facing opposition have raised and spent the most money. But what's interesting is how two rumored candidates for mayoral who are running for reelection to their council seats have dealt with THAT question.

Rusty Bailey is one of the strongest rumored candidates in the 2012 who hasn't formerly declared and here were his comments:


(excerpt, Press Enterprise)


The mayor's election is not for a year after (the council election), so if the voters decide to put me back in office in Ward 3, then I'll think about running for mayor after that," Bailey said.




That's kind of strange logic because just because an elected official gets picked to be a council person doesn't mean that the constituents want that person to the following year to say, wow I'm so popular, I think I'll spend most of my time running for higher office. No, when people usually vote a candidate to represent them for a term of four years, they usually have some expectation that the politician will fulfill the terms of office before running for anything else. Now politicians like Bailey might find that an utterly foreign concept but among the more ordinary folks, there's some degree of annoyance when a city council candidates runs for the job making claims about how much they want it, how important it is, how they won't rest until they do A, B and C and then only after getting elected to one office, do they decide, nah what I really want to do is be mayor or assemblyman or something else instead. That's a pretty basic tenet for most people but apparently the only ones who have trouble grasping it are politicians.

So Bailey should stick it out as a councilman because there's more than enough to keep him busy there for the duration of his next term in office, should he win one. But what's interesting is that the two councilmen who flirted with mayoral runs in 2006 were up for reelection in their own wards in 2007 and neither wound up winning.




Councilman Mike Gardner also made similar comments.


(excerpt)


"I haven't pushed real hard to raise money," Gardner said. "I would hope that I can do my campaign for less than $50,000."

He is also mulling a run for mayor next year, but like Bailey, he said he won't decide until after council elections, "and it will be influenced by how my election goes and who else is running."





The first part of his comments is great to be a candidate who isn't pushing for an expensive campaign during a period of economic hardship which is both realistic and makes it appear that he's not out for the special interest donations including those who from developers (who themselves are pretty strapped for contributions). But again, again it's interesting how incumbent council members opt to remain mum on the issue until they are reelected, assuming that they are and then apparently making announcements on whether or not to run for "higher" office. Ward residents tend to support and vote for candidates that they believe will fulfill the obligations the voters have of them when they make their choices including filling their entire political term of one office before seeking another. Many people probably wouldn't support the same council candidate for office if they were only interested in serving a partial term before moving on and up and they should have all the information on the candidates including future political plans so they can make an informed choice. Not necessarily only if the candidates win their seats, it's also that their elected officials would be adding more time campaigning for those "higher" electoral positions.

At the very least the councilmen running this year who are interested in contesting in next year's free for all race for the city's next mayor should declare that intent before running for council seats so that the voters in their respective wards can make fully informed decisions.

And Gardner in particular is going to have his hands full just being reelected in his own ward with two declared candidates and rumors that former Councilman Dom Betro has picked up papers which means he's at least thinking about running again. And every political rival has to be taken seriously no matter how unassuming and broke they appear because the main foe of political candidates is overconfidence.


Dan Bernstein wrote this article about the sacred bovine and caught Adams in a misstatement about not using cars for out of town trips.





City Hall Finally Hosts Reception for the New CPRC Manager




[CPRC Manager Frank Hauptmann was finally welcomed to Riverside by City Hall a month after beginning his job there]





The reception finally took place welcoming Frank Hauptmann into his position as CPRC manager which he's actually been working at for a month. He was hired to be part-time by the city manager and due to his PERS retirement, he can only be compensated for a certain portion of hours but he said at the reception which was attended by elected officials, police department employees and members of the public that he will stay at work until he finishes the work that needs to be done. Hauptmann has taken a very active role in the management so far even doing checks and balances on some of the ongoing errant behavior by certain commissioners in certain situations having to explain the appropriate procedures for the process that they have been entrusted with doing in a proper manner.

He spent time talking to individuals at the reception working his way around the room which is very good to see in a new management employee of any type but certainly one who's managing a community oversight mechanism.

Given that the commission has underperformed in nearly every area in the past couple of years, Hauptmann has his work cut out for him, that and avoiding micromanagement from his bosses and their bosses. He's in charge of managing a mechanism of oversight that's important for community managers but unfortunately a political football for City Hall, so yeah it's going to be a difficult ride. But Maywood was probably an even higher learning curve than River City in terms of the political dynamics.





Jurupa's political candidates dicuss their goals at a public forum.


Is anyone surprised by this development?








Press Release and PSA from the RPD





This came through the email list via Lt. Leon Phillips:


Riverside, CA -- On Thursday 2/3/11, just after 2:00 PM, Riverside Police Officers were dispatched to a call of an intoxicated juvenile in the area of California and Van Buren. A passerby reported seeing what appeared to be a 16-year-old juvenile passed out at the side of the road. The first officer on scene walked into the unimproved Challen Park and saw a group of approximately 15 juveniles. Several of them immediately ran away into the surrounding neighborhoods. Others were so intoxicated they were unable to flee. When more officers arrived they discovered a total of five (5) persons who were in need of emergency medical care because of excessive alcohol consumption and intoxication. At least two were completely unresponsive. Officers called for multiple AMR Ambulance and Riverside Fire Department units to render aid to the individuals. Four (4) intoxicated juveniles ranged in age from 14-17. One 18-year-old also received care. The individuals who were conscious were extremely belligerent with the officers, AMR and RFD personnel. The five (5) intoxicated persons were taken by ambulance to local hospitals for emergency medical treatment. The parents of the juveniles were notified of their condition and location by Riverside Fire Personnel.

The Riverside Police Department takes incidents such as this very seriously and encourages all parents to closely monitor the activities of their children to ensure their safety and well-being. Underage drinking can be very dangerous and may cause long lasting health concerns in addition to the immediate dangers associated with alcohol intoxication.




This is very solid information on the problems of intoxication from alcohol and the impact it can have on the individual and others around him in many different ways. But it doesn't just apply to teenagers but to adults as well including those who get behind the wheel. No matter who they are.






Public Meetings



Monday, Feb. 4 at 3:30 p.m and 5:30 p.m. the Riverside Unified School Board will conduct a study session and further discussion and vote on the John W. North High School Stadium issue. More information here. Some board members are saying that North High School should have the same stadium facilities as those afforded several other high schools but ironically former North High School Principal Chuck Beaty who's on the board has said that "they have enough already".


Tuesday, Feb. 5 at 3 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. The Riverside City Council will meet and discuss this agenda. The public is invited to attend, it's mostly theater but it's still free.





Campaign Event


Campaign Kick-Off for Dvonne Pitruzzello for Riverside City Council Ward 1 is Thursday, February 10 at 5:30pm at the Flowerloft in Downtown Riverside.



Joe Pitruzzello will unveil and showcase his art work of the Mission Inn and other collection pieces. Wine and Hors d’ oeuvres will be served to live music by Ellen Schwartz. Donation is $25.00. RSVP: 533-1122.






Political Announcement




(the best looking mayoral, official or rumored, yet)


Thanks Ron Woodbury for actually asking and remembering who votes



Greetings: My name is Ron Woodbury and I am running for Mayor of Riverside in 2012. In order to complete my platform I need your input. I do not believe a candidate can possibly publish their platform/agenda without obtaining a substantial amount of feedback from the community. This is Your Community, and I need Your Voice. I very-much appreciate your help. My survey is located at www.ron4mayor.com. If you wish to contact me directly, my contact information is on the Website as well. Thank you in advance for your help. Ron




Additional Training Needed?



After reading Dan Bernstein's column on real bovines as opposed to sacred ones, I found it very interesting.

It's clear that there's some additional training need for police officers and sheriff's deputies in bovine county (and Riverside County has ranked high as a county with many cows) and that involves how to preg check cows. It's not too hard, all you need is a pair of plastic gloves up to your elbows and a cow. Those with larger sized biceps might find the squeezing sensation to impinge the circulation but the tingling sensation that results is only temporary and no...your arm will not get stuck in there forever. The above link includes a tutorial on how to successfully determine whether your subject cow is pregnant.

It's a bit messy because of the part of the cow's anatomy that you're sticking your arm into for the preg check but as long as the cow doesn't bear down or better yet take off running with your arm stuck...there...then you're in pretty good shape.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

The Mayor's State of the Union in River City...Sponsored by the Chamber


[The Fireworks display in downtown Riverside during the first annual Lunar Festival which though very successful received no sponsorship from the Chamber of Commerce organization...though some of its businesses did break from the pack]





[Once again, Councilman Steve Adams was a no show during public comment but remained in his seat long enough to champion Redevelopment agencies]







[Mayor Ron Loveridge took time from his busy duties as president of the League of Cities to give his state of the city address but this year, no standing ovation]


The Riverside City Council passed a resolution to oppose the proposal of Governor Jerry Brown to disband city and county redevelopment agencies and a bunch of speakers including those who have received funding for projects associated with Riverside's Redevelopment Agency lined up to praise it. Even former Assemblyman Ted Weggeland showed up to perform "sweep" duties for the entourage of speakers. The presentation was put on by City Manager Brad Hudson, the guru of Redevelopment hired away from Riverside County's Economic Development Agency and it impressed many people but some of the facts regarding some of the "successes" including the University Village (which is allegedly in receivership) were somewhat overstated.

Redevelopment in itself isn't a bad thing and can be very necessary but what's needed is more outside oversight especially since the city council also functions as the Redevelopment Agency board and Hudson had such harsh words for Sacramento's announcement that it will audit 18 redevelopment agencies labeling it essentially a smear campaign against the agencies. Well if you're satisfied that your process is what it should be involving your own redevelopment agency then why not volunteer to have it audited? But that's not going to be happening in Riverside any time soon at least not voluntarily.


That kind of talk towards any form of outside oversight on an insulated process where the numbers put out by the city, as Karen Renfro and others have pointed out, don't seem to match those the city provides to the state is actually quite disturbing. What's just as disturbing is how the majority of the city council drank from the same Koolaid that Hudson served in terms of the evil state taking away "our" money and how the state has a "little budget" problem. Sacramento has serious budget issues including money coming in and its spending habits, so does the United States Government, so does Riverside County and yes, even Riverside City where Mayor Ron Loveridge claimed in his State of the City Address is this oft-repeated $40 million reserve fund that appears to be parceled out and essentially not easily discoverable in the city's budget. And that's a worrisome situation for more reasons that the public's inability to understand how the city does its accounting and the city's inability or unwillingness to explain it. But no, asking serious questions about what's going on with a redevelopment agency (including the merging of "zones" which have nothing to do with other simply so money can be siphoned out of one area in the zone to another) doesn't make a person against redevelopment even as several elected officials appear to paint it that way.

And remember what firm was auditing Riverside's finances for the last five years again? Hoffman, Mayer and McCann, the one under investigation by the State Comptroller's office. The one that some factions of City Hall said during a Finance Committee that they'd be open to hiring other "interests" within that firm to audit the city's books until a council member or two including Paul Davis, said whoa, isn't going to happen. That's a good step but what the city needs to do is to have at least the last couple of audits done by that troubled firm reviewed.

But some elected officials clearly believed that pushing for greater accountability and transparency over these agencies means that you oppose redevelopment, affordable housing (at very unaffordable rents), community centers, daycare centers and other things including probably Santa Claus. The only real convenient straw man argument that city officials can use to try to ward off any concerns that the Redevelopment Agency in Riverside should be audited.


Councilwoman Nancy Hart told some individuals loudly that only three speakers opposed Redevelopment and she didn't want to hear any more of it. But then again, Hart told the daily newspaper that she had an issue with releasing public information to individuals trying to catch City Hall at doing something wrong. So that's not all that surprising.


Hudson's shiny power point presentation on redevelopment's impact in Riverside was very impressive but some of the projects that were presented as success stories were not in fact successful at all or are struggling to survive including the University Village which apparently is in some form of receivership. The Raincross Promenade, a condo project done by a developer who was a popular donor to several political campaigns has sold three out of 144 of its units and the rest are rentals, adding to the percentage downtown which is interesting given that the city's goal for the ambitious project was to reduce the percentage of rentals in the downtown area.

But some individuals including Councilman Steve Adams said that Redevelopment is the biggest provider of jobs, an assertion that is contradicted by the filings provided by cities and counties to Sacramento. It makes sense that there's not that many jobs if you've followed what's been going on with some of these projects. The city seems to hire construction and contracting companies from outside the county and even the state, i.e. Arizona and many businesses that come into these areas bring their own labor forces with them and don't do much hiring or only offer a few positions. Many of those offered out in the endangered University Village were part-time jobs for students including at the two movie theaters that were housed there. Starbucks and other chains transferred employees in from other places. And people lost jobs, and some people lost businesses including on Market Street in downtown Riverside because they didn't own the buildings that were seized by the redevelopment agency under threat of eminent domain, they leased it which means that the city paid them zero compensation or relocation fees which only went to the property owners. So some individuals' life-long dreams of owning businesses were crushed by redevelopment including its rather way too broad and often very opportunistic definition of "blight".

Hudson also claimed that the redevelopment agency was responsibly for the demolition of motels on University Avenue but actually what happened in several cases including the well knowned University Lodge was that the city paid huge amounts of money to negligent property owners or in the case of the Lodge, a well-known slumlord from Menlo Park, Orange County (in that case an excess of $400,000) to leave town. The slumlord received much more in compensation for mishandling his property than those who lived in those squalid conditions to relocate. Why would any absentee property owner have any incentive to be responsible if they were simply negiligent or slum lords and were paid off rather than held accountable? Many people had questions about how that was handled, which weren't answered. Because if you did, then you were against getting rid of a problem property but wait a minute, what can be more pro-slumlord than allowing one to essentially win the lottery before going off to be a slumlord some place else? Most people in similar circumstances would have been told to pay fines to the city for code violations not paid huge sums of money to leave town.

Adams also said that the state took no budget cuts of its own and that educational institutions like the two university systems and the community college system didn't experience cuts but just increased fees. The same night that a summit was taking place at UC Riverside to discuss what else? Budget cuts. Adams is just so incredible to listen to some times, one wishes he'd return to sitting in his seat during public comment so that the city residents could further benefit from his colorful insights.



State Comptroller John Chiang has announced plans to review 18 redevelopment agencies including that in Riverside County. And what about Riverside, city? Well given that the agencies in both the city and county share a common thread if anything problematic is found in the county review, then perhaps that might lead to a city review. Stranger things have happened after all.

Riverside's city government was asked at the city council meeting to volunteer its own redevelopment agency for the Chiang's office to review among the 18 chosen but so far hasn't done that. Though with Riverside County being one of them, again who knows but that could lead to a review of Riverside the city if something doesn't smell right in the county because of a common thread.


Redevelopment Agencies annual reports to Sacramento, for people who are interested in researching them.


The Press Enterprise did this interesting article which includes a history of when city residents lost the ability to pull items from the consent calendar. Marjorie Von Pohle protested this action every week at city council meetings while she attended but although a couple of current city council members promised to revisit the issue during their campaigns, that never happened. Cities like Corona still allow people to pull consent calendar items for discussion but not Riverside.

Mayor Ron Loveridge did his annual state of the city address deal at the Riverside Convention Center and again, it's sponsored by the Greater Chamber of Commerce which makes a bundle from sponsorship and from the paying audience off of an event which should be non-profit given that it's an annual speech made by an elected official voted into office by many other city residents besides members of the Chamber. Some folks who attended and didn't pay the big bucks for tables and for catered food felt as if they were definitely second tier or were treated rudely with one individual being told that she would be "allowed" to go into the city vendor display room.

Gee thanks.

The mayor shouldn't be giving an annual address in front of a paying audience nor should it be a venue for an organization even a business one to rake in the bucks. It should be in a venue where it's open to everyone on equal footing. Especially since the city residents' sales tax money is paying for quite a few of the tables in that room. It's an opportunity for people to hob nob and feel great rather than an opportunity for the public to witness a mayoral address.

As one newcomer to this city in the cheap seats aptly put it, it's really an example of the difference between the "haves" and the "have nots", not the best welcoming lesson for people moving into this city.


Loveridge had a busy week because he also made comments that ticked off the Alvord Unified School District.






Concern Grows over Riverside's Two Tier Pension Plans


The Press Enterprise published this article about the reaction by some of the city's bargaining units to the announcement that the Riverside Fire Fighters' Association and Loveridge applauded the actions of this union in his State of the City's address as being visionary and a necessary part of pension reform. But in actuality, the RFA didn't vote to lessen its members pension plans but those who haven't been hired by the department yet, hence the full meaning of "two-tiered" plans. It's easier to vote away a portion of a future employee's pension than your own and at least the incoming fire fighter applicants will be aware of this happening before they are hired but that brings up the issues of how this "pension reform" will impact the recruitment pools, not just for fire fighters but for employees in other city bargaining units. Will the city still attract the top quality applicants to the fire department if they have a lesser retirement than that offered by other cities? Will they want to work in an agency alongside employees while taking the same risks of the job and get a lesser pension when they retire? Will it foster division within the ranks of a city department?

What if police officers took a similar plan? Would the Riverside Police Department still attract top candidates who might base their decisions on which agency they work for and pick one offering 3% at 50 over one that offers 3% at 55, for example. And pensions do factor majorly into where people decide to work in the public sector and in fact, one of the main attractions of the public sector have been the pension plans. But most city employees in Riverside aren't wading in excess and wealth when they collect retirement, in fact quite a few are barely surviving and keeping their homes because of the dramatic drop in income and the economy in this region in general.

These are questions that have been asked by city workers whose unions are facing similar issues and some say pressure to fall in line behind the RFA. This is a complicated issue but the two-tier plan doesn't really address it, in terms of whether employee retirement funds are invested in the best way possible with the least risk and most return, an issue that's been discussed quite a bit, especially when the stock markets take serious hits. And oversight of the retirement process in ways that protect employees as well as taxpayers.

But the one issue that really seems to be not explored here in these discussions is that there's a lot about sacrifices made to "reform" pensions and save money but not one peep about the pensions enjoyed by upper management at City Hall as well as the very generous life-long benefits given to elected officials who serve a certain length of time in office. In fact, the management level at City Hall has been very good at advocating for its own step increases even as other employee bargaining units have worked without contracts or increase in salaries or benefits for several years now. Some management members might be talking about deferring compensation but will they be engaged in this reform as well?

Unfortunately, there can't be any serious dialogue from elected officials who are so eager to hang on to what they get (and they don't have to work 20-30 years either!) and ask or even pressure other employees to "reform" their pensions so it's hard to take them seriously when it comes to talking about being the leader in pension reform.

Like Loveridge, before you run off and champion that cause as like your legacy or something, what are you doing about the life-time packages for elected officials including yourself? Is that something to look forward to in the next State of the City Address? Will Loveridge be able to announce that he engaged in pension reform in his own backyard?





Community Police Review Commission Votes to Hold Workshop



[The Community Police Review Commission shown at an earlier meeting discussed a workshop to be held Feb. 22]





CPRC Manager Frank Hauptmann


On Jan. 26, the Community Police Review Commission held its first meeting with its newest manager, Frank Hauptmann. Outgoing Chair Brian Pearcy proposed a workshop to explain to elected officials, new police management employees and Hauptmann the institutional history of the CPRC. Former Councilwoman Maureen Kane who chaired an exploratory committee investigating civilian oversight back in 2000 has been invited and Pearcy was working on finding another guest speaker. Suggestions to have representatives from the community and the police associations were not surprisingly denied by Pearcy and objected to by other commissioners.

After all, the commission in the past few years hasn't been exactly community friendly and Pearcy perhaps didn't get the reaction to his workshop idea that he had hoped for. Commissioner Ken Rotker said he had a difficult time accepting it without an outline and then went into this long monologue on the differences between an agenda and an outline. Art Santore not surprisingly thought it should be closed to public participation at all including public comments. The final product that was approved by the commissioners in attendance will take place on Tuesday, Feb. 22 at noon. With a time like that, I don't think individuals like Santore don't have to worry too much about city residents showing up and ruining their fun.






Lawsuit Involving Former Riverside Police Department Officer to Go to Trial?




Apparently the proposed settlement between Riverside and former Riverside Police Department Officer Jose Luis Nazario, Jr. fell through and the case is going to trial. Possibly as early as April. Nazario was fired by the department as a probationary officer after the NCIS began investigating him for alleged war crimes in Fallujah, Iraq in 2005. He was indicted by a federal grand jury and was acquitted of manslaughter charges at trial in the U.S. District Court in dowtown Riverside, the first discharged military serviceman to be tried for war crime allegations in a civil court system.


Information on the criminal proceedings in the Nazario case are here.


After his acquittal, Nazario who has his own Wikipedia page then reapplied online to get rehired by the police department but was not rehired by the city.

And really what appears to be the legal issues here regarding his employment with the police department are twofold. First there's the issue behind his original firing but there's a separate issue behind the city's rejection of his reapplication. Nazario and his attorney in the lawsuit apparently are focusing on the second issue rather than the first. But the difference between the two involves the process of undergoing potential screening by the police department which would include a background exam for the period of time between his firing and his reapplication for his job back as essentially a new hire.


In a Wall St. Journal article, it was revealed that Nazario on a phone call to one of his friends from the Marines that was taped by NCIS had made controversial comments about his stint as a police officer. The police department was put in the defensive position of having to respond to them.


(excerpt)



During his time in Riverside, Navy investigators arranged a surreptitiously taped phone call between Mr. Nelson and Mr. Nazario, during which Mr. Nazario described his work. Saying his job was much like the television show "Cops," he told Mr. Nelson that he regularly would "beat the s- out of" a criminal, finding "a reason to take him to jail" later, according to a transcript of the conversation.

In court filings, prosecutors say the conversation shows the two men discussing the killings in Fallujah. "Who gave us the orders though?" asks Mr. Nelson. Mr. Nazario replies: "I did." But Mr. Nazario then says the order to kill the men came via radio from someone higher up.

On Aug. 7, 2007, Mr. Nazario was finishing night patrol in Riverside, when ordered to return to headquarters. NCIS personnel were there and told him he was under arrest.

Asked in an interview about the statements that led to his arrest, Mr. Nazario says he didn't understand that Mr. Nelson was referring to a particular incident in Fallujah and that he wasn't acknowledging any crime. He defends his record at the Riverside Police Department, and says he may have been drinking during the call; he describes the conversation as "two guys" who were "talking tough" about "untrue stories."

A police spokesman said state law prevents him from commenting on Mr. Nazario's personnel record, but that he was aware of no criminal charges against Mr. Nazario during his time on the force.



So these statements made by Nazario caused issues for the police department and the city because after all, that's not exactly what the department would want said about it and have it wind up in one of the nation's top selling newspapers.

But apparently, this didn't cause the department not to hire him back either. During the rehiring process, the department allegedly found a disqualifying factor and took it. Whether or not that part of the episode will play out in U.S. District Court at trial remains to be seen.




Jurupa Valley is preparing to receive ballot information and sample ballots as it prepares to vote for cityhood.


Should the residents of San Bernardino County pay for former Assessor Bill Postmus' legal expenses? Um no.




Public Meeting




Tuesday, Feb. 1 at 3 pm and 6:30 p.m. The Riverside City Council is holding its weekly meeting and discussing this agenda. First up, is the biennial exercise in deciding whether or not to increase the salaries and benefits packages of elected officials. This report is must reading if only to find out how much the mayor currently makes.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

When the Clock Strikes Past Midnight

If you use Blackberry to get your emails, you're out of luck today. Massive Blackberry server outage all over United States...How long to fix it? Not known at this time.








[Employees of the Riverside Police Department and Fire Department receive accolades and induction into the Riverside Unified School District Honor Roll for saving the life of Arlington High School Head Football Coach Patrick McCarthy (l.)]








[Riverside Police Department Officer Richard Glover who also is an assistant football coach at Arlington High School receiving his award]








[Deputy Chief of Personnel Mike Blakely and Chief Sergio Diaz witness the award ceremony while the fate of Glover's career remains in their hands 14 months after the alleged incident took place]





California State Governmental Code 3304 (d)


(excerpt)



d) (1) Except as provided in this subdivision and subdivision
(g), no punitive action, nor denial of promotion on grounds other
than merit, shall be undertaken for any act, omission, or other
allegation of misconduct if the investigation of the allegation is
not completed within one year of the public agency's discovery by a
person authorized to initiate an investigation of the allegation of
an act, omission, or other misconduct. This one-year limitation
period shall apply only if the act, omission, or other misconduct
occurred on or after January 1, 1998. In the event that the public
agency determines that discipline may be taken, it shall complete its
investigation and notify the public safety officer of its proposed
discipline by a Letter of Intent or Notice of Adverse Action
articulating the discipline that year, except as provided in
paragraph (2). The public agency shall not be required to impose the
discipline within that one-year period.
(2) (A) If the act, omission, or other allegation of misconduct is
also the subject of a criminal investigation or criminal
prosecution, the time during which the criminal investigation or
criminal prosecution is pending shall toll the one-year time period.
(B) If the public safety officer waives the one-year time period
in writing, the time period shall be tolled for the period of time
specified in the written waiver.
(C) If the investigation is a multijurisdictional investigation
that requires a reasonable extension for coordination of the involved
agencies.
(D) If the investigation involves more than one employee and
requires a reasonable extension.
(E) If the investigation involves an employee who is incapacitated
or otherwise unavailable.
(F) If the investigation involves a matter in civil litigation
where the public safety officer is named as a party defendant, the
one-year time period shall be tolled while that civil action is
pending.
(G) If the investigation involves a matter in criminal litigation
where the complainant is a criminal defendant, the one-year time
period shall be tolled during the period of that defendant's criminal
investigation and prosecution.
(H) If the investigation involves an allegation of workers'
compensation fraud on the part of the public safety officer.
(e) Where a predisciplinary response or grievance procedure is
required or utilized, the time for this response or procedure shall
not be governed or limited by this chapter.
(f) If, after investigation and any predisciplinary response or
procedure, the public agency decides to impose discipline, the public
agency shall notify the public safety officer in writing of its
decision to impose discipline, including the date that the discipline
will be imposed, within 30 days of its decision, except if the
public safety officer is unavailable for discipline.
(g) Notwithstanding the one-year time period specified in
subdivision (d), an investigation may be reopened against a public
safety officer if both of the following circumstances exist:
(1) Significant new evidence has been discovered that is likely to
affect the outcome of the investigation.
(2) One of the following conditions exist:
(A) The evidence could not reasonably have been discovered in the
normal course of investigation without resorting to extraordinary
measures by the agency.
(B) The evidence resulted from the public safety officer's
predisciplinary response or procedure.
(h) For those members listed in subdivision (a) of Section 830.2
of the Penal Code, the 30-day time period provided for in subdivision
(f) shall not commence with the service of a preliminary notice of
adverse action, should the public agency elect to provide the public
safety officer with such a notice.





On Tuesday, Jan. 18 at around 6pm, a group of individuals including Riverside city employees appeared at a Board of Education meeting of the Riverside Unified School District to get awards and induction into the RSUD's Honor Roll for saving the life of Arlington High School Head Football Coach Patrick McCarthy after a severe infection caused him to go into cardiac arrest right in the football field during a practice. Assistant coaches Zaza Ralph and Richard Glover, a Riverside Police Department officer sprang into action taking emergency measures to resuscitate him until emergency personnel from the Riverside Fire Department arrived to apply further emergency measures before transporting McCarthy to a hospital where he struggled to survive for several days but a little more than two months later, he was standing at the podium at the Board of Education meeting which was filled with people witnessing the ceremony. Speakers including McCarthy cited the bravery of those who were involved including Glover and said if they hadn't acted that McCarthy wouldn't be alive today. Both Chief Sergio Diaz and Deputy Chief Mike Blakely attended and stood up proudly when introduced in front of the school board as they should after those awarded including Glover were given standing ovations. Both men play pivotal roles in a situation involving the young officer as it turned out in a situation that's started over a year ago.



But what might not have been known by most of the people attending the event was that Glover hadn't been able to wear his police uniform in months and that he had actually been placed on paid leave pending the outcome of an internal affairs investigation that has been in the works since about November 2009. They might not know that right now, there's allegedly a recommendation to terminate his employment and that of another patrol officer sitting on the desk of a high ranking management employee. And that the investigation against him and other officers has possibly exceeded its statutory limitations according to state law and the police officer bill of rights yet the management level of the department has either made or received recommendations to discipline them anyway for allegations it has apparently sustained.

It's an investigation and review process that's sparked many questions as it probably should. As it should have months ago so what happened? Because what's resulted is a quandary that taps into many issues involving the problems that have plagued the department's personnel and investigation process for the past few years. Problems that needed solutions before this investigation even got started and long before it got caught in a quagmire where it still remains.


The investigation allegedly originated from an arrest that had been made that had been the subject of a complaint and the investigation was conducted involving Glover, Officer Michael Bucy and later the supervising sergeant who were involved with its handling. An investigation where the direction that it has taken appears to be as prolonged as any investigation possibly could be, and one that has sparked some degree of controversy in whether or not the department has followed state law regarding instituting disciplinary actions of its officers. Not to mention that it seems to be an investigation that no one including in upper management appears to want to deal with as it meanders on past beginning its second year even as a recommendation for rather serious discipline of the two patrol officers has been presented. It appears to be the proverbial hot potato for quite a few people and that's exactly what it shouldn't be at all. Too many lives are involved in a situation that has become uncomfortable to being addressed, it's the first major disciplinary action by the new regime and so far it had seemed like there's been fumbling of the ball up to that point.

Not that by itself, investigations stretching out close to the one year mark aren't anomalies particularly in the area of citizen complaints, as statistics released have shown.

These statistics have shown that the department had already been struggling with the length of time it took to conduct its investigations particularly those involving complaints filed by the public for quite some time long before this particular investigation even began.

For the past five years or so, the average length of time it's taken to investigate both category I (more serious allegations) and 2 (those less serious) has ebbed and flowed but for the most part, has taken at least for citizen complaints often much longer than six months. Much longer than the recommended 60 or 30 days respectively (RPD Policy 4.12 D 5,6) to even reach the Community Police Review Commission if they're complaints under its jurisdiction. And for the most part, it's the category 2 complaints which have run up the highest number of day before completion according to those same statistics. That might be due to several reasons including prioritizing major investigations over minor ones and the fact that the vast majority of category 2 complaints are handled by field sergeants, a rank that's become pretty depleted in the past several years due to their positions being frozen when vacated.

Investigations involving personnel complaints filed against police officers have averaged up to 200-300 days at times to even reach the CPRC according to statistics released by that board on a monthly and annual basis. Yet the department assures both complainants and likely police officers not to mention members of the CPRC that there has never been an investigation that it's done which has extended past the expiration of the governmental code cited above, 3304(d) which states that an officer can't be disciplined more than 12 months after the initial suspicion of misconduct by that officer. The code cites a list of exemptions to that rule, which include the conduction of a criminal investigation/prosecution (which takes priority), investigations conducted by other law enforcement agencies (i.e. the FBI) or the incapacitation of officers involved in the investigation as subjects or witnesses.

Criminal charges were never filed in relation to this case and no civil litigation was initiated either yet the length of investigation and the holding pattern that emerged afterward for more months seemed endless. And in most cases involving the police department, officers are still disciplined (most often by termination) within 12 months of the suspicion of misconduct even in cases where they are being prosecuted on criminal charges. Former officers Robert Forman and Anthony Fletcher and Det. Scott Impola were all fired within six months of criminal charges being filed and well within the 12 months of when the clock was started under 3304(d). There's probably other similar examples where the clock didn't run out on investigations that became criminal cases. When the department strongly believes there's serious misconduct that has been sustained or will be, it acts decisively, it doesn't meander and malinger on an investigation past a year and then engage in a game of musical chairs handing it off to the one left standing to make the decision on what discipline to give out.

So then what happened here in this particular investigation which has presented a situation where officers might get disciplined possibly terminated after the 12 month mark? Even if the department can foster a reason, an exception to waive the requirements of the governmental code, will it past the muster if this disciplinary action is later appealed through arbitration?
Not very likely, given past decisions which heavily favor police officers who have faced serious discipline including termination and likely it would hinge on 3304(d) which means it mostly likely would be tossed out.

But this case hasn't even gotten that far.

So far it's been going on 15 months without any resolution to it and it has generated some degree of controversy as to why it took this long, putting the careers and lives of those involved on hold for over a year and the ultimate outcome for even longer than that. The concerns had included how the investigation into the complaint was handled in the first place including how it proceeded through the chain of command especially during the disciplinary process. It's a process that's not had any winners and has raised questions about how the investigation and disciplinary process is handled by the Riverside Police Department. An agency which already has some interesting history with how it disciplines in different ways for the same offenses. In the same department for example, one detective got a notice with an intent to terminate for alleging lying about making a racial comment several years before he had been investigated for making one last year. An investigation which was one that apparently took priority over this " very serious" one. Even though those involved in both cases sat in the same penalty box.

Another detective had made used a racial slur in roll call during training and had originally been facing a severe suspension. But he wound up with a written reprimand because the lieutenant of the Internal Affairs Division which had been investigating that detective for making the "wet back" comment had himself used that same slur in another training exercise involving the City Attorney's office in front of someone assigned to that office. The lieutenant hadn't really gotten any discipline against him for his slur so they had to go back and reduce the discipline recommended for the detective that his division had investigated for using the same slur, to a written reprimand. It's really hard to look at this ridiculous exercise in showing that accountability for misconduct is something that clearly doesn't trickle up the chain of command and take a law enforcement agency and how it handles that issue very seriously. One person loses their job, one gets a change of disciplinary action and the other gets to retire and then get rehired by the city to work where, but in the City Attorney's office. So at least in that case, the assignment of discipline to an officer seems somewhat capricious? No, the lesson that this situation sends to everyone is that the higher you are up in the chain of command, the less the discipline is that you receive. Because there's quite a large gap between a termination, a suspension, even a written reprimand and a retirement and another job with the city. If that's how discipline was carried out in practice or even as the rule, then it wouldn't seem to be a trustworthy process at all.

Then there was the officer who wasn't issued a notice of intent to discipline for sustained misconduct until 13 months after an incident and since they couldn't give him the disciplinary action that they had intended legally under 3304(d), they decided to "discipline" him through a "non-disciplinary" transfer out of a special assignment. What made that an eyeball rolling event was that the notice of the non-disciplinary transfer was actually written on a memo that had on the top of it, "notice of intent to discipline". What was humorously ironic in a Wonderland kind of way ultimately became very expensive when that episode played out in front of a civil jury about five years ago.

Another long-time detective had committed a serious act of misconduct within his assigned unit and the captain at the time in investigations had recommended that he receive a written reprimand violating departmental procedure that required one of the three following disciplinary actions: suspension, demotion or termination. The assistant chief in that situation then recommended a suspension while the police chief ultimately terminated the detective who then won his job back in arbitration, the city appealed it, lost and then ultimately paid him a medical retirement.

A patrol officer committed sexual misconduct on duty and wasn't terminated but then several years later was arrested and prosecuted for oral copulation under the color of authority and sexual battery and today, is a convicted felon and registered sex offender. Plus he was ultimately fired from the department.

But then the department took back the one police officer whose firing had been supported by arbitration and by Riverside County Superior Court for some inexplicable reason. The officer didn't stay in the department very long before regressing back to the behavior that got him terminated but this time the department didn't fire him, it paid him out, most likely on a "medical" retirement.

It's more than likely that most of the cases don't appear to be like these ones and that they have outcomes that make more sense including when it comes to issuing disciplinary action. At least one would hope so especially in the case of employee terminations. But it's problematic when the process goes astray even once because of the serious implications involved and how they impact people's lives.

Because it's one of the most serious actions that a police department can take and one that's required to adhere to state law including requirements involving statutory periods. An accountable and responsible law enforcement agency would see that it did just that as well as honoring the laws which require departments to have an accountable citizen complaint process, laws which were alleged to be violated by former State Attorney General Bill Lockyer in his lawsuits against Riverside in 2001, which of course was settled in the form of a five-year stipulated judgment. But was proper process followed here with this 15 month process of investigating misconduct allegations, sustaining them and then making recommendations and ultimate decisions involving any disciplinary action. And if the process wasn't followed correctly with Bucy and Glover's investigation, then why not?

There's been some talk about how major this case was in terms of what happened but if that's the case why did it sit for months essentially allowing the clock to run out? Shouldn't the most important investigations be the ones that get completed on time? Yes, investigations shouldn't be rushed to the finish line and risk being compromised in the process but there's plenty of room for taking great care in conducting them and in getting them completed before the 12 month mark. If this investigation really was so important, the situation so grave, it certainly wasn't treated that way. It was treated like it somehow became politicized along the way inside the insulated walls of the RPD. It also raises the issues of how investigations are prioritized within the department. Are the most serious ones treated as the highest priorities or those that become the most politicized? Past practice had often appeared to be that investigators would be placed on one case, work on that one and then be pulled off to deal with a newer one that was suddenly even a higher priority. Is that still the way business is being conducted, hopefully not because it's pretty easy to identify the inherent problems with that type of organizational system.

But this case itself is odd in more than one way including through the recommendations on disciplinary action which have been made so far. Because the discipline recommended in this investigation also diluted itself the higher up it went.


It's kind of difficult to look at this important and often very arduous process of deciding whether to assign discipline to an officer and if so what with an unjaded eye. If it seems that accountability for sustained misconduct goes down, the higher the rank then that hardly seems appropriate either and it sends a very disturbing message. Why should a detective get suspended or even written up for a racial slur whereas a lieutenant gets nothing, retires and earns another job with the city? Officers should get disciplined for that form of sustained misconduct but the severity shouldn't lessen the higher up in the chain of command that it goes. With increased privilege and power which is enjoyed at the higher levels such as supervision and management, comes responsibility and accountability as well.

What kind of message does that send to the department but also to the community, whether the community knows it or not? Because this type of behavior is often symptomatic of deeper problems that the community will become aware of perhaps in a big way down the road even if it's not aware initially. Riverside's definitely seen that scenario play out in technicolor several times.

Glover and Bucy were featured in earlier postings in the Mad, Mad World at Orange Street Station during the time period last spring when both of them and at least four sworn employees spent their days sitting in the Orange Street Station in a situation called the "penalty box" after being removed from their field operations or investigative assignments. That's the place where Lt. Leon Phillips was put as Former Acting Chief John DeLaRosa told officers at roll call to be trained for a "special assignment" rather than being disciplined. But a week later, he was given his notice of intent to terminate. Some special assignment. The "Penalty Box" as it's called might have some purpose but it's become more politicized than anything else, the fact that it has a name bears to that.

The only other thing that Bucy and Glover had in common was that both had testified in the late 2005 criminal trial of that former officer who was convicted of one count of oral copulation under the color of authority, Robert Forman. Bucy had testified as a former trainee of Forman but his testimony had actually hurt Forman because he had testified that his field training officer had been strict and meticulous about details whereas Forman's entire defense had been built on the premise that he had become a lazy, complacent officer.

Glover had testified that he had been at the scene when Forman and one of the alleged victims had been involved in a petty theft misdemeanor that Forman also had been convicted of at trial. But it seemed clear that the officers at the scene of that situation involving an angry prospective john who alleged he had his $100 stolen by Forman and the victim had no idea that anything illegal involving Forman had taken place.

But what happened last spring was that two officers were taken out of the patrol division and placed in the "penalty box" while the investigation of a complaint appeared to be in limbo months after much of it had allegedly been completed. If the investigation was so serious as had been claimed, why did it take so long, and why were the officers assigned to the Orange Street station for months before being placed on paid leave about two months ago? After all, an investigation involving a former detective who made a racial remark was apparently deemed more important and the highest priority by Orange Street Station about the same time that allegations raised by the detective involving an altercation with a management member hit the press. But yet, the situation was so serious the officers had to be removed from their field assignments and put on some form of desk duty yet for a long while it seemed as if the department's management (which itself was undergoing major changes) was content to run the clock out. Which makes no sense whatsoever.

The investigation finally made it to the desk of newly anointed field operations captain, John Wallace who was given the task, of making the recommendation for the disciplinary action imposed on the officers and sergeant nearly 12 months after it had first been noted. The newly appointed members of the management team apparently didn't want to get involved in making that recommendation themselves, leaving it up to Wallace who was left to come up with his own decision or to seek advice from other parties including his executive lieutenant, Gary Leach. A bit of a different protocol than in cases with former management personnel who had been more hands on with it than had the captains.

But for a while, it put Wallace in the hot seat.





[Field Operations Capt. John Wallace took two months of review to recommend termination for the two patrol officers and a suspension for their supervising sergeant]




Wallace who spends much of his time in his office at Lincoln Field Operations Station remained in there even when Deputy Chief Jeffrey Greer recently attended several roll call sessions without him. He rose up quickly through the ranks mostly through interior assignments becoming a captain before the age of 40 and had a flair and talent for writing which led him towards drafting quite a bit of the original Strategic Plan. He had also applied for the chief's position vacated by Russ Leach and had made the list of final candidates for interview. Apparently he had asked the police unions for their support of his candidacy but they demurred, perhaps because several of their members had their eye on another candidate in the finals.

But this captain who had tried out for the chief's spot ironically was left with a very important decision to make which was to issue a recommendation for the officers involved in the case. Not an enviable task to put it lightly given that it had taken so long for the process to even get that far. That put him from the start in a position that wasn't very fair to be placed in.

It allegedly took him about two months to decide on what disciplinary action if any to recommend against the involved department employees and it was apparently a difficult process because upper management left it up to him to decide on what to recommend. And at the end of that period of contemplation, Wallace finally did.

For Glover and Bucy, he allegedly recommended that their employment be terminated. He went a little easier on the supervising sergeant who received a recommendation of a suspension which was between 1-2 work weeks. If that's the case in terms of what was recommended as discipline for the involved parties, it raises an immediate question as to why the supervising sergeant would be receiving lessor discipline than the officers under his watch. Isn't it to be the other way around, because the department has preached that accountability increases with movement up the chain of command. But then you have to look at the Leach incident for guidance where the lieutenant wound up being the only party involved who at one time faced a loss of income being factored into his eventual pension, with the demotion that never came to be. After all, if that's how the management at City Hall issues out discipline, the department after all, is underneath that same management.

Still, it appears a bit odd, the fact that the involved officers faced a loss of employment while their supervisor (who's still on duty) received a recommendation of lessor disciplinary action. The recommendations allegedly made appear to go against the mission statement of the police department in that accountability for actions and misconduct increase the higher up the structural hierarchy that you go. If a supervisor supervises officers who commit behavior that is deemed by a captain to deserve termination and then gets a recommendation for lighter discipline, what does that mean exactly?

But anyway, at about the 14th month, the investigative packet wound up on the desk of Asst. Chief Chris Vicino for its next stage of handling.






[On Asst. Chief Chris Vicino's desk sits the package involving the involved officers and supervisor]



Vicino has to review an investigation that took 14 months to reach his desk, two months outside of the statutory limitation for disciplining officers which recommended termination for two patrol officers and there had been an inverse correlation between the severity of recommended disciplinary action and the ascension in rank of those involved. It puts Vicino in a difficult position of whether or not to accept or reject the recommendations for disciplinary action, one of the first critical and very involved decisions he has made since his arrival involving an investigation that had put the department in the position of potentially violating the state's peace officer bill of rights and 3304(d) unless the department can come up with an exemption. But Vicino has experience as an interim chief in Pasadena Police Department and has been a force out on the trail of the solicitation of input from different corners for the department's upcoming strategic plan so the task that has been assigned to him is certainly within his scope. Diaz himself comes from a police department where the chief had different and somewhat more limited powers of disciplinary action than is the case in Riverside's department. Does he view the issue similar to what happened back at his haunt or as it is in Riverside? Diaz has had his missteps since becoming chief but he's had his visionary moments too. But what defines a chief ultimately are the bigger tests that he or she faces and this is one of them.

What decision Vicino and possibly Diaz make remains to be seen on the investigation process that dragged on past its year. It's not likely that the officers will be fired, especially given that Diaz attended an award ceremony for one of them but will they be given lesser disciplinary action in hopes they won't contest it in arbitration? If the officers were terminated, they have nothing to lose and perhaps everything to gain by taking their case to arbitration where likely it would get tossed given the high rate of discipline overturned during this civilian process. But in the meantime, they face economic hardships that come along with the waiting game for a case to reach, to be presented and decided upon by an outside arbitrator.

Still it raises questions and revisits concerns that have been raised about the investigation and review process of complaints by the police department which has been a dilemma in the past five years. The situation has been raised as a "what if", in what would the department or city do if the ultimate discipline was recommended after the statuory of limitations had passed? Well, in this case it might have happened and is no longer a hypothetical.

Running the clock and playing fumble the ball with such an important process violates so many individuals rights. The complainant doesn't benefit if an allegation is sustained against an officer who then can't be legally disciplined. The officers don't really benefit either from having cases drag out so long either. Their lives are put in hold without any resolution in sight. But is the police department able to resolve its ongoing issues with complaints that average 200 days or more to reach the CPRC? The attempts made so far including having two lieutenants in the division at one time haven't produced long-term results and it's ironic that once again the complaint system has been compromised in its effectiveness not too long after then State Attorney General Bill Lockyer alleged that it was in violation of the state's penal code, necessitating rewriting and reform.

It remains a challenge for Diaz and Vicino, for newly anointed CPRC manager, Frank Hauptmann, for the commission itself, for complainants, for officers like Bucy and Glover and those who represent them. For those who investigate and review complaints including City Hall. But what will be shown here by the ultimate outcome is what kind of decision making has been brought into the police department, and the difference between what's management and what's leadership. Something that's been lacking in this investigation for too long. If people's careers and lives are at stake including officers, they and their process deserve much better than this as do the individuals who file complaints.

What's really needed at this point is serious dialogue among the different players including those in management, supervision, the police bargaining units and the CPRC about what this process is going to be. Because even if this investigation were the only one to experience serious problems, that won't be for long. The intelligence and commitment to improving the police department in the wake of the problems which gripped it are certainly there inside the department, but what is most important is the will to address this situation which has placed doubt in the complaint investigation and review process which needs to be removed. Everyone involved in this tangled mess of a process deserves at least that especially when the decisions made have a profound impact on people's lives and livelihoods.

It's awesome when leaders of departments appear when their employees are being recognized for heroic deeds but it's more important to make sure that the processes that these employees are involved in are what they need to be, to be fair and just for all parties. A process that doesn't realize that isn't ultimately worth very much in the end and inevitably serves as the definer of the leadership and the department itself.

And it seems that there needs to be much more work done on that process. The minds are there to do it, but will they be up to it, is the question.




The Press Enterprise Editorial Board weighs in on the proposed banning of most mobile food trucks. Too bad, it would bring a lot of people to the nearly dead downtown.






Public Meetings



Tuesday, Jan. 25 at 3 and 6:30 p.m., The Riverside City Council will be meeting to discuss this agenda including its plans to do some resolution over Governor Jerry Brown's proposed shutdown of redevelopment agencies.


Also in closed session, the federal lawsuit filed by former Riverside Police Department Officer Jose Nazario comes up for an update.


Wednesday, Jan. 26 at 5:30 p.m. The Community Police Review Commission meets in the city council chambers to discuss this agenda. It will be the first meeting where newly hired manager, Frank Hauptmann will appear.




Public Reception


Tuesday, Feb. 1 at 5:30 p.m. City Hall will finally be holding a welcoming reception for newly hired CPRC manager, Frank Hauptmann in the Mayoral Ceremonial Room about a month after he actually started his employment.








Labels: ,

Newer›  ‹Older